Simpson v Scott HC Tauranga CIV 2010-470-690

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND TAURANGA REGISTRY

CIV-2010-470-690

IN THE MATTER OF     of Section 13 Insolvency Act 2006

BETWEEN  DAVID MAVITTY SIMPSON Judgment Creditor

ANDLEWTYN MICHAEL SCOTT Judgment Debtor

Hearing:         9 December 2010

Appearances: Mr Harrison for Judgment Creditor

Mr Nicholls forJudgment Debtor

Judgment:      16 December 2010 at 10 a.m.

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE DOOGUE

This judgment was delivered by me on

16.12.10 at 10 am, pursuant to

Rule 11.5  of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date……………

Counsel:

Gary M Harrison, Barrister, P O Box 4338, Auckland – gmh@shortlandchambers.co.nz

Edwards Clark Dickie, P O Box 105-629, Auckland – nicholls@ecd-legal.co.nz

SIMPSON V SCOTT HC TAU CIV-2010-470-690  16 December 2010

Background

[1]      In May of 2010 the District Court at Tauranga entered judgment against the judgment debtor in the sum of $34,500 together with costs.  The judgment creditor who was the successful plaintiff in the District Court proceedings sued to recover his unpaid  legal  costs  and  amounts  that  he  had  paid  to  counsel,  Mr  J  Moody  of Auckland, that he had instructed on behalf of the judgment debtor.  The judgment not having been satisfied, the judgment creditor served a bankruptcy notice on the judgment debtor.   On 30 August 2010 the judgment debtor filed in this Court an application for an order setting aside the bankruptcy notice.   Three grounds were given for seeking the order:

a)        He was going to appeal the judgment entered against him;

b)He had a defence set-off or genuine triable counter-claim that could not be raised in the proceeding and that equalled or exceeded the amount claimed;

c)        The judgment debtor is able to pay his debts.

[2]      At the hearing before me 9 December 2010 the only ground which was dealt with was that in (b).

[3]      It is necessary to mention additional matters of background that are relevant to the application.  In 2006 Mr Scott was in dispute with members of his extended family arising out of family trusts and the estates of his late grandfather and father. On 17 February that year a mediation was convened before Mr W Sowerby.  The mediation continued for two days.   Late at night on the second day heads of agreement were produced for the parties to sign.   Mr Scott signed them.   He now complains that counsel who represented him at the mediation, Mr Moody, did not let him read the document before he signed it but explained its contents orally to him. Mr Scott says that the heads of agreement contained errors which meant that the arrangement evidenced by the heads of agreement was much less favourable to him than what had been negotiated.  That would not have happened he now says if Mr

Moody had let him read it.   Further he says that Mr Moody and the solicitor Mr Simpson, in the days following the mediation, failed to take effective steps to have the agreement between the parties corrected.   He says that he has suffered major financial loss which far outweighs the amount for which…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Simpson v Scott HC Tauranga CIV 2010-470-690 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NZHC 2288
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand heard an application by Lewtyn Michael Scott to set aside a bankruptcy notice issued by David Mavitt Simpson, the judgment creditor. Simpson had obtained a District Court judgment against Scott for $34,500, plus costs. Scott applied to set aside the bankruptcy notice on the grounds that he had a cross-claim against Simpson that could not be raised as a defence in the proceeding where the judgment was obtained. The primary legal issue was whether Scott could demonstrate a cross-claim of true substance which he genuinely proposed to pursue, and whether he was prevented from using the cross-claim as a defence by law or factual inability.

The court found that Scott had not shown a cross-claim of true substance, as it had been over four and a half years since the alleged breaches by the legal practitioners, and Scott had not quantified the alleged losses. Additionally, Scott was unable to put forward the cross-claim as a defence due to his own default in not articulating the defence in a particularised manner. The District Court Judge had declined to grant leave to amend the notice of opposition, and Scott had not appealed this decision. Therefore, the court dismissed Scott's application to set aside the bankruptcy notice.

The court directed that the parties attempt to agree on the costs of the proceedings, and if they were unable to do so, they should file memoranda not exceeding four pages on each side within 14 days of the date of the judgment.