Sax v Dempsey Wood Civil Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2011-404-8007 [2013] NZHC 1126

BETWEEN  PETER SAX AND LINDSAY FRANCIS GRACE AS TRUSTEES OF THE PETER SAX NO. 2 TRUST

Plaintiffs

ANDDEMPSEY WOOD CIVIL LIMITED Defendant

Hearing:         On the papers

Counsel:         B. Vautier - Counsel for Plaintiff

E. St John - Counsel for Defendant

Judgment:      22 May 2013

JUDGMENT AS TO COSTS OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE D.I. GENDALL

This judgment was delivered by me on 22nd day of May 2013 at 3.30 pm under r

11.5 of the High Court Rules.

.............................................................

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date: ...................................................

Solicitors:           Glaister Ennor, Solicitors, PO Box 63, Auckland

Alan Jones Law Partnership, PO Box 32249, Auckland

PETER SAX AND LINDSAY FRANCIS GRACE AS TRUSTEES OF THE PETER SAX NO. 2 TRUST V DEMPSEY WOOD CIVIL LIMITED HC AK CIV-2011-404-8007 [22 May 2013]

Introduction

[1]      This is a decision on a disputed issue of costs and disbursements.

[2]      The matter was before His Honour Associate Judge Faire for a costs decision when, on 7 May 2013 he issued a Minute for reasons set out therein, recusing himself.

[3]      Thereafter this matter was referred to me to give a decision of this Court on this issue of costs. A number of memoranda from counsel and further affidavits have been filed on the question of costs.  I have now had an opportunity to consider these, together with all the other material on the file for this proceeding, and give my decision on this costs question.

[4]      In this proceeding, Peter Sax and Lindsay Francis Grace as trustees of the Peter Sax No 2 Trust, (the plaintiffs), sought a declaration that a lease they entered into as landlords with Dempsey Wood Civil Limited, (the defendant), as tenant had been properly renewed. The defendant having originally opposed this application, eventually consented to the declaration sought being made.  On 27 September 2012

His Honour Justice Lang made an order by consent granting that declaration. The order declared specifically that there was a valid and enforceable renewal of the lease of the premises in question for a period of 5 years from 1 May 2009.   In making that order, His Honour Justice Lang noted that costs were reserved to be discussed between counsel and, in the event of disagreement, to be referred to this Court for decision.   Disagreement has occurred. The plaintiffs as the successful parties now seek an order for indemnity costs on this proceeding.

Background

[5]      On 29 September 2004, the plaintiffs as landlords and the defendant as tenant entered into a Deed of Lease (the Lease) for the commercial premises in question at Penrose, Auckland for a term of 5 years from 1 May 2004 with a right of renewal for

5 years. In April 2009, the parties’ agents negotiated for a renewal of the Lease. A

document titled “Deed of Variation” resulted, signed by agents for the parties.  It was dated 30 April 2009.

[6]      The dispute arose because the plaintiffs sought to enforce the renewal of the Lease…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sax v Dempsey Wood Civil Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 1126
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Sax v Dempsey Wood Civil Limited, the High Court of New Zealand, Auckland Registry, presided over by Associate Judge D.I. Gendall, dealt with a dispute over costs and disbursements following a declaration of a lease renewal. The plaintiffs, Peter Sax and Lindsay Francis Grace as trustees of the Peter Sax No. 2 Trust, sought a declaration that a lease they entered into with Dempsey Wood Civil Limited had been properly renewed. The defendant eventually conceded the renewal, leading to a consent order. The Court was then tasked with deciding the quantum of indemnity costs the plaintiffs could claim under the lease agreement, which stipulated that the tenant would pay the landlord's costs of enforcing the lease.

The plaintiffs claimed actual costs and disbursements totaling $48,800.00 for costs and $1,546.59 for disbursements. The defendant contested the reasonableness of these costs, arguing they were excessive and not properly incurred. They provided an expert's affidavit suggesting a much lower cost estimate and argued that the internal disbursement charge and costs related to the current costs application were not recoverable.

The Court assessed the reasonableness of the plaintiffs' costs, considering the nature of the work, the rates charged by the plaintiffs' solicitors, and the significance of the dispute. It concluded that the tasks undertaken were reasonably necessary and the charge-out rates were appropriate. The Court disallowed the 6% internal disbursement charge as it was not a specific and necessary expense related to the litigation. Regarding the costs of the costs application itself, the Court found the plaintiffs' claim excessive and reduced it from $13,500.00 to $3,000.00.

Ultimately, the Court awarded the plaintiffs indemnity costs of $36,135.00, deducting the disallowed internal disbursement charge and the reduced costs of the costs application from the total claimed. The plaintiffs' claim for disbursements was directed to be reconsidered and referred to the Registrar for approval.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established