Siemer v District Court North Shore

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA624/2018
 [2019] NZCA 96

BETWEEN

JANE DINSDALE SIEMER
Appellant

AND

DISTRICT COURT NORTH SHORE
First Respondent

DISPUTES TRIBUNAL NORTH SHORE
Second Respondent

CA14/2019

BETWEEN

JANE DINSDALE SIEMER
Appellant

AND

MINISTRY OF JUSTICE
First Respondent

CLAYTON LUKE
Second Respondent

Counsel:

Appellant self-represented
M J McKillop and L Dittrich for Respondents in CA624/2018

Judgment:
(On the papers)

8 April 2019 at 3 pm

JUDGMENT OF CLIFFORD J
 (Review of Registrar’s Decision)

AThe appeal in CA624/2018 may not be continued by the appellant without leave of the High Court.

BThe application for review of the Registrar’s decision declining to waive the filing fee in CA14/2019 is declined.

CThe filing fee in CA14/2019 is to be paid within 20 working days of the date of this judgment.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS

Introduction

  1. In:

    (a)CA624/2018 (the Contempt Appeal), Mrs Siemer seeks to appeal a finding of civil contempt made against her by Fitzgerald J in judicial review proceedings in the High Court at Auckland recorded in a minute of 7 August 2018,[1] and a further minute of 13 September 2018.[2]  Fitzgerald J made the challenged finding of civil contempt in judicial review proceedings brought by Mrs Siemer challenging the District Court decision rejecting her appeal against an order of the Disputes Tribunal at North Shore.  In a minute dated 31 May 2018 the Judge directed, in accordance with Mrs Siemer’s request, that a copy of the transcript of the hearing in the Disputes Tribunal be prepared and included in the record for the purpose of the judicial review hearing.  The Judge made the following further direction:[3]

    [1]That finding was initially recorded in Siemer v New Zealand District Court North Shore HC Auckland CIV-2018-404-610, 7 August 2018 (Minute of Fitzgerald J).

    [2]Siemer v New Zealand District Court North Shore HC Auckland CIV-2018-404-610, 13 September 2018 (Minute of Fitzgerald J).

    [3]Siemer v New Zealand District Court North Shore CIV-2018-404-610, 31 May 2018 (Minute of Fitzgerald J) at [10].

    I make a direction that a copy of the transcript, once filed and served, is not to be disclosed to third parties and is to be used for the sole purpose of this proceeding.

    In her subsequent minute of 7 August the Judge found that Ms Siemer had breached that order by annexing a copy of the transcript affidavits filed on her behalf into other proceedings before the High Court and disclosing it to the Law Society in connection with a complaint.  The Judge stated in her minute “[t]hose actions are in breach of my order”.[4] 

    (b)CA14/2019 (the Strike-out and Civil Restraint Appeal), Mrs Siemer seeks to appeal the decision of Hinton J, made on the application of the Attorney‑General, in the High Court at Auckland on 19 December 2018:[5] 

    (i)striking out and dismissing her judicial review application challenging the process adopted by the Ministry of Justice in dealing with complaints she and her husband made to the Ministry of Justice regarding Mr Clayton…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Siemer v District Court North Shore and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NZCA 96
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Siemer v District Court North Shore, the appellant, Jane Dinsdale Siemer, sought to appeal a finding of civil contempt made against her by Fitzgerald J in the High Court at Auckland, as well as the decision of the Disputes Tribunal North Shore rejecting her appeal against an order. The appeal also addressed the decision of the Attorney-General to strike out and dismiss Siemer's judicial review application, and to make a civil restraint order against her. Siemer sought to appeal the decisions of the Registrar in two related proceedings: firstly, the decision to decline her application to dispense with security for costs and to waive the scheduling fee for the appeal; and secondly, the decision to decline her application to waive the filing fee for her appeal. The legal issues before the court were whether Siemer had established that the appeal constituted a matter of genuine public interest, and whether the appeal would be unlikely to be commenced or continued unless the fee was waived.

The court found that Siemer had not established that the appeal constituted a matter of genuine public interest, or that the appeal would be unlikely to be commenced or continued unless the fee was waived. The court noted that most of the issues raised by Siemer's appeal would turn on the particular facts and would only affect the parties, notwithstanding that the question of whether the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990 prevents the strike-out of a judicial review proceeding would be of some interest to other members of the public. The court further noted that the High Court's decision to make the Civil Restraint Order with extended effect against Siemer is one of obvious importance to her, and raises an issue of some public significance, namely the threshold for the making of such orders under the Senior Courts Act 2016. However, the court did not see how Siemer could satisfy the second aspect of the genuine public interest criterion, namely that her appeal "is unlikely to be commenced or continued unless the fee is waived."

In conclusion, the court dismissed Siemer's application for review of the Registrar's decision declining to waive the filing fee for this appeal. The filing fee should be paid within 20 working days of the date of this judgment.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves two appeals brought by Jane Dinsdale Siemer against decisions made by the District Court North Shore and the Ministry of Justice. In the first appeal (CA624/2018), Siemer contests a finding of civil contempt made against her by Fitzgerald J in judicial review proceedings. This contempt finding arose from Siemer's breach of a court order by disclosing a transcript from a Disputes Tribunal hearing to third parties. The second appeal (CA14/2019) concerns the striking out and dismissal of Siemer's judicial review application against the Ministry of Justice's handling of complaints she made, as well as a civil restraint order prohibiting her from initiating proceedings related to specific cases for three years.

The first appeal, CA624/2018, originates from a finding of civil contempt by Fitzgerald J in judicial review proceedings. Siemer challenges this finding and seeks to appeal it. In the second appeal, CA14/2019, Siemer appeals the decision of Hinton J to strike out and dismiss her judicial review application and to make a civil restraint order against her. Siemer also applies for a Judge of the Court of Appeal to review the Registrar's decisions declining her applications to waive filing fees for both appeals.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the appeal in CA624/2018 may proceed without leave of the High Court.
2. Whether the application for review of the Registrar’s decision declining to waive the filing fee in CA14/2019 should be granted.
3. Whether the filing fee in CA14/2019 should be waived.

Held
1. The appeal in CA624/2018 may not proceed without leave of the High Court.
2. The application for review of the Registrar’s decision declining to waive the filing fee in CA14/2019 is declined.
3. The filing fee in CA14/2019 is to be paid within 20 working days of the date of this judgment.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the Contempt Appeal, Mrs Siemer sought to appeal a finding of civil contempt made by Fitzgerald J in judicial review proceedings. The Court of Appeal determined that Mrs Siemer's appeal required leave of the High Court as it concerned proceedings relating to Siemer v Hickson CIV-2017-044-495 and CIV-2017-044-562, which were subject to a civil restraint order. As such, without leave from the High Court, the appeal could not proceed. Consequently, the appeal in CA624/2018 was not allowed to proceed without leave from the High Court.

Regarding the application for review of the Registrar's decision declining to waive the filing fee in CA14/2019, the Registrar had declined Mrs Siemer's application on the basis that she had not demonstrated either undue financial hardship or that the appeal constituted a matter of genuine public interest. The Court of Appeal agreed with the Registrar's findings. Mrs Siemer had not provided sufficient evidence to show that paying the fee would cause undue financial hardship, and the Court found her appeal did not meet the genuine public interest criterion. The appeal was unlikely to be commenced or continued without fee waiver merely because Mrs Siemer would choose not to pay the fee if it was not waived. The application for review of the Registrar’s decision was therefore declined, and Mrs Siemer was directed to pay the filing fee within 20 working days from the date of the judgment.