Siemer v Judicial Conduct Commissioner

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV-2013-485-985 [2014] NZHC 596

BETWEEN  VINCENT ROSS SIEMER Plaintiff

ANDJUDICIAL CONDUCT COMMISSIONER

First Defendant

RODNEY HANSEN Second Defendant

CIV-2013-485-1369

BETWEEN  VINCENT ROSS SIEMER Plaintiff

ANDJUDICIAL CONDUCT COMMISSIONER

First Defendant

DAVID HARVEY Second Defendant

Hearing:                   26 March 2014

Counsel:                  Plaintiff in person

L Theron for First Defendant

Judgment:                27 March 2014

JUDGMENT OF THE HON JUSTICE KÓS

[1]      The  Judicial   Conduct  Commissioner  seeks   security  for  costs   against

Mr Siemer.

[2]      Mr Siemer has commenced two judicial review proceedings against decisions of  the  Commissioner.                The  first  (proceeding  985)  seeks  judicial  review  of  the

SIEMER v JUDICIAL CONDUCT COMMISSIONER [2014] NZHC 596 [27 March 2014]

Commissioner’s  decision  to  dismiss  Mr  Siemer’s  complaint  about  Hansen  J excluding him from the courtroom during the argument of a procedural point in the “Urewera Four” trial in 2012.   Mr Siemer had asserted that he was a media representative entitled to remain (along with other members of the media).  Hansen J permitted the other persons to remain, but not Mr Siemer.  Mr Siemer complained to the Commissioner.  The Commissioner dismissed the complaint as lying outside his jurisdiction.  That was because it called into question an “instruction”, “direction” or “other decision” given by a Judge “in relation to any legal proceeding”.  Section 8(2) of the Judicial Conduct Commissioner and Judicial Conduct Panel Act 2004 (the Act) expressly excludes Commissioner jurisdiction in such cases.

[3]      In  the  second  (proceeding  1369),  Mr  Siemer  seeks  judicial  review  of  a decision by the Commissioner to take no further action in respect of a complaint about Judge Harvey.   In a District Court proceeding brought by Mr Siemer, Judge Joyce  had   required  him  to  provide  security  for  costs.     Mr Siemer  sought “reconsideration” of that decision.  That came before Judge Harvey.  In the course of the hearing there was this passage:

THE COURT:

I’m  not  defending  Judge  Joyce.    Judge  Joyce  is  perfectly  capable  of defending himself.  I’m making an observation Mr Siemer and you better be very careful where you go, I know you’re familiar with contempt of Court proceedings and you may not be aware of the decision in the case of Mihaka where the abuse of a judge, of one Judge A to another Judge B was deemed to be contempt of Court, so tread carefully sir, tread carefully.

MR SIEMER:

I’m sorry sir, if I offended Your Honour, all I was simply saying –

THE COURT:

You haven’t offended me, your contempt was directed towards Judge Joyce. He doesn’t need any defence.  Now let’s move on shall we, put that to one side.

Mr Siemer complained that the Judge’s conduct was “personally disrespectful, threatening me with contempt in the face of the Court with no justification”.  The Commissioner determined to take no further action in respect of that complaint.  The Commissioner said in his decision:

… Judge Harvey did not threaten the complainant with contempt of Court. He warned the complainant to be careful in the comments he was making about Judge Joyce and,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Siemer v Judicial Conduct Commissioner and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 596
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Siemer v Judicial Conduct Commissioner, the Judicial Conduct Commissioner sought an order for security for costs against Mr Siemer, who had initiated two judicial review proceedings against the Commissioner. The first proceeding concerned a complaint about a judge excluding Mr Siemer from a courtroom during a trial, and the second involved a complaint about a judge's conduct during a hearing. The Commissioner argued that Mr Siemer's claims were unmeritorious and that he had a history of failing to pay costs, which would be oppressive to the Commissioner's reasonable interests. Mr Siemer, who appeared in person, asserted that he was impecunious and unable to pay the costs.

The court considered four issues: whether there was reason to believe Mr Siemer would be unable to pay the Commissioner's costs if he was unsuccessful in his proceedings, how the discretion under the relevant rule should be exercised, what amount of security for costs should be fixed, and whether a stay should be ordered. The court found that the Commissioner had met the threshold requirement for ordering security, and that Mr Siemer's claims were prima facie unmeritorious. The court also found that denying security would not be oppressive to the Commissioner's reasonable interests, as previous costs awards against Mr Siemer had gone unpaid, and that ordering security would not deprive Mr Siemer of the capacity to advance a prima facie meritorious claim. The court ordered security for costs in the sum of $10,000 in each proceeding and stayed each proceeding until Mr Siemer paid the security sums ordered into Court. The court also granted leave to the Commissioner to renew his application for security if the amount proved insufficient and ordered that the time for filing a statement of defence be extended until seven days after security was paid.

In conclusion, the court ordered security for costs against Mr Siemer in both judicial review proceedings against the Judicial Conduct Commissioner. The court found that Mr Siemer's claims were prima facie unmeritorious, and that ordering security was necessary to protect the Commissioner's reasonable interests, as Mr Siemer had a history of failing to pay costs. The court ordered security for costs in the sum of $10,000 in each proceeding and stayed each proceeding until Mr Siemer paid the security sums ordered into Court. The court also granted leave to the Commissioner to renew his application for security if the amount proved insufficient and extended the time for filing a statement of defence until seven days after security was paid. The Commissioner was entitled to costs on the present application on a category 2 band B basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.