Solomon-Rehe v Hokotehi Moriori Trust

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV 2014-485-10740 [2016] NZHC 239

UNDER

the Trustee Act 1956 and the Charitable

Trusts Act 1957

IN THE MATTER OF

an application to remove trustees and direct fresh elections

BETWEEN

CHARLES LOUIS SOLOMON-REHE, ERIC THOMAS SOLOMON, ROSALIE MARY ANDERSON, ELAINE GOOMES, JULIA ANNE SCRIMGEOUR, ALFRED HENRY RETIMANA, THOMAS HENRY

LANAUZE, MARGARET JUNE SWAIN, AARON GRAEME DONALDSON, JAMES ALEXANDER EUGENE MATENGA

Plaintiffs

AND

HOKOTEHI MORIORI TRUST First Defendant

AND

SHIRLEY JOYCE KING Second Defendant

AND

AMANDA JUANITA KING Third Defendant

AND

BRIAN JAMES SOLOMON Fourth Defendant

AND

DENNIS GRAEME SOLOMON Fifth Defendant

AND

LINDA-MAE SARAH ENTWISTLE Sixth Defendant

Hearing: On Papers

Counsel:

P B Churchman QC and T H Bennion for plaintiffs

J P Ferguson and H K Irwin-Easthope for second to sixth defendants

C Linkhorn and H Carrad for Attorney-General

R Schmidt-McCleave and S Karipa for Te Ohu Kai Moana

SOLOMON-REHE & ORS v HOKOTEHI MORIORI TRUST [2016] NZHC 239 [22 February 2016]

Trustee Limited

Judgment:

22 February 2016

COSTS JUDGMENT OF BROWN J

[1]      This judgment addresses claims for costs and requests for indemnification in respect of legal costs consequent upon my judgment in Solomon-Rehe v Hokotehi Moriori Trust.1

[2]      The litigation was the outcome of an impasse between the defendant trustees and other persons who had also been serving as trustees.  As the overview to my judgment stated:

[3]       The  current  state  of  trustee  dysfunction  is  recognised  by  the intervention of the Attorney-General.  In his role of protector of charities he seeks an immediate order for the removal of all those acting as trustees and the appointment of independent persons as interim trustees pending the holding of elections for new trustees.

[4]       The outcomes sought by the plaintiffs and the defendant trustees reflect their inevitably partisan approaches.  The plaintiffs apply to have the defendant trustees removed immediately on the grounds of their alleged unlawful and obstructive actions while seeking an order that Messrs Donaldson, Matenga and Lanauze should remain in place pending trustee elections.   The defendant trustees take the position that all eight trustees should remain as interim trustees to work alongside any court-appointed trustees pending fresh elections.  Their alternative position is that all eight trustees should be removed.

The outcome of the litigation

[3]      In my judgment I made orders removing all the trustees and appointing two interim trustees who were directed to arrange an AGM on proposed amendments to the 2005 Trust Deed and to organise an election for vacant trustee positions.  Those

orders followed from my findings on the following six issues.

1      Solomon-Rehe v Hokotehi Moriori Trust [2015] NZHC 46, [2015] NZAR 776.

[4]      The first issue was whether (as the plaintiffs contended) the 2010 amendment to the 2005 Trust Deed was validly made?   That question was answered in the negative because the process stipulated in the deed – i.e. a Hui a Moriori with the requisite quorum – was not followed.

[5]      The second issue concerned the plaintiffs’ request that the Court…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Solomon-Rehe v Hokotehi Moriori Trust and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 239
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Solomon-Rehe v Hokotehi Moriori Trust, the plaintiffs sought removal of trustees and fresh elections, while the defendant trustees sought to maintain their positions. The High Court removed all trustees and appointed two interim trustees. The parties contested the costs of the litigation, with the plaintiffs seeking reimbursement and indemnification from the Trust, and the defendant trustees seeking indemnification from the Trust and no personal liability for costs. The plaintiffs argued that they brought the action to avoid catastrophic consequences and that the defendants’ insistence on an investigation before elections led to the adversarial nature of the litigation. The defendant trustees argued that both parties were unsuccessful and that they were entitled to indemnification under the Trust Deed. The Court found that both parties were unsuccessful and that neither should bear the costs of the litigation. The Court also found that none of the parties were entitled to indemnification from the Trust, as the plaintiffs who purported to hold office as trustees were found to have been invalidly holding that office. The Attorney-General did not seek costs, recognizing the need for the parties to work together in the future.

The Court's decision in Solomon-Rehe v Hokotehi Moriori Trust highlights the complex issues that can arise in trust litigation, particularly when there are disputes between trustees or between trustees and beneficiaries. The Court's approach to costs in this case reflects the need to balance the interests of the beneficiaries of the Trust with the need for the parties to work together in the future. The decision also underscores the importance of clear and unequivocal language in Trust Deeds to avoid disputes over interpretation and administration.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established