IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE
CIV-2023-404-2074
[2025] NZHC 808
BETWEEN SHAMARIAH CONSULTANCY LTD
First Plaintiff
AND
ROBERT GRANT DARBY
Second Plaintiff
NEW ZEALAND EGG GROUP LTD
First DefendantNICHOLAS JOHN BENNIK and
CULLINANE STEELE TRUSTEES (2020)LTD as trustees of the NJ BENNIK TRUST Second Defendants
Hearing: On the papers Appearances:
E Taia for the Second Plaintiff
J Land / S Jeffs for the Second Defendants
Judgment:
7 April 2025
JUDGMENT OF GARDINER J
(Costs)
This judgment was delivered by me on 7 April 2025 at 3:00pm pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules
Registrar/Deputy Registrar
Solicitors:
Franklin Law, Pukekohe
Cullinane Steele Lawyers, Levin Bankside Chambers, Auckland
SHAMARIAH CONSULTANCY LTD v NEW ZEALAND EGG GROUP LTD [2025] NZHC 808 [7 April 2025]
[1] On 30 September 2024, I dismissed the second defendants’ application for summary judgment or strike out of the second plaintiff’s claim.1
[2] The second defendants, the trustees of the NJ Bennik Trust (trustees), now seeks costs.
[3] Robert Darby, the second plaintiff, also seeks costs and denies that the trustees are entitled to costs.
Application for summary judgment and strike out
[4] The trustees sought summary judgment or strike out of Mr Darby’s claim against them that they hold 22,500 shares on trust for him pursuant to an institutional constructive trust. This claim was the sixth cause of action in the statement of claim.
[5] After reviewing the facts, I accepted that the pleaded claim against the trustees based on an institutional constructive trust could not succeed. However, I was not persuaded that Mr Darby did not have a claim of any kind against the trustees. Therefore, I declined to enter summary judgment or strike out the cause of action and gave Mr Darby leave to replead the cause of action in light of the discussion in the judgment.
The trustees’ submissions
[6] Since my judgment, Mr Darby has filed an amended statement of claim abandoning the cause of action in constructive trust and advancing two new causes of action, for breach of contract and misrepresentation. Accordingly, the trustees submit that they are entitled to 2B scale costs, or that costs should lie where they fall or be reserved until the substantive hearing.
[7] In support of their submission they are entitled to 2B costs, the trustees say they were more successful considering the completely amended statement of claim. The trustees say that the exercise of the Court’s discretion to grant leave to amend the pleading, rather than striking it out, does not affect their entitlement to costs to the
1 Shamariah Consultancy Ltd v NZ Egg Group Ltd [2024] NZHC 2771.
extent this signalled that the claim was fundamentally untenable and could not succeed. This is also evidenced by the amended statement of claim, which has abandoned the constructive trust claim in its entirety in favour of claims in breach of contract and misrepresentation.
[8] Alternatively, the trustees submit that…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Shamariah Consultancy Ltd v New Zealand Egg Group Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2025] NZHC 808
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The trustees submitted that they were entitled to 2B scale costs, or that costs should lie where they fall or be reserved until the substantive hearing. They argued that the exercise of the Court’s discretion to grant leave to amend the pleading, rather than striking it out, did not affect their entitlement to costs to the extent this signalled that the claim was fundamentally untenable and could not succeed. The trustees submitted that the second plaintiff could not be seen as truly successful considering his entirely amended claim. Alternatively, the trustees submitted that costs should be reserved pending final determination of the substantive litigation. The second plaintiff submitted that he was plainly the successful party and was thus entitled to costs in the ordinary way. Alternatively, he submitted that costs should lie where they fall as the trustees should have anticipated that leave to amend the pleadings was a possible outcome following their application. Also in alternative, the second plaintiff submitted that costs should be reserved.
The court accepted that on a superficial level, the second plaintiff was the successful party in that he managed to avoid summary judgment or strike out. However, the court accepted the trustees' submission that the second plaintiff cannot truly be defined as the successful party, considering he has completely changed his position in light of the court's conclusion that his claim could not succeed as pleaded. Weighing these considerations, the court is of the view that the trustees are entitled to their costs. The trustees would not have been put to the cost of bringing the application for summary judgment/strike out had the second plaintiff appropriately pleaded his claim, as he has now done, following the court's judgment.
Accordingly, the court orders the second plaintiff to pay 2B scale costs as sought by the trustees, in the amount of $7,648 along with disbursements of $650.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi