IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-A-TARA ROHE
CIV-2019-485-376
[2019] NZHC 1908
BETWEEN MARY ELIZABETH SCOTT
First Plaintiff
JOHN ROBERT DOUGLAS
Second PlaintiffGRAY STRATTON THOMPSON
Third PlaintiffAND
ANZ BANK NEW ZEALAND LIMITED
Defendant
On the papers: Counsel:
J B M Smith QC and F J Cuncannon for Plaintiffs M Smith and I Rosic for Defendant
J Tibshraeny in person
Judgment:
7 August 2019
JUDGMENT OF CHURCHMAN J
[1] By email dated 16 July 2019, Jenée Tibshraeny, a journalist with “interest.co.nz” asked the Registrar to provide her with a copy of the statement of claim in this matter. This request was forwarded by the Registrar to counsel for both the plaintiffs and defendant.
[2] Counsel for both the plaintiffs and defendant filed separate memoranda dated 22 July 2019. Both opposed the application.
SCOTT v ANZ BANK NEW ZEALAND LIMITED [2019] NZHC 1908 [7 August 2019]
[3] The position adopted by counsel for the plaintiffs was that the application was premature and that any such application was best dealt with in the context of the representative orders application.1
[4] The memorandum filed by counsel for the defendant was more comprehensive. It submitted that the request should be declined for the following reasons:
(a)first, the request does not comply with the minimum procedural requirement set out in r 11 of the Senior Courts (Access to Court Documents) Rules 2017 (“the Rules”);
(b)second, the Court’s general practice has been not to allow access to the pleadings until, at a minimum, both parties’ pleadings are available to allow a balance reporting. The application is premature on any view; and
(c)third, at this very early stage of the proceeding, it is not appropriate to release the statement of claim, given the serious and untested nature of the allegations made in it, and the need to adequately protect the orderly and fair administration of justice.
[5]The legal propositions relied on were:
(a)the application is governed by the Rules;
(b)the statement of claim is not part of the formal Court record (r 8), and interest.co.nz is not a party to the proceeding (r 9). Accordingly, the applicable rules are rr 11 to 14;
(c)rule 12 sets out the mandatory relevant considerations for the Court in considering access;
1 In reliance on Strathboss Kiwifruit Limited v Seeka Kiwifruit Industries Limited [2015] NZHC 1596 at [77].
(d)under r 13(a), as this application is made before the substantive hearing stage “the protection of confidentiality and privacy interests and the orderly and fair administration of justice may require that access to documents be limited”; and
(e)the exercise is evaluative, not discretionary: Crimson Consulting Ltd v Berry [2018] NZCA 460 at [18]-[31].
[6] The memorandum noted that the applicant had failed to give reasons for asking for access to the document, or indicate the purpose for which access was sought, thereby failing to comply with r 11(2)(c) of the Rules.
[7] Counsel for the defendant agreed with counsel for…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Scott v ANZ Bank New Zealand Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] NZHC 1908
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues involved the application of the Senior Courts (Access to Court Documents) Rules 2017 and the general practice of the court not to allow access to pleadings until both parties' substantive pleadings were available. The court also had to consider the untested and potentially damaging allegations made in the statement of claim. The plaintiffs and the defendant both opposed the application, with the plaintiffs arguing that it was premature and the defendant arguing that the request did not comply with the rules and that the allegations were too serious to be released at this stage.
The court found that the application was premature and that the general practice of the court was not to allow access to pleadings until both parties had filed substantive pleadings. The court also found that the untested and damaging nature of the allegations against the defendant warranted limiting access to the pleadings until after the close of pleadings date. The court declined the application but noted that it could be renewed at a later stage.
This case highlights the importance of balancing the principles of open justice and the protection of confidentiality and privacy interests, particularly in cases with untested and potentially damaging allegations. The court's decision to decline the application at this stage demonstrates its commitment to protecting the integrity of the judicial process and ensuring that parties have an opportunity to test the allegations made against them before they are made public.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi