Schenker AG and Schenker (NZ) Limited v Commerce Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND
CA162/2012
[2012] NZCA 245

BETWEEN  SCHENKER AG AND SCHENKER (NZ) LIMITED
Appellants

AND  THE COMMERCE COMMISSION
First Respondent

AND  AIR NEW ZEALAND LIMITED
Second Respondent

AND  CATHAY PACIFIC AIRWAYS LIMITED
Third Respondent

AND  EMIRATES
Fourth Respondent

AND  JAPAN AIRLINES INTERNATIONAL CO LIMITED
Fifth Respondent

AND  KOREAN AIRLINES CO LIMITED
Sixth Respondent

AND  MALAYSIAN AIRLINE SYSTEM BERHAD LIMITED
Seventh Respondent

AND  SINGAPORE AIRLINES LIMITED & SINGAPORE AIRLINES CARGO PTE LIMITED
Eighth Respondent

AND  THAI AIRWAYS INTERNATIONAL PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED
Ninth Respondent

AND  QANTAS AIRWAYS LIMITED
Tenth Respondent

AND  BRITISH AIRWAYS PLC
Eleventh Respondent

Hearing:         21 May 2012

Court:             O'Regan P, Wild and Miller JJ

Counsel:         P N Collins for Appellants
J L Land for Second to Ninth Respondents

Judgment:      14 June 2012 at 11.30 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe second to ninth respondents’ challenge to the Court’s jurisdiction to hear the appeal is dismissed.

BCosts are reserved.

_______________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Miller J)

Introduction

  1. The Commerce Commission brought proceedings against the respondent airlines, alleging that they and others fixed prices of international air cargo services.  The airlines were sued separately, and the proceedings were all entered on the commercial list at Auckland.  Those against the tenth and eleventh respondents ended in judgment.  The trial of those against the other respondents is to resume in February 2013.

  2. The present appellants, whom we will call Schenker, are not parties to any of the proceedings.  They are freight forwarders who say they “may have suffered loss as a result of the alleged conduct” in the proceedings.  They seek evidence.  They want to inspect and copy the High Court files, including pleadings and evidence and the agreed bundle of documents.

  3. Schenker applied by letter to the Registrar of the High Court at Auckland for directions under High Court Rules 3.9 and 3.13 allowing them to access the files.  The application was referred to the parties, who objected, so a hearing was held before Asher J, who is a commercial list Judge and also the trial Judge.  The Judge dismissed Schenker’s application in a judgment dated 24 February 2012.[1]

  4. Schenker filed an appeal which met with the response that, because the judgment was an interlocutory decision in proceedings entered on the commercial list, leave must first be obtained under s 24G of the Judicature Act 1908. 

  5. This judgment answers the preliminary question whether, leave having not been sought, this Court has jurisdiction to entertain the appeal.  The answer turns on the meaning of “interlocutory decision” in s 24G. 

Appeals from interlocutory decisions in commercial list proceedings

  1. We begin by outlining the relevant provisions of the Judicature Act and High Court Rules.  Appeals from interlocutory decisions of the High Court are normally brought as of right, although this Court may refuse to hear them before trial.[2]  But appeals from interlocutory decisions in proceedings entered on the commercial list are exceptional.  The Judicature Act…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Schenker AG and Schenker (NZ) Limited v Commerce Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZCA 245
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Schenker AG and Schenker (NZ) Limited appealed against a decision of the High Court at Auckland which dismissed their application for access to court files in proceedings brought by the Commerce Commission against several airlines for price fixing of international air cargo services. The airlines, who were respondents to the proceedings, opposed Schenker’s application. The Court of Appeal considered whether it had jurisdiction to hear the appeal, given that the proceedings were entered on the commercial list and the High Court’s decision was interlocutory in nature. The Court of Appeal held that the judgment was not interlocutory in nature for the purposes of section 24G of the Judicature Act 1908 and the Court of Appeal had jurisdiction to hear the appeal. The Court of Appeal dismissed the respondents’ challenge to its jurisdiction and reserved costs.

The central issue in this appeal was whether the Court of Appeal had jurisdiction to hear the appeal given that the proceedings were entered on the commercial list and the High Court’s decision was interlocutory in nature. Section 24G of the Judicature Act 1908 provides that an appeal cannot lie from an interlocutory decision of the High Court in respect of any proceeding entered on a commercial list unless leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal is given by the High Court or, if leave is refused there, this Court. The Court of Appeal held that the judgment was not interlocutory in nature for the purposes of section 24G and the Court of Appeal had jurisdiction to hear the appeal. The Court of Appeal held that a decision on an informal request for access under rule 3.9 of the High Court Rules is not an interlocutory application as defined in the Judicature Act and High Court Rules and an order on an access request under rule 3.9 is not interlocutory either. The Court of Appeal held that this is not the end of the matter because an interlocutory decision need not always follow an interlocutory application made in the prescribed form. However, the Court of Appeal held that a request for access need not delay the trial, to which it has no direct connection and form cannot be decisive. The Court of Appeal held that it accepts that this analysis means the less formal the application for access the less circumscribed the right of appeal but that criticism holds good for commercial list proceedings only. The Court of Appeal held that the challenge to jurisdiction extends to the closed proceedings and jurisdiction having been contested, the Court must be satisfied that it exists. The Court of Appeal held that the decision was not interlocutory vis-a-vis the tenth and eleventh respondents, so Schenker need not seek leave under s 24G with respect to the closed proceeding. The Court of Appeal held that although rule 3.13 confers no right of access and speaks of applications not requests, its procedure is relevantly indistinguishable from that under rule 3.9, so the distinction drawn above between requests for access and interlocutory applications applies equally to rule 3.13. The Court of Appeal held that it concludes that the judgment was not an interlocutory decision for purposes of s 24G, so Schenker need not seek leave to appeal and accordingly, this Court has jurisdiction to hear the present appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established