Shehata v Director of Proceedings

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

NOTE: PUBLICATION OF NAME OF COMPLAINANT PROHIBITED BY S 98 OF THE HEALTH PRACTITIONERS COMPETENCE ASSURANCE ACT

2003

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND PALMERSTON NORTH REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE PAPAIOEA ROHE

CIV-2018-454-31

[2019] NZHC 615

BETWEEN

NASSER SHEHATA

Appellant

AND

THE DIRECTOR OF PROCEEDINGS

Respondent

Hearing: 30 August 2018

Appearances:

W G Manning for Appellant

K M Eckersley and J V Herschell for Respondent

Judgment:

28 March 2019


JUDGMENT OF GRICE J


[1]    Dr Shehata is a consultant gynaecologist and obstetrician. The Health Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal (the Tribunal) found him guilty of professional misconduct under the Health Practitioners Competency Assurance Act 2003 (HPCA Act).1

[2]    Dr Shehata appeals the three-month suspension which was part of the penalty imposed on him.2 On 24 April 2018, the Court granted Dr Shehata’s application to stay his suspension pending determination of this appeal.


1      Health Practitioners Competency Assurance Act 2003, s 100(1)(a) and (b).

2      Director of Proceedings v Shehata HPDT 958/MED 17/396D, 16 March 2018.

NASSER SHEHATA v THE DIRECTOR OF PROCEEDINGS [2019] NZHC 615 [28 March 2019]

Background

[3]    The factual background is well summarised in the Tribunal decision as follows:3

9.[The patient]4 was referred by her general practitioner to Dr Shehata, the letter referring to [the patient]’s worrying for simple reasons and anxiety and other relevant matters, the clinical problem being “post coital bleeding for … assessment and opinion and management”.

10.[The patient] consulted with Dr Shehata on 17 March 2015 and it was recommended that she have a diagnostic hysteroscopy, dilatation and curettage, an endometrial biopsy and insertion of a Mirena. [The patient] had had an IUD previously and said that she told Dr Shehata that she had not had any problems but did not want another one. A Request for Surgical Treatment/Procedure form  was  filled  in  by Dr Shehata. In his Section  C  in  the  Procedure  to  be  performed Dr Shehata wrote: “… + Mirena insertion”. The remainder of that form was then completed by [the patient] later, at the time of the procedure and she deleted those words from the form and also wrote the word “Mirena” in the section: “I do/do not give permission for …” Because there was no deletion in the expression that was ambiguous.

11.There was disputed evidence before the Tribunal about the discussions between [the patient] and Dr Shehata concerning the Mirena, and the reasons behind inclusion of insertion of the Mirena on the consent form at a later date, but the Tribunal does not need to resolve those issues. This is because on 4 May 2015 when [the patient] attended for the proposed surgery and while she was in the ward prior to surgery she expressly deleted from the consent form reference to insertion of the Mirena. Dr Shehata acknowledged that [the patient] informed him that day that she did not want to have the Mirena and that she reiterated that when he advised her that what was then…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Shehata v Director of Proceedings and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NZHC 615
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

- Parties: The appellant is Dr Nasser Shehata, a consultant gynaecologist and obstetrician. The respondent is the Director of Proceedings.

- Nature of the dispute: Dr Shehata appeals the three-month suspension which was part of the penalty imposed on him by the Health Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal (the Tribunal) under the Health Practitioners Competency Assurance Act 2003 (HPCA Act). The Tribunal found Dr Shehata guilty of professional misconduct for inserting a Mirena into a patient without her informed consent.

- Court: The High Court of New Zealand, Palmerston North Registry.

- Legal issues: The legal issues the court was required to decide were whether the three-month suspension imposed on Dr Shehata was excessive, out of proportion, unduly punitive, unfair, unreasonable, inconsistent with penalties imposed in similar cases, and not the least restrictive penalty that could reasonably be imposed.

- Court's reasoning and outcome: The court found that the grounds of appeal were not made out and dismissed the appeal. The court agreed with the Tribunal's decision that the three-month suspension was an appropriate penalty considering the gravity of Dr Shehata's actions, his lack of insight, and the need to maintain professional standards and protect the public.

- Final orders: The appeal is dismissed. The orders of the Tribunal are confirmed. Costs are to be determined according to the specified timeline.