Scott v Sovereign Assurance Company Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND
CA452/2010
[2011] NZCA 214

BETWEEN  DOUGLAS NORMAN SCOTT
Appellant

AND  SOVEREIGN ASSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED
Respondent

Hearing:         5 April 2011

Court:             Harrison, Stevens and Wild JJ

Counsel:         P W Michalik and P P Silva for Appellant
J G Miles QC and B J Burt for Respondent

Judgment:      24 May 2011 at 3.00 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The appeal is allowed.

BThe respondent must pay the appellant’s costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis plus the usual disbursements.  The appellant is entitled to costs in the High Court plus disbursements fixed by the Registrar.  If the parties cannot agree, costs are to be determined by the High Court Judge.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Stevens J)

Introduction

  1. The appellant, Mr Scott, was granted leave by this Court to argue the question whether the High Court was correct in deciding that this proceeding against the respondent insurer (Sovereign) should be struck out on the basis that it was out of time.[1]  In the High Court, Sovereign was successful in its appeal against a refusal by the District Court to strike out a claim brought by Mr Scott under a critical illness insurance policy.[2]  The claim related to a stroke suffered by Mr Scott.  The Judge in the High Court held that the claim had been commenced after the expiry of the limitation period prescribed by the Limitation Act 1950.

Factual background

The policy

[2]Sovereign Assurance Company Ltd v Scott HC Rotorua CIV-2008-463-909, 30 September 2009 [Sovereign (HC)].

  1. In January 1994, Mr Scott took out a critical illness cover insurance policy with The Prudential Assurance Company New Zealand Ltd (Prudential), Sovereign’s predecessor.  The policy provided a benefit of $100,000 in the event of Mr Scott suffering a stroke.  The front cover of the policy stated:

    Your Critical Illness Cover policy will pay you a lump sum on medical diagnosis of:

    After 90 days from the policy’s commencement:

    ...

    -      Stroke

  2. The term stroke was defined in the policy as follows:

    A cerebrovascular incident producing significant permanent neurological sequelae. This requires evidence of infarction of brain tissue, intracranial or subarachnoid haemorrhage or embolisation from an extra-cranial source. Transient ischaemic attacks, cerebral symptoms due to migraine, cerebral injury resulting from trauma or hypoxia or vascular disorders affecting the eye or optic nerve are specifically excluded.

  3. In terms of claims, the documentation accompanying the policy stated:

    4.    CLAIMS PROCEDURE

    Please read carefully the claims procedure described in your policy and note that claims should be lodged within 30 days of an insured event or first diagnosis of an insured event.

  4. The policy itself dealt with benefits and claims as follows:

    1.    Benefits

    Critical Illness Benefit

    1.1     The CRITICAL ILLNESS BENEFIT shown in the Appendix to Schedule 1 will be paid where other conditions in this policy are met if:

    (a)After the cover for an Insured has been…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Scott v Sovereign Assurance Company Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZCA 214
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Scott v Sovereign Assurance Company Limited, Mr. Scott appealed against the High Court's decision to strike out his claim against the insurer, Sovereign, for failing to pay a benefit under a critical illness insurance policy. The Court of Appeal found that the claim was not time-barred and that it should not have been struck out. The Court considered the terms of the insurance policy and the medical evidence provided by Mr. Scott and his medical practitioners. The critical issue was whether the insured event occurred when Mr. Scott suffered a subarachnoid haemorrhage or when the neurological sequelae arising from that event became significant and permanent. The Court concluded that it was arguable that the insured event did not occur until the sequelae became significant and permanent, which may not have happened until some years after the initial event. Therefore, the Court of Appeal held that the claim was not out of time and remitted the case to the District Court for hearing.

The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal and held that the High Court was incorrect to strike out Mr. Scott's claim on the ground that it was out of time. The Court of Appeal concluded that it was arguable that the insured event did not occur until the neurological sequelae arising from Mr. Scott's subarachnoid haemorrhage became significant and permanent, which may not have happened until some years after the initial event. The Court of Appeal found that the English cases relied upon by the High Court did not assist in the analysis of this New Zealand contingency insurance policy for a fixed benefit payable under a critical illness policy. The Court of Appeal held that a determination as to whether, and if so when, the neurological sequelae consequent on Mr. Scott's cerebrovascular incident became significant and permanent is a determination that can only be made on the evidence at trial. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal and remitted the case to the District Court for hearing. The Court of Appeal also ordered that the respondent must pay the appellant's costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements. The appellant is also entitled to costs in the High Court plus disbursements fixed by the Registrar. If the parties cannot agree, costs are to be determined by the High Court Judge.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established