Shepherd v Wood Northland 2011 Limited (in liquidation)

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WHANGAREI REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA WHANGĀREI TERENGA PARĀOA ROHE

CIV-2017-488-000097 [2017] NZHC 3023

UNDER the District Courts Act 2016, s 124

IN THE MATTER

of an appeal against a decision of the
District Court of Whangarei

BETWEEN

JENNIFER MARY SHEPHERD Appellant

AND

WOOD NORTHLAND 2011 LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) AND THOMAS LEE RODEWALD

Respondents

Hearing: 4 December 2017

Counsel:

JA Browne for Appellant
TM Braun and MK Brady for Respondents

Judgment:

7 December 2017

JUDGMENT OF DOWNS J

This judgment was delivered by me on Thursday, 7 December 2017 at 11 am pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors/Counsel:

Henderson Reeves Lawyers, Whangarei.

Whitfield Braun Ltd, Hamilton.

SHEPHERD v WOOD NORTHLAND 2011 LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) [2017] NZHC 3023 [7 December 2017]

The appeal

[1]      On 24 July 2017 Judge D J McDonald found Ms Jennifer Shepherd liable to repay Wood Northland 2011 Ltd (Wood Northland 2011) and its liquidator $40,000.1

Ms Shepherd received the money in $20,000 payments on 2 and 16 April 2012.  The Judge concluded the liquidator had established the restitutionary claim of “money had and received”.   The Judge considered it unnecessary to determine other causes of action.  Ms Shepherd appeals.2   She contends the Judge was wrong to conclude she was required to repay the money. Her central appeal ground invites attention to when Wood Northland 2011 became insolvent, and alleged prejudice arising from the late introduction of evidence on this subject.

[2]      For reasons explained below, I consider the precise timing of Wood Northland

2011’s insolvency is something of a red herring, whereas incontrovertible insolvency of another company—Bay Lumber Ltd (Bay Lumber)—has significance.

The facts as found by the Judge

[3]      Ms Shepherd is the partner of Mr Martin Nicholls.   They have been in a relationship since August 2011.  Ms Shepherd is a chiropractor.  On 8 February 2012

Ms Shepherd incorporated Bay Chiropractic Ltd, of which Ms Shepherd was both director and shareholder.

[4]      In 2002 Mr Nicholls and his then wife, Ms Giacomelli, incorporated Bay Lumber.  Mr Nicholls was a director; so too Ms Giacomelli between 2004 and 2011. Bay Lumber was a sawmilling company.  It operated a mill in Kerikeri.

[5]      In 2010 Mr Nicholls incorporated Wood Northland Ltd (Wood Northland), and was its sole shareholder and director.  Wood Northland bought green or freshly sawn

timber from Bay Lumber, processed it, and on-sold it to wholesalers.

1      Wood Northland 2011 Ltd v Shepherd [2017] NZDC 15049.

2      The appeal is governed by Austin, Nichols & Co v Stichting Lodestar [2007] NZSC 103, [2008] 2

NZLR 141.

[6]      On 11 October 2011 Mr Nicholls and his father incorporated Wood Northland

2011.  Mr Nicholls was its director; his father the sole shareholder.  Wood Northland

2011 was incorporated “to ensure ... any transactions of that company could be hidden from Mr Martin Nicholls’ wife, with whom he had separated”.3   The new company took over the business of Wood Northland.4    Bay Lumber was in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Shepherd v Wood Northland 2011 Limited (in liquidation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 3023
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Shepherd v Wood Northland 2011 Limited (in liquidation), the High Court of New Zealand dealt with an appeal against a decision of the District Court, which found Jennifer Mary Shepherd liable to repay Wood Northland 2011 Ltd (Wood Northland 2011) and its liquidator $40,000. Shepherd received the money in two payments of $20,000 on 2 and 16 April 2012. The District Court judge concluded the liquidator had established the restitutionary claim of "money had and received." The central issue in the appeal was whether Shepherd was required to repay the money, with her argument focusing on the timing of Wood Northland 2011’s insolvency and alleged prejudice arising from the late introduction of evidence on this subject.

The court found that the precise timing of Wood Northland 2011’s insolvency was not a necessary ingredient of the cause of action, as the claim for money had and received was established on an agency basis. Wood Northland 2011 acted as an agent for Bay Lumber, which was in incontrovertible insolvency, to collect money owing to it. The money paid to Shepherd was either from the sale of timber owned by Bay Lumber or otherwise payable to it. As such, the money paid to Shepherd was not hers, and the money should have been paid to Bay Lumber, which in turn would have been available to its creditors. Wood Northland 2011 paid the money to Shepherd without any consideration on her part within a few weeks of Bay Lumber being placed in liquidation. This established the cause of action for money had and received, as the retention of the money would unjustly enrich Shepherd, who had no right to retain it.

Additionally, Shepherd’s defence under the Companies Act was dismissed. The court found that Shepherd had not established the second and third limbs of the defence, which required her to prove that she did not suspect Wood Northland 2011 was, or would become, insolvent and that she had a reasonably held belief the payment of the money to her would not be set aside. The court concluded that a person in Shepherd’s position would have been suspicious that the money was being paid to her to defeat creditors of her partner’s company. As a result, the appeal was dismissed, and the original decision of the District Court was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established