Sew Hoy v Sew Hoy

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND CA48/00
CA96/00
BETWEEN JUSTIN SEW HOY

First Appellant

AND JOYCE SEW HOY

Second Appellant

AND DONALD SEW HOY

Third Appellant

AND JENNIE SEW HOY

Fourth Appellant

AND PETER HERBERT CHRISTOPHER SEW HOY AND PETER WING HO CHIN

Respondents

Hearing: 26 September 2000
Coram: Keith J
Blanchard J
McGrath J
Appearances: R J Asher QC for Appellants
D J More for Respondents
Judgment: 6 November 2000

JUDGMENTS OF THE COURT

Judgments

Paras No

Keith J  [1]
Blanchard J  [2] – [51]
McGrath J  [52] – [73]

KEITH J

  1. I have had the advantage of reading in draft the judgments prepared by Blanchard J and McGrath J.  I agree with them both and with the result and order set out in the judgment of Blanchard J.

BLANCHARD J

  1. This appeal relates to an offer made by the Crown to members of the Sew Hoy family in 1992 pursuant to s40 of the Public Works Act 1981.  Land which had been taken under the Public Works Act 1928 was no longer required by the Crown for a public work.  In terms of s40(2) the Crown was obliged to offer to sell it by private contract “to the person from whom it was acquired or to the successor of that person” (i.e. to the person entitled to the land under the will or intestacy of that person (subs(5)).  The “person” from whom the land was acquired was a family partnership which had long since been dissolved.  The issue on this appeal is whether in such circumstances any fiduciary duties were owed to one another by the former partners or their successors in relation to the Crown’s offer.

  2. The appeal is against a decision of Chisholm J in the High Court at Dunedin on 9 February 2000 refusing relief to the appellants for the actions of the trustees of the estate of a deceased former partner in taking up the offer under s40 without fully consulting the appellants and without revealing certain information about the land.  That information (a valuation and a letter concerning zoning from the local authority) related to its potential for subdivision and showed that the land might be worth much more than the Crown’s offer price.

Background

  1. In 1973 three Sew Hoy brothers, Justin, Duncan and Donald, and their respective wives, Joyce, Shirley and Jennie, purchased approximately 70 ha of land at Cromwell as tenants in common in equal shares.  It is accepted that the Sew Hoys held the land in partnership.  It was the only asset of that partnership.  Three years later the Crown compulsorily acquired the land for works associated with the Clutha Valley hydro development.  Title to the land passed to the Crown in 1976 upon the registration of a proclamation.

  2. One of the partners, Shirley Sew Hoy, died in 1977.  That event dissolved the partnership in accordance with s36 of the Partnership Act 1908.  Shirley’s son, Dr Peter Sew Hoy, the firstnamed respondent, and a solicitor, Peter Chin, the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sew Hoy v Sew Hoy and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] NZCA 314
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Sew Hoy family, through their legal representatives, appealed against a decision of the High Court at Dunedin. The appeal was dismissed. The former owners of land acquired by the Crown for public works in 1976 sought to establish that the trustees of the estate of a deceased former partner owed them a fiduciary duty in relation to an offer by the Crown under section 40 of the Public Works Act 1981 to sell back the land. The trustees had taken up the offer without fully consulting the appellants and without revealing information about the land which showed that it might be worth much more than the Crown's offer price. The Court found that the offer by the Crown pursuant to s40 of the Public Works Act was a new transaction. The right to have the land offered back was not a partnership asset: it was not definite that the land would ever be offered back. Any other interpretation would give rise to the “extraordinary situation” that partnerships whose land had been taken under the Public Works Act would effectively linger indefinitely. In the absence of continuing duties of partnership, the Court could not find any basis for the appellants’ claim that the respondents owed them a fiduciary duty to disclose all relevant information relating to the land. The appeal was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.