Solicitor-General v Miss Alice Ca168/06

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA168/06

BETWEENTHE SOLICITOR-GENERAL


Appellant

ANDMISS ALICE (PREVIOUSLY ROBERT ALEXANDER MOODIE)


Respondent

Hearing:5 September 2006

Court:Glazebrook, Chambers and Chisholm JJ

Counsel:C R Gwyn and T J Warburton for Crown


M Alice in Person

Judgment:25 October 2006 at 10 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is allowed and the order of the High Court preventing Mr Dobson QC and Mr Lithgow having any further role in the proceedings is set aside.

BCosts of $6,000 plus usual disbursements are awarded to the Solicitor‑General.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Glazebrook J)

Table of Contents

Para No

Introduction  [1]

Has there been a change in function for Mr Dobson and
         Mr Lithgow?
  [8]
Would Mr Dobson and Mr Lithgow have an undue advantage
         because of their previous role as amici?
  [20]
Was the special character of contempt proceedings given
         sufficient weight?
  [24]
Should Mr Lithgow have been allowed to continue acting?                  [25]
Should the Judge have allowed Mr Dobson and Mr Lithgow
         to brief new counsel?
  [26]
Other matters raised by Dr Alice  [27]
Result and costs  [28]

Introduction

[1]       During 1994 a beekeeper was killed when the bridge over which he was travelling collapsed.  The bridge was on the property of Mr and Mrs Berryman but had been built by the New Zealand Army.  In 2003 Mr and Mrs Berryman commenced judicial review proceedings challenging the decision of the Solicitor‑General not to order a further coronial inquest into the beekeeper’s death, the original inquest having largely attributed responsibility for the beekeeper’s death to Mr and Mrs Berryman.  Around August 2004, Dr Alice (then known as Dr Robert Moodie) was instructed to act for the Berrymans in those proceedings.

[2]       In September 2004, Dr Alice obtained access to documents held by the New Zealand Defence Force (NZDF) including a report, the “Butcher report”, originally prepared by the NZDF on the causes of the bridge collapse.  Provision of the documents arose out of a non‑party discovery process.  The documents were provided on conditions contained in a consent memorandum filed with the High Court in February 2004.  These conditions included a condition that the report not be admitted in evidence.  An attempt by the Berrymans to have the conditions lifted was ultimately unsuccessful in the High Court (see Berryman v Solicitor-General [2005] NZAR 512). As a result, the Berrymans discontinued their proceedings.

[3]       In early March 2005, Dr Alice released the Butcher report to Television New Zealand (TVNZ).  On 24 March 2005, the High Court ordered Dr Alice to return all NZDF documents, including the report.  In April, Dr Alice received a further copy of the report from another source and disseminated copies to the media, as well as posting it on the internet.

[4]       Mr Dobson QC was appointed by the High Court as amicus curiae to identify whether Dr Alice was in contempt of court in releasing the Butcher report.  On 31…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Solicitor-General v Miss Alice Ca168/06 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] NZCA 301
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Solicitor-General v Miss Alice concerns an appeal against an order preventing Mr. Dobson QC and Mr. Lithgow from acting for the Solicitor-General in contempt proceedings. The appeal was heard by Glazebrook, Chambers, and Chisholm JJ in the Court of Appeal of New Zealand on 5 September 2006. The Court allowed the appeal and set aside the order preventing Mr. Dobson QC and Mr. Lithgow from acting for the Solicitor-General. The Court awarded costs of $6,000 plus usual disbursements to the Solicitor-General.

The appeal raised several legal issues. Firstly, whether there had been a change in function for Mr. Dobson and Mr. Lithgow. Secondly, whether Mr. Dobson and Mr. Lithgow would have an undue advantage because of their previous role as amici. Thirdly, whether the special character of contempt proceedings and the role of the Solicitor-General were given sufficient weight. Fourthly, whether Mr. Lithgow should have been allowed to continue acting. Finally, whether the Judge should have allowed Mr. Dobson and Mr. Lithgow to brief new counsel.

The Court found that there had been no change in function for Mr. Dobson and Mr. Lithgow as their role was always to investigate the facts and, if warranted, prosecute the alleged contempt. The Court also found that Mr. Dobson and Mr. Lithgow would not have an undue advantage because of their previous role as amici, as a fully informed member of the public would understand that judges decide cases impartially on the merits and the law. The Court accepted that the special character of contempt proceedings and the role of the Solicitor-General as Law Officer representing the public interest provided an added reason why the order should not have been made. The Court did not need to deal with the issue of whether Mr. Lithgow should have been allowed to continue acting, given its conclusion that neither Mr. Dobson nor Mr. Lithgow should have been prevented from continuing to act. Finally, the Court considered that the Judge should have allowed Mr. Dobson and Mr. Lithgow to brief new counsel in order to minimise unnecessary expense and disruption to the process.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.