Smith v Police

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CRI-2014-404-313 [2014] NZHC 2896

BETWEEN

MICHAEL SMITH

Appellant

AND

NEW ZEALAND POLICE Respondent

Hearing: 20 November 2014

Appearances:

S D Patel for Appellant
J Barry for Respondent

Judgment:

20 November 2014

(ORAL) JUDGMENT OF LANG J [on appeal against sentence]

SMITH, M v NEW ZEALAND POLICE [2014] NZHC 2896 [20 November 2014]

[1]      Mr  Smith  pleaded  guilty  in  the  District  Court  to  two  charges,  one  of breaching community work and one of breaching supervision.   The maximum sentence in respect of each charge was three months imprisonment.

[2]      On 11 September 2014, Judge Coyle sentenced Mr Smith to eight weeks imprisonment.1    Mr Smith appeals against that sentence on the basis that the Judge ought to have sentenced him to community detention.

[3]      I record that Mr Smith spent a week in custody before being released on bail pending determination of his appeal.  This means that he served approximately 25 per cent of the sentence the Judge imposed on him.

Background

[4]      Mr Smith was sentenced to 80 hours community work on 19 March 2012. He reported for the first time on 24 March 2012, and was inducted into the rules and requirements of community work.   He failed to  report for community work on several occasions during the period between March and June 2012.

[5]      On  22  June  2012,  the  Department  of  Corrections  cancelled  his  agency placement, and changed it to the Community Work Centre in New Lynn.  He was inducted at that Centre on 22 June 2012, and directed to report to that Centre every Tuesday until instructed otherwise.  Mr Smith then failed to report to the Community Work Centre three days later, on 25 June 2013.  After he failed to contact the Centre to explain his absence, numerous telephone calls and text messages failed to evoke any response. This led to the charge of breaching the sentence of community work.

[6]      On 8 November 2013, Mr Smith was sentenced to 12 months supervision after being convicted on the charge of breaching his community work.  A standard condition of that sentence was to report to a probation officer not later than 72 hours

after the sentence was imposed.  Mr Smith failed to report within this timeframe.

1      Department of Corrections v Smith DC Waitakere CRI-2013-090-005088, 22 September 2014.

[7]      On 18 November 2013, the Department of Corrections issued Mr Smith with a final warning for failing to report within 72 hours.  He was instructed to report on

21 November 2013 and was advised that if he did not do so, enforcement action would be taken. This failed to prompt Mr Smith to report as required.

[8]      On 27 November 2013, a probation officer delivered an instruction requiring Mr Smith to report on 28 November 2013.  Mr Smith failed to report on that date. This led to the charge of breaching the sentence of supervision.

Decision

[9]      Mr Patel advances a wide range of arguments in support of the appeal.  They are all…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Smith v Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 2896
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, the appellant, Michael Smith, appealed against his sentence of imprisonment for breaching community work and supervision. The maximum penalty for each charge was three months imprisonment. The appellant was employed as a glazier at the time of sentencing and his employment would be terminated if he were required to spend a month in prison. The appellant argued that the sentencing judge should have imposed a sentence of community detention instead of imprisonment. The court accepted that the evidence regarding the appellant’s employment was not before the sentencing judge, and it was material to the appropriate type of sentence. The court considered that a sentence of community detention was appropriate, but it needed to have a significant deterrent factor. The court accepted the concession that a sentence of six months community detention was appropriate, but it reduced the sentence by one month to reflect the fact that the appellant had already served one-quarter of the prison sentence that he received.

The court was required to decide whether the appellant’s sentence of imprisonment should be quashed and replaced with a sentence of community detention. The court considered that the appellant’s employment was material to the appropriate type of sentence, and it accepted that the evidence regarding the appellant’s employment was not before the sentencing judge. The court considered that a sentence of community detention was appropriate, but it needed to have a significant deterrent factor. The court accepted the concession that a sentence of six months community detention was appropriate, but it reduced the sentence by one month to reflect the fact that the appellant had already served one-quarter of the prison sentence that he received.

The court held that the appeal was allowed. The sentences of imprisonment were quashed. In their place, the appellant was sentenced to five months community detention on each charge to be served concurrently and subject to certain conditions. The sentence would commence as soon as the appellant was inducted into the electronic monitoring programme. The appellant was also required to attend an assessment for alcohol and drug counselling as directed by his probation officer, and to attend and complete any counselling treatment or programme as may be directed by, and to the satisfaction of, his probation officer.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established