| IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND |
| CA427/2015 [2016] NZCA 54 |
| BETWEEN | YASODHARA DA SILVEIRA SCARBOROUGH |
| AND | MICRON SECURITY PRODUCTS LIMITED |
| CA578/2015 | |
| BETWEEN | YASODHARA DA SILVEIRA SCARBOROUGH |
| AND | MICRON SECURITY PRODUCTS LIMITED |
| Court: | Stevens, Cooper and Kós JJ |
Counsel: | Applicant in person |
Judgment: (On the papers) | 9 March 2016 at 12.00 pm |
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
ALeave to appeal in CA427/2015 and CA578/2015 is declined.
BThe applicant is to pay the respondent’s costs, on each application, for a standard application on a band A basis together with usual disbursements.
____________________________________________________________________
REASONS OF THE COURT
(Given by Kós J)
Ms Scarborough applies for leave to appeal against two costs decisions in the Employment Court. No appeal against the substantive judgments of that Court is sought.
Ms Scarborough was employed by Micron Security Products Ltd (Micron) as an assembler of medical emergency response products for three months. She was made redundant on 16 December 2013. She made a claim in the Employment Relations Authority that this was an unjustified dismissal. The Authority found the redundancy dismissal was substantively justified, but awarded Ms Scarborough $750 for humiliation and loss of dignity because Micron had not provided Ms Scarborough with information about its proposal to make her redundant in advance. Ms Scarborough challenged the Authority’s decision to the Employment Court, which dismissed the challenge and various related applications and awarded costs.
It is convenient to set out the relevant procedural history before addressing the matters on which leave to appeal is sought.
(a)11 June 2014: the Authority determined Ms Scarborough’s dismissal was substantively justified but procedurally flawed, and awarded $750 as “distress compensation” to Ms Scarborough.[1] No costs were awarded.
[1]Scarborough v Micron Security Products Ltd [2014] NZERA Auckland 231.
(b)7 July 2014: Ms Scarborough filed a notice electing to challenge the Authority’s determination in the Employment Court on a de novo basis pursuant to s 179 of the Employment Relations Act 2000.
(c)8 August 2014: Ms Scarborough’s application for a stay of the Authority’s determination pending the Employment Court proceedings was dismissed.[2] Costs were not expressly reserved.
[2]Scarborough v Micron Security Products Ltd ARC61/14, 8 August 2014 (Minute of Chief Judge Colgan).
(d)25 September 2014: interlocutory judgment of Chief Judge Colgan declining an application to join Micron’s directors as defendants, declining an application for judicial review of the Authority, declining an application to remit the proceeding to the Authority for investigation, and making timetabling directions.[3] Costs were reserved.
[3]Scarborough v Micron Security Products Ltd [2014] NZEmpC 183.
(e)19 November 2014: interlocutory judgment of Judge Perkins declining a second application to remit the matter to the Authority and dismissing a complaint about disclosure of documents.[4] Costs were reserved.
[4]Scarborough v Micron Security Products Ltd [2014] NZEmpC 216.
(f)30 March 2015: substantive judgment of Judge Inglis dismissing challenge to Authority’s determination and declining a third application to remit the matter to the Authority.[5] Costs were reserved.
[5]Scarborough v Micron Security…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Scarborough v Micron Security Products Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] NZCA 54
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court had to decide whether there were any arguable points of law sufficient to grant leave to appeal. For the first application (CA427/2015), the court considered whether Judge Inglis was obliged to stay proceedings, whether costs were properly before the court, and whether the court should have reconsidered the costs judgment. The court found no legal obligation to stay proceedings, that the Employment Court had jurisdiction over the costs, and that the proper avenue for challenging the costs decision was an application for leave to appeal.
For the second application (CA578/2015), the court examined questions about the substantive justification of the redundancy, whether Micron's counsel acted improperly, whether the Court Registry's handling of a memorandum caused injustice, and the legal basis of an application for rehearing. The court concluded that the first three questions did not relate to the relevant costs decision and raised factual issues rather than questions of law. The fourth question, concerning the application for rehearing, was deemed to have a legal basis, and no error of principle was found in the costs award.
Both applications for leave to appeal were declined. The court found no arguable points of law of general or public importance and no other reason for referring the costs decisions to the Court of Appeal. Consequently, Scarborough was ordered to pay Micron's costs for both applications.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi