| IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND | CA292/99 |
| BETWEEN | BRYAN HISLOP SMITH |
| Appellant |
| AND | THE CHRISTCHURCH PRESS COMPANY LIMITED |
| Respondent |
| Hearing: | 18 October 2000 |
| Coram: | Gault J Thomas J Keith J |
| Appearances: | A A Couch for Appellant C H Toogood QC and A M Toohey for Respondent |
| Judgment: | 21 November 2000 |
| JUDGMENT OF THE COURT DELIVERED BY GAULT J |
This is an appeal against a judgment of the Employment Court (Judge Shaw) dismissing the appellant's claim against The Christchurch Press Co Ltd (The Press), his employer, for wrongful dismissal; Smith v Christchurch Co Ltd [1999] 2 ERNZ 685.
The dismissal arose out of an incident between the appellant and a co-worker (S) during a lunch break one working day. According to the Judge's findings, the appellant approached S just before lunch and suggested they have lunch together. They knew each other through work functions. The appellant commented on S's neck, as she was wearing a neck brace. S considered the appellant to be compassionate and agreed to have lunch with him. The appellant drove home and got some sandwiches and then met S in his car. He then drove her back to his house, though S did not realise where they were going until they arrived. The appellant brought out the sandwiches and some alcohol. It was cold in the dining room so the appellant suggested they shift into his bedroom. S was wary, but the appellant assured her she was safe.
The appellant offered to massage S's neck, but she refused and told him she was in a happy relationship and was not interested in him. Finally, after more assurances, she sat on a cushion and the appellant began to massage her neck. Gradually he began to massage under her top and commented on her breasts. S resisted and moved towards the door, but by this time the appellant had removed his shirt and was unbuckling his belt. He kissed her, placed his hand inside her skirt and masturbated. S said that she was scared and decided to acquiesce to prevent any further trouble. She humoured him, though she refused to take hold of his penis. Eventually the appellant released her and she told him to take her back to work. The appellant suggested they keep the incident quiet and she agreed.
S was ten minutes late back to work and was forced to reschedule an appointment she had for 2:30pm. That afternoon she asked a colleague to stay with her because she was scared of seeing the appellant. She left work early after telling the colleague about the incident. That night S and her partner wrote a note to the appellant telling him to stay away from her. The next day she left the note on his desk and together with her colleague went to her supervisor and complained about the incident.
The following day a formal complaint was made to the deputy general manager of The Press, Mr Broughton, and an investigation was initiated. At the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Smith v Christchurch Press Company Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] NZCA 341
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court of Appeal found that the employer was not in breach of its obligation to act fairly and reasonably in conducting an investigation. The appellant was fully informed of the allegations and the evidence supporting them, was represented at all times, and was given adequate opportunity to answer the allegations in his own way. The Court also found that the appellant's dismissal was not wrongful. The Court of Appeal agreed with the Employment Court's conclusion that the appellant's conduct amounted to serious misconduct, and that it had a sufficient nexus with his employment to justify dismissal. The Court held that the procedure followed in dismissing the employee was irrelevant to a question of wrongful dismissal at common law, as all that was required was serious misconduct. As such, the appeal was dismissed and there was no order for costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case was initially heard in the Employment Court where Judge Shaw dismissed Smith's claim for wrongful dismissal against The Christchurch Press Co Ltd. Smith appealed this decision to the Court of Appeal of New Zealand. The appeal was heard on 18 October 2000 before Gault J, Thomas J, and Keith J. Smith's counsel, A A Couch, presented arguments similar to those made in the lower court, challenging the appropriateness of the "but for" test used by Judge Shaw and the fairness of the investigation procedure. The Christchurch Press Co Ltd was represented by C H Toogood QC and A M Toohey. The Court of Appeal delivered its judgment on 21 November 2000, dismissing the appeal.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the Employment Court apply the correct test in determining whether the conduct complained of occurred in the context of the employment relationship?
2. Was the procedure adopted for the investigation of the appellant's conduct unfair?
Held
1. The Employment Court applied the correct test in determining whether the conduct complained of occurred in the context of the employment relationship. The Court of Appeal found that the conduct had a sufficient nexus with the employment relationship, as it arose out of the work situation and had the potential to adversely affect the working environment.
2. The procedure adopted for the investigation of the appellant's conduct was not unfair. The Court of Appeal found that the employer engaged an investigator who was more experienced and more competent than the decision-maker to conduct the interviews.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court of Appeal considered whether the Employment Court had applied the correct test in determining whether the conduct complained of occurred in the context of the employment relationship. The Court found that the "but for" test was appropriate to ascertain whether the appellant was acting in the course of his employment. The Court noted that the conduct in question did not have to occur within the workplace to be considered in the course of employment. The conduct was between two present employees, arose out of the work situation, and had the potential to adversely affect the working environment. Therefore, the Court concluded that there was ample basis for the Judge's conclusion that there was a sufficient nexus between the appellant's conduct and his employment.
Regarding the procedure adopted for the investigation, the Court found that it was appropriate for the employer to seek advice before conducting the interviews with the complainant and the appellant. The employer engaged an investigator who was more experienced and more competent than the decision-maker to conduct the interviews, which the Court found to be a proper procedure in the circumstances.
The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, as all the grounds of appeal had failed. The Court noted that the procedure followed in dismissing the employee was irrelevant to a question of wrongful dismissal at common law, as all that was required was serious misconduct. The Court was satisfied that the misconduct was properly found by the Judge and that the employer had engaged in a fair procedure.