Siemer v Fardell, Executrix for Robert Fardell, Deceased

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA171/07
[2007] NZCA 530

BETWEENVINCE AND JANE SIEMER


First Appellants

ANDPARAGON SERVICES LIMITED


Second Appellant

ANDKATE FARDELL, EXECUTRIX FOR ROBERT FARDELL, DECEASED


Respondent

Hearing:13 November 2007

Court:Arnold, Panckhurst and Keane JJ

Counsel:First Appellants in person


A A Lusk QC for Respondent

Judgment:22 November 2007 at 2.30 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The appeal is dismissed.

BThe first appellants must pay the respondent costs of $3000 plus usual disbursements.

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Arnold J)

Introduction

[1]       The appellants, Mr and Mrs Siemer and Paragon Services Limited (Paragon), are suing the estate of Robert Fardell QC.  They allege that Mr Fardell was negligent and in breach of fiduciary duty in certain actions he took and advice he gave when acting for them. 

[2]       They issued what has been treated as a jury notice under r 435 of the High Court Rules.  The respondent then applied under s 19A(5) of the Judicature Act 1908 for an order that the trial be held before a Judge alone.  John Hansen J granted the respondent’s application: HC AK CIV-2003-404-5782 3 April 2007.

[3]       The appellants now appeal against that decision.

Background

[4]       A company called Waterford Holdings Limited (Waterford) was developing an oil purification process to enable the recycling of oil from transformers.  The Siemers agreed to provide funding for the development of the process.  Paragon was formed as the vehicle for this.  Waterford held the majority shareholding in Paragon.  The Siemers had a substantial minority shareholding (around 40 per cent) and the two shareholders of Waterford, Ms McCaig and Mr Rutherford, had small shareholdings.  The intellectual property in the process was to be transferred from Waterford to Paragon.

[5]       The transaction was settled on 1 September 2000.  The Siemers made an initial payment of over $500,000.  Soon after, however, the Siemers became concerned that they were being excluded from Paragon’s operations by the other shareholders.  They consulted Paragon’s legal advisers, who recommended that they seek advice from Mr Fardell. 

[6]       Mr Fardell took a number of urgent steps on behalf of the Siemers.  On 22 November 2000 he commenced proceedings under s 174 of the Companies Act 1993 alleging oppression.  He advised the Siemers that they should apply to have Paragon placed into receivership.  They did so, and on 15 December 2000 the Court, by consent, placed Paragon into receivership and appointed Mr Stiassny of Ferrier Hodgson as receiver.  On 6 December 2000, Mr Fardell commenced misrepresentation proceedings against the other shareholders and other people associated with Waterford.  Subsequently, Waterford went into voluntary liquidation, and Mr Rutherford took his own life. 

[7]       Initially the receiver seems to have thought that Paragon might be able to continue operating, if additional funding could be found to enable the commissioning of a machine incorporating the technology to be completed.  The Siemers declined to provide further funding, however.  Accordingly, in his second report to the Court dated 12 March 2001, the receiver indicated that, in view of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Siemer v Fardell, Executrix for Robert Fardell, Deceased and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NZCA 530
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Siemer v Fardell, Executrix for Robert Fardell, Deceased, involved an appeal against a decision by John Hansen J to order that the trial of the proceedings be heard by a judge alone, rather than by a judge and jury. The appellants, Mr and Mrs Siemer and Paragon Services Limited, alleged that Mr Robert Fardell was negligent and in breach of fiduciary duty in certain actions he took and advice he gave when acting for them. The respondents applied for an order under s 19A(5) of the Judicature Act 1908 that the trial take place before a judge alone, which was granted by Hansen J. The appellants appealed this decision, arguing that a judge sitting alone would not hear the action in a fair and impartial manner.

The Court of Appeal considered the legal issues of whether s 19A(5)(a) and (b) were met in this case and whether the Judge had exercised his discretion correctly in ordering trial by judge alone. The Court found that both s 19A(5)(a) and (b) were met, as the proceedings involved mainly the consideration of difficult questions of law and required any prolonged examination of documents or accounts, or any investigation in which difficult questions in relation to scientific, technical, business or professional matters were likely to arise. The Court also considered that the appellants' concerns about the fairness of a trial by judge alone were not a justification for refusing to order trial by judge alone where that would otherwise be justified.

The appeal was dismissed, and the Siemers were ordered to pay the respondent costs of $3,000 in this Court, plus usual disbursements. The Court of Appeal considered the appellants' views about the courts and the judiciary to be based on a profound misunderstanding of the nature of the judicial process and the difficulties inherent in their claim against Mr Fardell. The Court found that the Judge had exercised his discretion correctly in ordering trial by judge alone.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established