Smith v Trustees Executors Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2012-404-001155 [2013] NZHC 384

IN THE MATTER OF     the Bankruptcy of GERALD MURRAY SMITH

BETWEEN  GERALD MURRAY SMITH Judgment Debtor

ANDTRUSTEES EXECUTORS LIMITED Judgment Creditor

Hearing:         28 February 2013

Appearances: C R Pidgeon QC for Judgment Debtor

C A E Carey for Judgment Creditor

Judgment:      1 March 2013

JUDGMENT OF COURTNEY J

This judgment was delivered by Justice Courtney on 1 March 2013 at 4:00 pm

pursuant to R 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar / Deputy Registrar

Date……………………..

Solicitors:           Pidgeon Law, P O Box 6535 Wellesley Street, Auckland 1141

Fax: (09) 337-0827
JTLaw, P O Box 25443, Wellington 6140
Fax: (04) 901-0711 – C Carey – Email:charlotte@jtlaw.co.nz

Counsel:             C R Pidgeon QC, P O Box 105924, Auckland

Fax: (09) 308-2417 – Email: colpidge@xtra.co.nz

SMITH V TRUSTEES EXECUTORS LTD HC AK CIV-2012-404-001155 [1 March 2013]

[1]      Trustees Executors Ltd (TEL) has applied for an order adjudicating Gerald Murray Smith bankrupt.  It is common ground that TEL satisfies the prerequisites for adjudication in s 13 of the Insolvency Act 2006.   However, Mr Smith, who is 73 years old and has no assets, opposes the application and seeks to have this Court exercise its discretion to refuse adjudication on the grounds provided in s 37(c)[1] and

(d)[2].  Having heard from Mr Pidgeon QC, for Mr Smith, and Ms Carey, for TEL, I

refused TEL’s application for adjudication with my reasons to follow in writing.

These are my reasons.

[1] That it is just and equitable that an order not be made. 

[2] That for any other reason an order should not be made.

[2]      Although the making of an order for adjudication under s 13 is discretionary, when a judgment  creditor satisfies the prerequisites of s 13 the onus  is on the opposing debtor to show why an order should not be made.  The general principles upon which the discretion under s 37 are to be exercised were set out by Faire AJ in Fontein v Bank of New Zealand[3] and I gratefully borrow from his summary:

[3] Fontein v Bank of New Zealand HC Auckland CIV-2009-404-007769.

1)“A creditor who establishes the jurisdictional facts set out in s 23 is not automatically entitled to an order.  On the other hand, it is for an opposing  debtor  to  show  why  an  order  should  not  be  made.” McHardy v Wilkins & Davies Marinas Ltd (Court of Appeal, Wellington, CA54/93, 7 April) at p 3.

2)“… in the exercise of the discretion under s 26 it is proper for the Court to consider not only the interests of those directly concerned – the petitioner, other creditors, the debtor – but also the wider public interest.”  McHardy v Wilkins & Davies Marinas Ltd at p 3.

3)In determining whether an order should be made, the wider public interest   must   be   taken   into   account   to   determine   whether adjudication is “conducive or detrimental to commercial morality and the interests of the general public.”   Re Nisbett, ex parte Vala

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Smith v Trustees Executors Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 384
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Trustees Executors Limited (TEL) applied for an order adjudicating Gerald Murray Smith bankrupt. Mr Smith opposed the application, arguing that it was not just and equitable to make an order, and that the application should be refused for other reasons. The primary issue for the Court was whether, in exercising its discretion under section 37 of the Insolvency Act 2006, it should refuse to make an order for adjudication. The Court considered the relevant principles, including the general discretion to be exercised by the Court in bankruptcy petitions, the public interest, and the potential for further investigation. The Court also took into account the conduct of both parties and the effect that adjudication would have on the parties involved and more widely.

The Court found that TEL's conduct and attitude towards Mr Smith, including the alleged threat by an employee to "destroy" him, were unacceptable. The Court also found that TEL's application was brought in large part to punish Mr Smith for being difficult, rather than to serve any practical purpose for TEL or the commercial community. The Court found that adjudication would not improve TEL's position at all nor benefit the commercial community, as Mr Smith had no assets or income that might go towards reducing the outstanding amount, and there were no other creditors. The Court found that Mr Smith's insolvency had not come about through any failing on his part, and there was no suggestion of dishonesty or incompetence. The Court found that adjudication would prevent Mr Smith from contributing in a useful way to the industry in which he had worked all his life.

The Court refused TEL's application for adjudication, finding that it was not just and equitable to make an order, and that the application should be refused for other reasons. The Court found that TEL's previous conduct and doubtful motivation in bringing the application led to its decision to refuse the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established