Sawer v Satara Co-operative Group Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY

CIV-2011-441-715

BETWEEN  SHARLENE BRYANT AND DAVID SAWER

Applicant

ANDSATARA CO-OPERATIVE GROUP LIMITED

Respondent

CIV-2008-441-856 [2012] NZHC 156

AND BETWEEN            SATARA CO-OPERATIVE GROUP LIMITED

Plaintiff

ANDFUS LIMITED (IN LIQ) First Defendant

ANDSHARLENE BRYANT AND DAVID SAWER OF STAPLES RODWAY HAWKES BAY LTD AS LIQUIDATORS OF FUS LIMITED

Second Defendants

Hearing:         On the papers

(Heard at Napier)

Counsel:         J. Krebs for Applicant

H. Sutherland-Stacey for Respondent

Judgment:      30 January 2012 at 3:30 PM

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE D.I. GENDALL

This judgment was delivered by Associate Judge Gendall on 30 January 2012 at 3.30 pm under r 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

SB AND D SAWER V SATARA CO-OPERATIVE GROUP LIMITED HC NAP CIV-2011-441-715 30 January

2012

Solicitors:         Bramwell Grossman, Solicitors, PO Box 500, Napier

Sharp Tudhope, Lawyers, Private Bag 12020, Tauranga

Introduction

[1]      Before me is an application for costs relating to proceedings brought by the liquidators, Ms Bryant and Mr Sawyer, of Fus  Ltd  (in liquidation).   While the application  on  proceeding  CIV-2011-441-715  was  for  directions  concerning  the future  conduct  of  the  liquidation  and  it  was  not  filed  as  such,  it  is  properly considered  as  an  originating application:  r 19.4  of the High  Court  Rules.   The directions  sought  were  related  to  other  proceedings:  CIV-2008-441-856.    The plaintiff in those proceedings is Satara Co-Operative Group Ltd (Satara).   Those proceedings are taken against Fus Ltd, which was formerly known as Apollo Fruit Ltd.  Satara’s claim relates to an alleged failure on the part of Apollo Fruit Ltd to store and transport kiwifruit in Satara’s control pursuant to a contract between the two parties.  Satara’s claim is for $368,212.00 plus interest and costs.  After Satara initiated proceedings against Apollo, Apollo (by that time called Fus Ltd) was placed into liquidation.   Satara applied to have its full claim admitted for proof in the liquidation.  That application was declined by the liquidators.

[2]      Subsequently, in an amended statement of claim in proceeding CIV-2008-

441-856 filed in 2009, Satara applied to have that decision reversed under s 284 of the Companies Act 1993, and added the liquidators as second defendants to that proceeding.    That  application  was  opposed  by the liquidators.    Eventually,  that matter was resolved by consent on the basis that Satara would discontinue its claim against the liquidators and the matter would proceed against Fus Ltd (in liquidation), with the liquidators’ consent.  Therefore, if Satara was to succeed as against Fus Ltd (in liquidation), any judgment obtained would be accepted as a proved debt.  If Fus Ltd (in liquidation) did not defend the claim, Satara would need to proceed by way of formal proof.

[3]      On 11 June 2011, the liquidators received a report prepared by a Mr Errol W Hewett  (Mr  Hewett)  a  kiwifruit  storage  ―expert‖  that  suggested  Apollo/FUS Limited’s liability was no more than 10 per cent.  Accordingly, the liquidators made

an offer to Satara to accept for proof 10 per cent of the quantum claimed by it.  That offer  was  rejected.    The  liquidators  accordingly  on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sawer v Satara Co-operative Group Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 156
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand was presented with an application for costs related to proceedings brought by the liquidators of Fus Ltd, Ms Bryant and Mr Sawyer. Satara Co-Operative Group Ltd (Satara) sought indemnity, increased, or scale costs for expenses incurred in response to the liquidators' withdrawn application for directions in the liquidation of Fus Ltd. The liquidators opposed the application, requesting that costs be reserved until the substantive proceeding was resolved.

The court found that the liquidators' liability for costs in relation to this application was clear, as they had brought proceedings that required a response by Satara. Although the liquidators withdrew the application, costs had still been incurred by Satara. The court determined that Satara was entitled to scale costs, as the liquidators had not acted vexatiously, frivolously, improperly, or unnecessarily in commencing the proceedings. However, the court declined to award increased or indemnity costs, as the liquidators were acting on the basis of all the information available to them at the time.

The court ordered that Satara was to be awarded 2B costs and reasonable disbursements, amounting to $2,444.00 in costs and $8.90 in disbursements. The court certified the disbursement for the courier but not that for the online search, as the latter should be absorbed by a firm's overheads.