Soroka v Stephen Elliott Investments Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NELSON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA WHAKATŪ ROHE

CIV-2020-442-12

[2020] NZHC 2244

UNDER s 124 of the District Courts Act 2016

IN THE MATTER

of an appeal against a decision of the District Court at Nelson

BETWEEN

DARREN JOHN SOROKA

Appellant

AND

STEPHEN ELLIOTT INVESTMENTS LIMITED

Respondent

Hearing: 30 July 2020 (AVL)

Counsel:

Y E Clarisse for Appellant S Galbreath for Respondent

Judgment:

31 August 2020


JUDGMENT OF SIMON FRANCE J


[1]    Mr Soroka appeals a decision of the District Court granting a summary judgment application by Stephen Elliott Investments Ltd (SEIL).1 The company was a guarantor of a borrowing by another company, Sportsmall. Mr Soroka was also a guarantor. SEIL paid off the debt and sought contribution from Mr Soroka. The District Court awarded SEIL summary judgment on Mr Soroka’s liability to contribute. It declined to give judgment on the quantum but sent that issue to trial. SEIL cross appeals the decision on quantum.


1      Stephen Elliott Investments Ltd v Soroka [2020] NZDC 2198. The appeal is brought under the District Court Act 2016, ss 124 and 127.

SOROKA v STEPHEN ELLIOTT INVESTMENTS LTD [2020] NZHC 2244 [31 August 2020]

Facts

[2]    Mr Soroka and Mr Elliott were equal shareholders in, and directors of, Sportsmall. In 2010 Sportsmall sought a loan of $100,000 from a bank. It was approved on the basis that Mr Soroka, Mr Elliott and a company of Mr Elliott, SEIL, all guaranteed the loan on a joint and several basis. Further, SEIL provided a property it owned as security.

[3]    SEIL is owned 49 per cent each by Mr Elliott and his wife. The remaining two per cent is held in their son’s name. Mr and Mrs Elliott are the directors. In 2014 SEIL decided to sell the property that was the security for the loan. Mr Soroka was not aware of this. SEIL obviously needed a discharge of the mortgage that was securing Sportsmall’s loan. SEIL paid the bank $94,775.86 on 31 October 2014 to secure a discharge of the mortgage.

[4]    Mr Elliott and Mr Soroka agreed that Sportsmall would repay SEIL over time. The agreement was reflected in Sportsmall’s records by Mr Elliott’s personal shareholder account being credited with the repayment amount. That was the only step taken at the time, although subsequently there were obviously movements in the status of Mr Elliott’s shareholder account.

[5]    Two and a half years later, in May 2017, Sportsmall ceased trading and on  Mr Elliott’s application, liquidators were appointed on 26 July 2018. There were insufficient funds to pay unsecured creditors, meaning Mr Elliott received no payment in relation to his shareholder account.

[6]    SEIL issued proceedings claiming an equitable contribution from Mr Soroka as co-guarantor of the payment it made in 2014.

Decision under appeal

[7]    The Judge first noted the summary judgment principles governing the application.2 The onus is on the plaintiff seeking summary judgment to show that there is no arguable defence. The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Soroka v Stephen Elliott Investments Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NZHC 2244
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand, Nelson Registry, heard an appeal by Darren John Soroka against a decision of the District Court which granted a summary judgment application by Stephen Elliott Investments Limited (SEIL). The District Court had awarded SEIL summary judgment on Soroka's liability to contribute as a co-guarantor for a debt paid off by SEIL, but declined to give judgment on the quantum of the contribution, sending that issue to trial. SEIL cross-appealed the decision on quantum. The case involved an appeal under section 124 of the District Court Act 2016. Soroka and Elliott were equal shareholders and directors of Sportsmall, which had taken out a loan guaranteed by both Soroka and SEIL. When Sportsmall ceased trading, SEIL sought equitable contribution from Soroka for the amount it had paid to the bank to secure a discharge of the mortgage on Sportsmall's property.

The legal issues before the court were whether Soroka had an arguable defence that he was not liable to make a contribution to SEIL and whether Soroka had an arguable defence as to the correctness of the amount of the claim. The District Court had assessed that SEIL's payment was voluntary, but that Soroka was liable to contribute as a principal debtor under the loan agreement. The court had also considered the possibility of a new agreement governing the situation in 2014, but ultimately found that the equitable right of contribution could not be derailed by SEIL's conduct. The court granted summary judgment on liability, but not quantum. The High Court found that the District Court's analysis was flawed and that there were genuine issues of fact and law that should have been decided at a trial. The court allowed the appeal, quashed the order for summary judgment on liability, and awarded costs on the appeal. The cross-appeal on quantum was not dealt with as it was not necessary.

In conclusion, the High Court found that the District Court had erred in granting summary judgment on liability and that the case should proceed to trial. The court found that there were genuine issues of fact and law that needed to be resolved, particularly in relation to the events of 2014 and the agreement between Soroka and Elliott. The court awarded costs on the appeal, with costs in the District Court to be reserved for determination as part of costs on the trial.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established