Siemer v District Court at North Shore

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2012-404-4532 [2012] NZHC 3191

BETWEEN  JANE SIEMER Plaintiff

ANDTHE DISTRICT COURT AT NORTH SHORE

First Defendant

ANDTHE AUCKLAND COUNCIL Second Defendant

Hearing:         28 November 2012

Counsel:         F Deliu for Plaintiff

D Soper for First Defendant (abides decision of the Court) P Mulligan for Second Defendant

Judgment:      28 November 2012

(ORAL) JUDGMENT OF LANG J [on application for judicial review]

JANE SIEMER V THE DISTRICT COURT AT NORTH SHORE HC AK CIV-2012-404-4532 [28 November

2012]

[1]      In  this proceeding Ms  Siemer challenges by way of judicial review two decisions by Justices of the Peace in a proceeding arising out of an infringement notice issued by the Auckland Council.

Background

[2]      On or about 21 May 2011, the Auckland Council (“the Council”) posted an infringement notice to Ms Siemer alleging she had committed an offence against a Council bylaw by permitting her dog to rush at another person.

[3]      On 22 May 2011, Ms Siemer wrote to the Council indicating she wished to dispute the alleged infringement.   She sought details as to the witnesses to the alleged infringement, details regarding the location where the incident took place and confirmation as to the date and time of the infringement.  In addition, she sought a description of the dog alleged to have been involved in the incident, together with details of the events leading up to it.

[4]      The Council responded to Ms Siemer by letter dated 5 July 2011, indicating that the incident had taken place at 27 Clansman Terrace at 5.30 pm on Thursday

12 May 2011.  The letter also gave details of the dog allegedly involved.  The letter advised, however, that the Council was unable to divulge the name of the witness to the incident, but that the witness would be named in Court should the matter proceed to a defended hearing.   The letter enclosed a statement allegedly taken from the witness, but with the name and address of the witness deleted.

[5]      On 7 July 2011, the Council sent a further letter to Ms Siemer indicating that her request for a Court hearing had been granted, and that the necessary documentation would be sent to the Court.

[6]      Ms  Siemer  maintains  she  heard  nothing  further  about  the  matter  until

13 December 2011, when she was contacted by Ms Wilkinson of the Auckland Council.   Ms Wilkinson advised her that the infringement notice had been called before the Justices of the Peace in the North Shore District Court that morning.  The

Council had sent notice of the hearing to Ms Siemer in a letter dated 4 October 2011. Ms Siemer has always maintained she never received that letter.

[7]      During the telephone conversation, Ms Wilkinson indicated that the matter could be heard before the Justices of the Peace on 21 February 2012.  She asked Ms Siemer whether that would be a suitable date for her to attend the defended hearing. Ms Siemer confirmed she could attend on that date, and asked Ms Wilkinson…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Siemer v District Court at North Shore and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 3191
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Ms Siemer sought judicial review of two decisions made by Justices of the Peace in the North Shore District Court. These decisions related to an infringement notice issued by the Auckland Council. The first decision was the Justices’ decision to convict Ms Siemer in her absence on 21 February 2012. The second decision was the Justices’ refusal of Ms Siemer’s application for a re-hearing of the infringement notice on 12 April 2012. The Justices purported to reinstate the infringement notice and penalty under s 76(b) of the Summary Proceedings Act 1957. However, there is no such section in the Act. Moreover, the Justices did not have any factual material before them that enabled them to conclude that the charge contained in the infringement notice had been proved beyond reasonable doubt. Ms Siemer’s application for a re-hearing was also declined without reasons. The Justices’ failure to give reasons was particularly egregious in light of the fact that Ms Siemer had filed an affidavit explaining how she had not received notice of the earlier hearing, and had also not been advised of the details of the resumed hearing on 21 February 2012.

The court was satisfied that the application for judicial review must be granted. The fine and order for costs imposed by the Justices were quashed. Ms Siemer was the successful party, and as such she was entitled to an award of costs in her favour. The court considered that both the Justices of the Peace and the Auckland Council bore a degree of responsibility for what had happened. The District Court was to be heard in relation to the issue of costs, and the court directed counsel for the District Court to file a brief memorandum no later than 12 December 2012 setting out the District Court’s position regarding costs. The Council was to respond by 5 pm on Friday 14 December 2012, and counsel for Ms Siemer could respond by brief memorandum no later than 5 pm on Tuesday 18 December 2012. The court would then deal with the issue of costs on the papers.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established