Smith v Hills

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND HAMILTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA KIRIKIRIROA ROHE

CIV-2020-419-000020

[2020] NZHC 2293

IN THE MATTER OF The estate of DAVID BRUCE SMITH

BETWEEN

WARREN PETER SMITH

Plaintiff

AND

BARBARA JOY HILLS and BRADLEY

JOSEPH HILLS, as executors in the estate of DAVID BRUCE SMITH

Defendants

Hearing: 25 August 2020

Appearances:

Plaintiff in Person

M Brady and C R Lunt for Defendants

Judgment:

4 September 2020


JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE P J ANDREW


This judgment was delivered by Associate Judge Andrew on 4 September 2020 at 11.00 am

pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules Registrar / Deputy Registrar

Date………………………

SMITH v HILLS [2020] NZHC 2293 [4 September 2020]

Introduction

[1]    This is the third set of High Court proceedings relating to the estate of the deceased, Mr David Bruce Smith (Mr Bruce Smith).

[2]    The plaintiff, Mr Warren Smith, is the son of Mr Bruce Smith. The defendant, Ms Barbara Joy Hills, is Mr Bruce Smith’s daughter and the defendant, Mr Bradley Hills, is Mr Bruce Smith’s grandson. The defendants are the executors appointed under the Will for Mr Bruce Smith’s estate.

[3]    In the present interlocutory application, the defendants seek to strike out the whole of the plaintiff’s statement of claim dated 6 December 2019. The defendants claim that the proceedings are an abuse of process, the causes of action are not reasonably arguable and are unintelligible, and that the deficiencies will not be remedied by amending the statement of claim.

Background facts

[4]    The deceased’s wife, namely the mother of the plaintiff and Ms Barbara Hills, and the grandmother of the defendant, Mr Bradley Hills, died in November 2000. She left a life interest in her half-share of 1 Thompson Street, Hamilton, to her husband, Mr Bruce Smith.

[5]    The plaintiff, Mr Warren Smith, subsequently challenged his mother’s Will under the Family Protection Act 1955. There was a settlement of those proceedings and the property at 1 Thomson Street was transferred into various ownership interests. Mr Warren Smith was awarded 1/14th share under the settlement and Ms Barbara Hills a 1/7th share. The Deed of Settlement is dated 7 June 2002.

[6]    In accordance with his life interest,  Mr Bruce  Smith continued living in      1 Thomson Street until 26 June 2016, when he moved into a rest home.

[7]    In May 2005, Mr Bruce Smith entered into  a mortgage with his daughter,  Ms Anne Roach, secured against the Thomson Street property, and for the principal sum of $32,000, together with interest at the rate of eight per cent per annum. Whether

there was an entitlement to impose an additional three per cent per annum as penalty interest is at issue.

[8]    On 3 November 2016, a residential tenancy agreement was entered into between Mr Bruce Smith and his grandson, the defendant, Mr Bradley Hills, and Bradley’s then partner, Lynda, now his wife.

[9]    The final Will of Mr Bruce Smith is dated 19 May 2017. It replaced…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Smith v Hills and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NZHC 2293
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Smith v Hills, the plaintiff, Mr Warren Smith, challenged the executors of his father’s estate, Mr David Bruce Smith, alleging that they failed to provide an accurate inventory of the estate and that they should compensate for the shortfall. The defendants, Ms Barbara Joy Hills and Mr Bradley Joseph Hills, sought to have the plaintiff’s claims struck out, arguing that the claims were frivolous, vexatious, and not reasonably arguable.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the plaintiff's claims could be struck out under rule 15.1 of the High Court Rules 2016. The court considered the plaintiff’s claims that the executors wrongfully paid penalty interest on a mortgage, that they allowed the rental of a family property at an unreasonably low rate, and that they should reimburse him for a motor vehicle he had gifted to his father. The court had to determine if these claims were legally tenable and if they could succeed.

The court concluded that the claims were not reasonably arguable and, therefore, should be struck out. Regarding the mortgage, the court found that there was a clear contractual entitlement to penalty interest, which had already been settled. The rental agreement was part of informal family arrangements and did not support the plaintiff’s claims of fraud or underpayment. Concerning the motor vehicle, the court held that the promise made in an earlier will was removed in 2002, and it was unlikely the vehicle was of significant value at the time of the father’s death. The court also noted that the executors had already provided comprehensive information about the estate’s assets and liabilities.

The court granted the application to strike out the proceedings, finding that the claims were not reasonably capable of success and that the pleadings could not be amended to disclose tenable causes of action. The court reserved costs, allowing the defendants to file written submissions on costs within 14 days, after which the plaintiff would have an opportunity to respond.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.