IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY
CIV 2014-404-3085 [2015] NZHC 2479
BETWEEN HEATHER RUTH SHOTTER AND MBT
LTD AS TRUSTEES OF THE SHOTTER FAMILY TRUST
Plaintiff
AND
KOKAKO FARMS LTD Defendant
CIV 2015-404-977
BETWEEN EVAN WELCH DAVIES Plaintiff
ANDHEATHER RUTH SHOTTER Defendant
CIV 2015-404-1448
BETWEEN HEATHER RUTH SHOTTER AND MBT LTD AS TRUSTEES OF THE SHOTTER FAMILY TRUST
Plaintiff
ANDEVAN WELCH DAVIES Defendant
Hearing: 9 October 2015 Counsel:
H L Thompson for Shotter interests
A H H Choi for Kokako Farms Ltd and Mr DaviesJudgment:
9 October 2015
(ORAL) JUDGMENT OF HEATH J
Solicitors:
McMahon Butterworth Thompson, Auckland
Kemps Weir, AucklandCounsel:
D A T Chambers QC, Auckland
SHOTTER AND MBT LTD AS TRUSTEES OF THE SHOTTER FAMILY TRUST v KOKAKO FARMS LTD [2015] NZHC 2479 [9 October 2015]
Introduction
[1] Ms Shotter and Mr Davies married on 18 November 2000 and separated on
12 June 2006. An agreement dealing with (among other things) relationship property issues (the relationship property agreement) was signed by each of them on 28 June
2006.
[2] Three proceedings have been issued, all of which appear to have their genesis in the relationship property agreement. They are:
(a) Shotter and MBT Ltd v Kokako Farms Ltd (the Company proceeding).1 This proceeding was commenced in November 2014. Kokako is a company presently controlled by Mr Davies. In this proceeding, the trustees of the Shotter Family Trust (Ms Shotter and MBT Ltd), (the trustees) claim that Kokako holds a property in Hawke’s Bay on trust for them and seek an order for the transfer of
the asset. The trustees allege that the trust to which they say Kokako is subject was established by the relationship property agreement.
(b)Davies v Shotter (the Summary Judgment proceeding).2 This proceeding was commenced on 5 May 2015. It is a summary judgment proceeding. An Amended Statement of Claim was filed on
11 June 2015 in which Mr Davies sought judgment against Ms Shotter in the sum of $1,554,036.60, and an order for interest in respect of other sums owing under the relationship property agreement.
(c) Shotter and MBT Ltd v Davies (the Damages proceeding).3 This proceeding was issued on 26 June 2015. The trustees seek judgment for $500,000 under cl 3.7 of the relationship property agreement, and compensation for the market value of the Hawke’s Bay property that
they allege was promised under the relationship property agreement.
1 CIV-2014-404-3085.
2 CIV-2015-404-977.
3 CIV-2015-404-1448.
[3] The Company proceeding has been set down for hearing on 23 November
2015. Kokako applies to vacate that hearing. Kokako and Mr Davies seek an order consolidating (or requiring a joint hearing of) all three proceedings.
[4] The summary judgment application was argued on 25 August 2015 before Associate Judge Sargisson. Her judgment remains reserved. The present applications proceed on the assumption that the summary judgment proceeding will not be determined finally by the Associate Judge’s decision. If the contrary position were to result, consolidation or joint hearing of the Company…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Shotter v Kokako Farms Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] NZHC 2479
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was tasked with deciding whether the proceedings should be consolidated or jointly heard, as well as whether the hearing of the first proceeding should be adjourned and whether the third proceeding should be stayed pending the resolution of the other proceedings. The court found that while the proceedings arose from the same relationship property agreement and shared some common issues, they each involved distinct legal and factual considerations. The court held that the Company proceeding, which sought the transfer of the Hawke’s Bay property, was distinct from the Damages and Summary Judgment proceedings, which sought monetary remedies. The court also noted that the Summary Judgment proceeding could not be consolidated as it was an interlocutory application.
The court found that the grounds for consolidation had not been made out, as the common questions did not necessitate consolidation to do justice among the parties. The court also found that there was no need to adjourn the hearing of the Company proceeding or to stay the Damages proceeding, as adequate remedies existed to protect the interests of Kokako Farms Ltd and Davies if the trustees were to obtain judgment. The court dismissed all applications and ordered costs to be paid by Kokako Farms Ltd and Davies on a joint and several basis.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi