Speargrass Holdings Limited v Van Brandenburg

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA296/2018
 [2019] NZCA 684

BETWEEN

SPEARGRASS HOLDINGS LIMITED
First Appellant

CHRISTOPHER SCOTT MEEHAN AND MICHAELA WARD MEEHAN
Second Appellants

AND

FREDERIKUS PETRUS MARIA VAN BRANDENBURG AND DIANNE MARY JACQUELINE VAN BRANDENBURG
First Respondents


QUEENSTOWN LAKES DISTRICT COUNCIL
Second Respondent

Court:

Cooper and Gilbert JJ

Counsel:

R A Rose for First and Second Appellants
P J Page for First Respondents

Judgment:
(On the papers)

20 December 2019 at 10.30 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

The applications for a stay of execution and other interim orders are declined.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Cooper J)

Introduction

  1. On 18 November 2019, this Court dismissed the appellants’ appeal against a decision of Dunningham J.[1]  The appellants now seek a stay and/or interim relief pending an application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court.  This application is opposed by the first respondents.

  2. The underlying dispute concerns the construction of an earth mound on the first respondents’ property in the Wakatipu Basin.  Judge Jackson in the Environment Court granted a variation to the earthworks consent required for the mound.[2]  The appellants, who own property adjacent to the first respondents’ land, appealed that decision to the High Court.  In addition, they applied for judicial review of the second respondent’s decision not to notify a resource consent application for the construction of the mound, and for an order under s 333 of the Property Law Act 2007 (the PLA) requiring removal of the mound.[3]  These “three discrete proceedings” were heard together.[4] 

    [2]Flax Trust v Queenstown Lakes District Council [2016] NZEnvC 202 at [178].

    [3]Speargrass Holdings Ltd v Queenstown Lakes District Council [2018] NZHC 1009 at [4]. The volume and area of the mound as built exceeded the mound that was originally granted consent by the second respondent. The larger mound was the subject of a further consent application (essentially an application to vary a condition of the original consent), rejected by the second respondent but then allowed by the Environment Court on appeal.

    [4]At [5].

  3. In relation to the appeal from the Environment Court’s decision, Dunningham J decided that the Environment Court Judge erred in several material ways.[5]  Consequently, that appeal was allowed, and the Environment Court’s decision granting a variation of the resource consent was set aside.[6]  In relation to the judicial review application, the Judge held that the second respondent had erred in making the non‑notification decision,[7] but declined relief both in respect of that application and the PLA application.[8] 

    [5]At [115].

    [6]At [116].

    [7]At [172].

    [8]At [274]–[275].

  4. The appellants appealed from the decision of the High Court in respect of the judicial review and PLA proceedings.  The decision on the appeal from the Environment Court decision was not appealed to this Court. 

The stay application

  1. The appellants seek a stay and/or interim orders, “preventing/halting any further progression of all outstanding aspects of the Environment Court…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Speargrass Holdings Limited v Van Brandenburg and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NZCA 684
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Speargrass Holdings Limited and Christopher Scott Meehan and Michaela Ward Meehan appealed against a decision of the High Court that upheld a decision of the Environment Court to grant a variation to an earthworks consent. The first respondents, Frederiku Petrus Maria van Brandenburg and Dianne Mary Jacqueline van Brandenburg, opposed the appeal. The appellants sought a stay of the Environment Court’s reconsideration of the consent variation and other interim orders pending an application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal from the High Court but the appellants sought a stay pending the outcome of a Supreme Court appeal. The first respondents opposed the stay application on the basis that the Court of Appeal had no jurisdiction to grant the relief sought.

The Court of Appeal found that the appeal to the Court had not included the decision of the Environment Court. The Court further found that the appellants could not rely on Rule 30 of the Supreme Court Rules to support the grant of a stay as the appeal was not to the Supreme Court. The Court found that the stay would prevent the Environment Court from lawfully commencing a hearing on the reconsideration of the consent variation. The Court held that the proper course for the appellants would have been to seek an adjournment of the reconsideration hearing from the Environment Court or an application for review from the High Court. The Court declined the application for a stay of execution and other interim orders.

Background

Background to the litigation

The underlying dispute concerns the construction of an earth mound on the first respondents' property in the Wakatipu Basin. The appellants, who own property adjacent to the first respondents' land, sought a variation to the earthworks consent required for the mound. Judge Jackson in the Environment Court granted the variation. The appellants appealed this decision to the High Court. In addition, they applied for judicial review of the second respondent's decision not to notify a resource consent application for the construction of the mound, and for an order under s 333 of the Property Law Act 2007 requiring removal of the mound. The volume and area of the mound as built exceeded the mound that was originally granted consent by the second respondent. The larger mound was the subject of a further consent application, which was rejected by the second respondent but then allowed by the Environment Court on appeal.

The appellants appealed the decision of the Environment Court to the High Court, which allowed the appeal and set aside the Environment Court's decision. The appellants then appealed from the decision of the High Court in respect of the judicial review and Property Law Act proceedings to the Court of Appeal. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal on 18 November 2019. The appellants now seek a stay and/or interim relief pending an application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court. This application is opposed by the first respondents.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the Court of Appeal have jurisdiction to grant the stay and/or interim relief sought by the appellants?
2. If the Court of Appeal does have jurisdiction, should the stay and/or interim relief be granted?

Held
1. The Court of Appeal does not have jurisdiction to grant the stay and/or interim relief sought by the appellants.
2. Even if the Court of Appeal had jurisdiction, the stay and/or interim relief would not be granted.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal began by noting that the appellants sought a stay and/or interim relief pending an application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court, which had already been filed. The Court reviewed the grounds upon which the appellants sought the stay, relying on Rule 30 of the Supreme Court Rules 2004. The Court considered whether the appellants' proposed appeal would be rendered nugatory if the orders were not granted, but concluded that the appeal would not be affected by any further proceedings in the Environment Court. The Court observed that the proceedings relating to the Environment Court’s decision were not before the Court of Appeal as the High Court’s decision setting aside that decision was not appealed. Therefore, the Court of Appeal did not have jurisdiction to grant the relief sought. Additionally, the Court noted the motives behind the stay application, which appeared to be to delay the proceedings until after the retirement of a particular judge. The Court also considered whether it was appropriate for Judge Jackson, who made the decision that was set aside on appeal to the High Court, to rehear the matter. The Court ultimately declined the applications for a stay of execution and other interim orders, finding that the appellants' proposed course of action was not the appropriate one. The Court suggested that the appellants should have applied for an adjournment of the proceedings in the Environment Court or approached the High Court in its supervisory jurisdiction for review if the Environment Court refused an adjournment. The Court's decision was based on preserving its appellate role and ensuring that the proper legal procedures were followed.