Sillick v Sillick

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WHANGAREI REGISTRY

CIV-2010-488-000824 [2016] NZHC 2880

IN THE MATTER OF

the estate of LUCY RIHI SILLICK

(deceased)

UNDER

the Administration Act 1969

BETWEEN

FRANZINA DE ANNA SILLICK Applicant

AND

BRIAN EARL SILLICK Respondent

DAWN KELLY SILLICK Interested Party

Hearing: 30 November 2016

Appearances:

F Fuiava for Applicant
Interested Party in Person

Judgment:

30 November 2016

ORAL JUDGMENT OF GILBERT J

Solicitors:

Denham Bramwell, Manukau, Auckland

SILLICK v SILLICK [2016] NZHC 2880 [30 November 2016]

Introduction

[1]      This is an application pursuant to s 21 of the Administration Act 1969 by one administrator, Franzina Sillick, for the removal of the other, her uncle, Brian Sillick.

Background

[2]      Lucy Sillick died on 8 December 2010.  She had four children, Brian, Dawn, Charlotte and Anne (who died in infancy).  Franzina is one of Charlotte’s children.

[3]      Lucy appointed Brian and Franzina as executors and trustees under her will and probate was granted to them on 29 December 2010.  The sole asset in the estate was a property in Kaitaia which has a capital value of $285,000.  In her will, Lucy left the property to Brian and Franzina as tenants in common in equal shares and recorded her wish that it be kept in the Sillick family and not sold.  Brian has lived at the property since his mother died.

[4]      Dawn made a claim under the Family Protection Act because her mother made no provision for her in her will.  This claim was settled and a consent order was made in the Auckland Family Court on 7 May 2014.  The order varied the will so as to provide that the property would be owned by Brian, Franzina and Dawn as tenants  in  common  in  shares  37.5  per  cent,  37.5  per  cent  and  25  per  cent respectively.  An additional clause was added, clause 3(e), dealing with Brian’s right of occupation of the property.   The operative clause of the will following these amendments reads as follows:

3.        MY EXECUTOR AND TRUSTEE shall hold the whole of my estate

UPON TRUST either to retain or sell it and:

(a)       to pay my debts taxes duties and executorship expenses, and

(b)       to pay and transfer the residue equally to the said Brian Earl Sillick as to 37.5% and Francina Deanna Sillick as to 37.5% and to Dawn Kelly Sillick as to 25% absolutely as tenants in common.

(c)       in  the  event  that  my  son  or  my  grand-daughter  do  not survive me [not applicable].

(d)       I EXPRESS the wish that my house property and land is not to be sold and is to be kept in the Sillick family.

(e)       if, after my death, my son Brian Earl Sillick shall choose to occupy  the  property  which  I  own  at  193  Okahu  Road,

Ahipara, Kaitaia (identifier NA37B/107) then he shall be responsible for meeting outgoings on the property during the period of his occupancy.

[5]      Title to the property has been transferred to Franzina and Brian as tenants in common in equal…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sillick v Sillick and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 2880
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Franzina de Anna Sillick applied for the removal of Brian Earl Sillick as an administrator of the estate of Lucy Rhihi Sillick, who had died on 8 December 2010. The sole asset of the estate was a property in Kaitaia with a capital value of $285,000. Lucy had appointed Brian and Franzina as executors and trustees under her will, and the property was left to them as tenants in common in equal shares. Dawn Kelly Sillick made a claim under the Family Protection Act because she had not been provided for in the will. The claim was settled and a consent order was made in the Auckland Family Court on 7 May 2014. The order varied the will to provide that the property would be owned by Brian, Franzina, and Dawn as tenants in common in shares 37.5 per cent, 37.5 per cent and 25 per cent respectively. The court had to decide whether Franzina had the right to remove Brian as an administrator due to his failure to maintain the property and pay outgoings. The court found that the estate had already been administered and the administrators had no continuing role. Franzina had no right to sell the property as she had agreed to a settlement of the Family Protection Act claim on terms which included giving Brian the right to occupy the property. Although Brian had agreed to meet the outgoings on the property and Franzina was entitled to enforce that obligation, his failure to pay did not give her an immediate right to sell the property. The application was dismissed.

Franzina Sillick applied for the removal of Brian Earl Sillick as an administrator of the estate of Lucy Rhihi Sillick. The court had to decide whether Franzina had the right to remove Brian as an administrator due to his failure to maintain the property and pay outgoings. The court found that the estate had already been administered and the administrators had no continuing role. Franzina had no right to sell the property as she had agreed to a settlement of the Family Protection Act claim on terms which included giving Brian the right to occupy the property. Although Brian had agreed to meet the outgoings on the property and Franzina was entitled to enforce that obligation, his failure to pay did not give her an immediate right to sell the property. The application was dismissed.

The application is dismissed. The court found that the estate had already been administered and the administrators had no continuing role. Franzina had no right to sell the property as she had agreed to a settlement of the Family Protection Act claim on terms which included giving Brian the right to occupy the property. Although Brian had agreed to meet the outgoings on the property and Franzina was entitled to enforce that obligation, his failure to pay did not give her an immediate right to sell the property. The application was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established