Southland Building Society v Nicholas

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND TAURANGA REGISTRY

CIV-2014-470-152 [2015] NZHC 1141

BETWEEN

SOUTHLAND BUILDING SOCIETY

Plaintiff

AND

PATRICK LYALL NICHOLAS Defendant

Hearing: 26 May 2015 at 10:00am

Appearances:

N Elsmore for the Plaintiff
P L Nicholas, Defendant in person

Judgment:

26 May 2015

ORAL JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE R M BELL

Solicitors:

Preston Russell Law (Sarah N McKenzie) Invercargill, for Plaintiff

Holland Beckett (Mark Beech) Tauranga, (previous solicitors for Defendant)

Copy for:

G C McArthur, Barrister, Tauranga

SOUTHLAND BUILDING SOCIETY v PATRICK LYALL NICHOLAS [2015] NZHC 1141 [26 May 2015]

The claim

[1]      The  Southland  Building  Society  sues  Mr  Nicholas  as  guarantor  for  the shortfall it suffered when it sold properties over which it had a mortgage.   The Building Society has applied for summary judgment against Mr Nicholas.

[2]      At the early stages of this proceeding, Mr Nicholas had lawyers acting for him.   They have applied to be released from representing Mr Nicholas.   On his behalf they applied for legal aid but the application was unsuccessful. At the start of the hearing I granted leave to the lawyers to withdraw.  Mr Nicholas has appeared in his own right.   Before the hearing, a notice of opposition was filed on behalf of Mr Nicholas and he swore affidavits in opposition.  He also spoke in opposition to the application.  Mr Nicholas has opposed the summary judgment application on the ground that under s 176 of the Property Law Act 2007, the building society did not take reasonable care to obtain the best price reasonably obtainable at the date of sale.

Summary judgment principles

[3]      The principles that apply on a summary judgment application are these:1

[a]       The question is whether the defendant has no defence to the claim;

that is, that there is no real question to be tried.

[b]      The onus is on the plaintiff, but if the plaintiff’s evidence is sufficient to show that there is no defence, the defendant will have to respond if the application is to be defeated.

[c]      The court will not normally resolve material conflicts of evidence or assess the credibility of deponents, but it need not accept uncritically

evidence that is inherent lacking in credibility.

1 Krukziener v Hanover Finance Ltd [2005] NZCA 187, (2008) 19 PRNZ at [26].

[d]      At the end of the day, the court’s assessment of the evidence is a matter of judgment and the court is entitled to take a robust view and a realistic approach when the facts warrant it.

The facts

[4]      Mr Nicholas is sued as guarantor of a company, YY Ltd, of which he is director.    He  signed  a  deed  of  guarantee  in  favour  of  the  building  society  on

23 September  2014.    As  is  typical  of  guarantees  for  financial  institutions,  the guarantee is comprehensive.  There are ample provisions directed at protecting the position of the building society as much as possible.  It is not disputed that the debts the subject of the building society’s claim are within the guarantee.

[5]      The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Southland Building Society v Nicholas and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 1141
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Southland Building Society brought a claim against Patrick Lyall Nicholas, who was sued as a guarantor for a company that had defaulted on its loan obligations. The building society sought summary judgment to recover the shortfall it suffered when it sold properties over which it held a mortgage. The court was required to decide whether the building society had taken reasonable care to obtain the best price reasonably obtainable at the date of sale, as required by section 176 of the Property Law Act 2007. The court also had to determine whether the building society's evidence regarding the marketing and sale of the properties was admissible.

The court found that the building society had not provided admissible evidence to demonstrate that it had taken reasonable care to obtain the best price reasonably obtainable at the date of sale. The court held that the hearsay evidence provided by the building society was inadmissible under the Evidence Act 2006, as the building society had failed to satisfy the requirements of sections 18 and 19. Consequently, the court could not take that evidence into account when deciding whether the building society had complied with its duty under section 176 of the Property Law Act. As a result, the court was unable to make an order for summary judgment in favour of the building society and dismissed the application.

The court reserved costs and directed a telephone conference to be held on 22 July 2015 at 2:15 pm. The building society was asked to file and serve a memorandum for the conference five working days beforehand, and Mr Nicholas was asked to file a memorandum for the conference two working days beforehand. The court noted that Mr Nicholas had arranged legal representation since the judgment was delivered.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.