Savelio v R HC Wellington CRI 2007-485-8

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CRI 2007-485-8

MICHAEL XAVIOUR SAVELIO

Appellant

v

THE CROWN

Respondent

Hearing:         27 March 2007

Appearances: T Rickard-Simms for Appellant

C J Boshier for Respondent

Judgment:      28 March 2007

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF MILLER J

[1]      Mr  Savelio  appeals  against  a  sentence  of  two  years  and  six  months imprisonment on one charge of sexual connection with a girl aged 14 years, contrary to s.134(1) of the Crimes Act.

[2]      The summary of facts records that  Mr Savelio  met  the victim through a relative and began sending text messages to her, asserting that he wanted to be with her.  They began to exchange regular text messages and eventually started meeting alone.  This led to him performing oral sex on the victim on three separate occasions and ultimately to sexual intercourse on two occasions.  He was 31 at the time.  The

offending began in January 2006 and ended in March 2006.

SAVELIO V R HC WN CRI 2007-485-8  28 March 2007

[3]      Mr Savelio is described as a solo father of Samoan descent who until arrest had custody of one of his children and was in a relationship with a partner who is said  to  be  supportive  of  him.    His  own  family  background  was  difficult.    He explained his offending by maintaining that he loved the victim.  At interview with the probation officer, he accepted full responsibility and was remorseful.  He agreed to pay reparation of $2,860, and the probation officer recommended a non-custodial sentence.

[4]      The District Court had before it victim impact statements from the girl herself and also her mother.  The girl says that he made her feel happy at a time when she was upset, and that as a result of the incidents she has been out of school for two terms and was removed by her mother from the family environment to separate her from Mr Savelio.  Her mother confirmed the impact on her daughter socially and at school,  although  she  went  on  to  make  allegations  that  as  the  District  Court recognised, could not be taken into account against Mr Savelio.

[5]      Judge Everitt  had the benefit  of written submissions.    He  noted that the charge had been laid summarily, and that it carried a potential maximum penalty of up to ten years imprisonment.   The offending was inherently serious because  it involved taking advantage of an underaged female for the purpose of sexual gratification.  He noted the ages of the victim and Mr Savelio.  He would edit out of the victim impact statements those matters that were not appropriate; nonetheless, it was clear that the mother and the family of the victim had been devastated.   He referred to Mental Health Services correspondence and a psychiatric report stating that Mr Savelio  has had difficulties with depression and  had suffered childhood sexual abuse himself.

[6]      Turning to sentencing principles, the Judge observed that there is no tariff. Whilst imprisonment is the usual outcome there are exceptions, particularly where the offenders are younger than Mr…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Savelio v R HC Wellington CRI 2007-485-8 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NZHC 1703
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Michael Xavier Savelio appeals against his sentence of two years and six months imprisonment on one charge of sexual connection with a girl aged 14 years, contrary to s.134(1) of the Crimes Act. The appellant met the victim through a relative, began sending her text messages, and eventually engaged in sexual acts with her. The District Court imposed the sentence, noting the inherent seriousness of the offence due to the age disparity and breach of trust, and taking into account the victim impact statements and mitigating factors. The appellant argues that the sentence is manifestly excessive and that consideration should have been given to a non-custodial sentence.

The court begins by examining the starting point for the sentence, noting that there is no guideline judgment for this offence. The court considers several cases, including R v P, R v Crooks, R v Tomkinson, and R v Boyd. The court determines that a starting point of two and a half years imprisonment would have been appropriate, incorporating the abuse of trust, age disparity, and the element of grooming. The court finds that there was an element of double counting in this case, as the Judge referred to some of the same matters when dealing with aggravating factors after already taking them into account in the starting point. The court also finds that the discount for mitigating factors was too small, and that a full discount of up to one-third should have been given.

The court is satisfied that the resulting sentence was clearly excessive. The court adopts a starting point of two years, six months, and reduces the sentence by ten months for mitigating factors, resulting in a final sentence of 20 months imprisonment. The court agrees that imprisonment was inevitable, but that leave should be given to apply for home detention due to the appellant's acceptance of responsibility, remorse, and care for his son. The appeal is allowed, and a sentence of 20 months imprisonment is substituted. There will be leave to apply for home detention.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established