IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE
CIV-2021-404-000491
[2022] NZHC 2620
BETWEEN SHK TRUSTEE COMPANY LIMITED
Plaintiff
AND
NZDMG LIMITED
First Defendant
HAORAN MAO
Second DefendantLILI DONG
Third Defendant
Hearing: 28-30 March 2022 Appearances:
P J Morris and E Gamet for the Plaintiff
No appearance for or on behalf of the First Defendant H Mao, Second Defendant in person
L Dong, Third Defendant in person
Judgment:
11 October 2022
JUDGMENT OF HARVEY J
This judgment was delivered by me on 11 October 2022 at 3 pm, pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.
Registrar/Deputy Registrar Date: ………………………….
Solicitors: Stace Hammond, Hamilton And to: Second Defendant
Third Defendant
SHK TRUSTEE COMPANY LTD v NZDMG LTD [2022] NZHC 2620 [11 October 2022]
Contents
Introduction............................................................................................................... [1]
Issues.......................................................................................................................... [8]
Background............................................................................................................... [9]
Procedural history................................................................................................... [18]
What was payable during the COVID-19 Alert Level 3 and 4 Lockdowns? [20]
Plaintiff ’s submissions............................................................................................ [20]
Defendants’ submissions......................................................................................... [42]
Legal framework and principles............................................................................... [49]
Discussion................................................................................................................. [56]
What was payable under Alert Level 3?................................................................... [56]
What was payable under Alert Level 4?................................................................... [63]
Is the plaintiff entitled to loss of rent damages, removal and reinstatement costs? [69]
Submissions.......................................................................................................... [69]
Discussion................................................................................................................. [71]
Are the Property Law Act 2007 notices issued to the defendants valid? [76]
Plaintiff ’s submissions............................................................................................ [76]
Defendants’ submissions......................................................................................... [83]
Discussion................................................................................................................. [86]
What are the consequences of any invalidity of the notices?..................................... [91]
Should any of the defendants’ counterclaims be granted?........................................ [92]
Counterclaim plaintiffs’ submissions....................................................................... [92]
Counterclaim defendants’ submissions................................................................... [101]
Discussion............................................................................................................... [106]
Decision.................................................................................................................. [109]
Costs....................................................................................................................... [111]
Introduction
[1] By an oral decision dated 26 July 2021, Associate Judge Bell gave summary judgment in favour of the plaintiff, SHK Trustee Company Ltd (SHK) for its claim for rent and outgoings as well as interest, later calculated in the amount of $146,371.71, against the first defendant, NZDMG Ltd.1 This excluded the periods of the Level 3 and 4 COVID-19 lockdowns in Auckland in 2020.2 The first defendant, NZDMG Ltd is a kitchen manufacturing company, who previously leased commercial premises from SHK. The second and third defendants, Haoran Mao and Lili Dong, are directors and guarantors under the leases of the first defendant.
1 SHK Trustee Company Limited v NZDMG Limited [2021] NZHC 1895 [Summary Judgment]; as directed, the sum was later calculated in a case management conference, SHK Trustee Company Limited v NZDMG Limited HC Auckland CIV-2021-404-491, 6 August 2021 [Minute of Associate Judge Bell] at [2].
2 SHK Trustee Company Limited v NZDMG Limited [2021] NZHC 1895 at [55].
[2] Associate Judge Bell also noted that the second and third defendants took issue on a jurisdictional point – that they preferred the proceeding was deferred until such time as the parties had engaged in arbitration.
[3] In addition, the Judge raised issues at paragraphs [41] to [54] of his decision that the notice of termination of the lease may have been invalid where the amounts claimed were sufficiently incorrect in magnitude with the result that the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read SHK Trustee Company Limited v NZDMG Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] NZHC 2620
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The plaintiff, SHK Trustee Company Limited, sought rent and outgoings, interest, legal costs, and removal and reinstatement costs from the defendants, NZDMG Limited, Haoran Mao, and Lili Dong, who had leased commercial premises from the plaintiff. The defendants argued that they were not liable for any rent during the Level 3 and 4 lockdowns due to the inability to access their premises and the non-essential nature of their business. They also claimed that the plaintiff’s notices were invalid, leading to an unlawful termination of the lease.
The court found that the defendants were liable for 70 percent of the rent during Alert Level 3 and 60 percent during Alert Level 4, given their ability to operate their business under Level 3 and the complete inaccessibility under Level 4. The court also determined that the plaintiff’s notices were valid, despite some inaccuracies, as they sufficiently informed the defendants of the required payment. Consequently, the plaintiff was entitled to recover the full amounts due, including interest, removal and reinstatement costs, and legal costs. The defendants’ counterclaims, which included claims for damages and losses due to the eviction, were dismissed due to lack of evidence and the defendants' breach of the lease.
The final orders of the court were that SHK Trustee Company Limited was entitled to judgment for unpaid rent and operating expenses, interest, removal and reinstatement costs, and legal costs. The defendants’ counterclaims were dismissed. Costs were to be determined based on the submissions filed by the parties within specified timeframes.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi