Smith v Noble Investments Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2014-409-000549 [2015] NZHC 3006

BETWEEN

GREGORY ROBERT SMITH AND

COLIN PETER STOKES Plaintiffs and First Counterclaim Defendants

AND

NOBLE INVESTMENTS LIMITED
First Defendant and Counterclaim Plaintiff

APPLE FIELDS LIMITED
Second Defendant and Counterclaim
Plaintiff

JUSTIN WILLIAM PRAIN Third Defendant

CARDNO (NZ) LIMITED Fourth Defendant

SHAYNE PHILPOTT, NEW ZEALAND TRUSTEE SERVICES LIMITED,

FAY EUNICE RICHARDSON, AND BURNSIDE TRUSTEES LIMITED Second Counterclaim Defendants

STUART ELLESMERE LINDSAY AND JULIE IVONNE LINDSAY

Third Counterclaim Defendants

Hearing: 21 August 2015

Appearances:

S Caradus for Plaintiffs Smith and Stokes
P B McMenamin for First, Second and Third Defendants
G J Ryan for Second Counterclaim Defendants
A C Hughes-Johnson QC for Third Counterclaim Defendants

Judgment:

30 November 2015

JUDGMENT OF GENDALL J

SMITH v NOBLE INVESTMENTS LIMITED [2015] NZHC 3006 [30 November 2015]

Introduction

[1]      The  plaintiffs  in  this  litigation,  Gregory  Robert  Smith  (Mr  Smith)  and Colin Peter Stokes (Mr Stokes) claim against the first defendant, Noble Investments Limited (Noble) for breach of a contract dated 17 May 2002 relating to the purchase by Mr Smith and Mr Stokes of land in a subdivision to be completed by Noble.  The present  substantive  claim  is  against  both  Noble  and   the  second   defendant Apple Fields Limited (Apple Fields), the company used by Noble to manage the development of this particular subdivision.   Essentially it is a claim for breach of contract and misrepresentation.  Further, Mr Smith and Mr Stokes claim that they are the victims of deceit perpetrated by the director of Apple Fields, the third defendant Justin William Prain (Mr Prain), and the fourth defendant, Cardno (NZ) Limited (a company engaged by Noble to acquire the requisite consents and assist in planning the subdivision in question).

[2]      Noble and Apple Fields in turn have counterclaimed against Mr Smith and Mr Stokes alleging breach of the 17 May 2002 sale and purchase contract (the ASP). Specifically, Noble and Apple Fields contend that Mr Smith and Mr Stokes have contravened their obligations under the ASP by refusing to surrender certain caveats lodged against the land contained in the subdivision.

[3]      Noble and Apple Fields as counterclaimants further contend that this refusal by Mr Smith and Mr Stokes to surrender their caveats has delayed the entire development of the land and has ultimately caused this commercial undertaking to stagnate.  They therefore claim damages and seek an order for specific performance requiring Mr Smith and Mr Stokes as counterclaim defendants to surrender their caveats.

[4]      Noble and Apple Fields have also named third parties against whom they wish to pursue their counterclaim.  These are the second counterclaim defendants, Shayne Philpott, New Zealand Trustee Services Limited, Fay Eunice Richardson and Burnside Trustees Limited (the Philpott Interests) and the third counterclaim defendants, Stuart Ellesmere Lindsay and Julie Ivonne Lindsay (the Lindsays).

The security for costs application

[5]      The  matter  of  immediate  concern  before  me  is  an  application  by  all counterclaim defendants for security for costs against Noble and Apple Fields with respect to their counterclaim.  The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Smith v Noble Investments Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 3006
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, Gregory Robert Smith and Colin Peter Stokes, as plaintiffs, brought a claim against Noble Investments Limited and Apple Fields Limited for breach of contract and misrepresentation relating to the purchase of land. Noble and Apple Fields counterclaimed against the plaintiffs for breach of the sale and purchase contract, specifically for the refusal to surrender certain caveats lodged against the land. The counterclaim also named third parties, Shayne Philpott, New Zealand Trustee Services Limited, Fay Eunice Richardson, Burnside Trustees Limited, Stuart Ellesmere Lindsay, and Julie Ivonne Lindsay, who were counterclaim defendants. The matter of immediate concern was an application by the counterclaim defendants for security for costs against Noble and Apple Fields.

The court examined whether Noble and Apple Fields were impecunious and if their inability to provide security for costs was caused by the actions of the counterclaim defendants. The court noted that Noble and Apple Fields were currently encountering financial difficulty and that their inability to access sufficient equity in the land to provide security for costs was, at least in part, due to the counterclaim defendants' caveats. However, the court also noted that the counterclaim would determine whether the caveats should continue to subsist.

The court considered the merit of the counterclaim, the nature of the counterclaim, and the potential for denial of justice. The court found that the counterclaim was relevant to the main claim, and therefore, ordering security for costs against the plaintiffs would likely result in Noble and Apple Fields withdrawing the counterclaim. The court also found that there was a real argument that the impecuniosity of Noble and Apple Fields had been caused by the third-party counterclaim defendants in lodging and maintaining their caveats.

In balancing the interests of the parties, the court concluded that the proper balancing of the interests fell on the side of the counterclaim plaintiffs, Noble and Apple Fields. The court dismissed the applications for security for costs brought by all the counterclaim defendants.

In conclusion, the court found that the counterclaim plaintiffs, Noble and Apple Fields, were entitled to one award of costs in their successful opposition to the present applications. The court urged the parties to consider mediation or a similar process to resolve all issues and bring an end to the ongoing disputes.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.