Smith v Ball

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2017-404-002268

[2018] NZHC 1140

IN THE MATTER OF the Estate of Raymond Alexander Smith (Deceased)

BETWEEN

SAHRA LING SMITH

Plaintiff

AND

ROGER NEVILLE BALL

First Defendant

CRYSTAL MINT DEVELOPMENT LIMITED

Second Defendant

CRYSTAL MINT LIMITED

Third Defendant

Hearing: [On the Papers]

Counsel:

K P McDonald for the Plaintiff R T Glover for the Defendants

Judgment:

23 May 2018


JUDGMENT OF EDWARDS J

[re Costs on the Summary Judgment Application]


This judgment was delivered by Justice Edwards on 23 May 2018 at 10.00 am, pursuant to

r 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar Date:

Counsel:     K T Glover, Auckland

Solicitors:    Kevin McDonald and Associates, Auckland Schnauer and Co Ltd, Auckland

SMITH v BALL [2018] NZHC 1140 [23 May 2018]

[1]                 Ms Smith is the daughter of the late Raymond Smith and was appointed executrix of his estate on 15 August 2016. She commenced proceedings against the defendants seeking transfer of documents, shares and interests in real property back to Mr Smith’s estate.

[2]                 The application against the first defendant was for the transfer of shares in Key Consultants Ltd and the return of estate documents. Ms Smith sought summary judgment on those causes of action. The application was initially opposed, but ultimately resolved without the need for a hearing. The plaintiff now seeks leave to withdraw the application for summary judgment.

[3]                 The plaintiff and the first defendant have been unable to reach agreement on costs. The plaintiff seeks costs in the sum of $9,366 and disbursements totalling

$1,589.75. These sums have been calculated on a schedule 2B basis for the commencement of proceedings, the filing of the summary judgment application, two appearances at mentions hearings and the sealing of the costs order.

[4]                 The defendants oppose the plaintiff’s application for costs. They submit that the costs and disbursements in relation to the summary judgment application should lie where they fall, and that the remaining costs and disbursements should be reserved pending determination of the proceeding.

Analysis

[5]                 The Court’s general practice is to reserve costs on an unsuccessful application for summary judgment with costs to be determined once the substantive proceeding is resolved.1 That principle is reflected in the exception to the rule that costs on interlocutory applications should be fixed when the application is determined.2

[6]                 However, in this case, the withdrawal of the summary judgment application resolves the substantive causes of action against the first defendant. It is accordingly appropriate to determine who should bear the costs of the summary judgment application at this stage in the proceeding.


1      NZI Bank Ltd v Philpott [1990] 2 NZLR 403 (CA) at 405–406.

2      High Court Rules 2016, r 14.8(3).

[7]                 Rule 15.23 of the High Court Rules 2016 states that unless the defendant otherwise agrees or the Court otherwise directs, a plaintiff who discontinues a proceeding against a defendant must pay costs to the defendant of and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Smith v Ball and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZHC 1140
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Smith v Ball involved a dispute regarding the transfer of shares and documents back to the estate of Raymond Alexander Smith, who had passed away. Sahra Ling Smith, the executrix of her father’s estate, sought the return of these assets from Roger Neville Ball, the first defendant, and other defendants associated with the estate. The case was heard on the papers, with submissions made by counsel representing the plaintiff and the defendants. The central legal issue before the court was the allocation of costs in relation to the summary judgment application filed by the plaintiff. The plaintiff sought costs amounting to $9,366, along with disbursements of $1,589.75, calculated based on the commencement of proceedings and subsequent filings. The defendants opposed this application, arguing that the costs of the summary judgment application should lie where they fall and that other costs should be reserved pending the outcome of the substantive proceedings.

The court considered the general practice of reserving costs on unsuccessful applications for summary judgment, which are usually determined once the substantive proceeding is resolved. However, the withdrawal of the summary judgment application in this case resolved the substantive causes of action against the first defendant, prompting the court to decide the costs at that stage. The court noted that while the plaintiff essentially obtained what she had sought in the summary judgment application, the remaining costs relating to the commencement of the proceeding should be reserved pending the final determination of the substantive proceeding. The court also took into account the conduct of the first defendant, which included delays in responding to the claim and initial attempts to avoid service, and found that this conduct did not warrant leaving costs to lie where they fall or reducing the costs payable to the plaintiff.

In conclusion, the court awarded the plaintiff costs and disbursements for the summary judgment application on a schedule 2B basis, but reserved all other claims for costs and disbursements. This decision was based on the principle that costs follow the event, the resolution of the substantive causes of action through the withdrawal of the summary judgment application, and the conduct of the first defendant during the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established