Sahar Ehsani Investment Limited v Sinclair

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2022-404-2080

[2024] NZHC 570

UNDER The Contempt of Court Act 2019

BETWEEN

SAHAR EHSANI INVESTMENT LIMITED

Applicant

AND

WARREN GRAEME SINCLAIR

First Respondent

RETYRED (2020) LIMITED

Second Respondent

Hearing: 7 March 2024

Appearances:

T Ashley for Applicant

G Simms for Respondent

Judgment:

7 March 2024

Reasons:

18 March 2024


JUDGMENT OF WOOLFORD J


This judgment was delivered by me on Monday, 18 March 2024 at 2:30 pm pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:Daniel Overton and Goulding (B Hantz), Auckland Wynn Williams (G Simms), Auckland

Counsel:            T Ashley, Auckland

SAHAR EHSANI INVESTMENT LIMITED v SINCLAIR [2024] NZHC 570 [7 March 2024]

[1]    This is an application under the Contempt of Court Act 2019 (the Act) for orders that:

(a)A warrant be issued committing the first respondent, Warren Graeme Sinclair, to a term of imprisonment as the Court considers it appropriate or, in the alternative, that a fine be imposed on Mr Sinclair, payable to the applicant, Sahar Ehsani Investment Limited (SEIL).

(b)A fine be imposed on the second respondent, Retyred (2020) Limited (Retyred), payable to SEIL.

(c)The respondents pay SEIL’s costs in this application.

[2]    SEIL  alleges  that  the  respondents  have  breached  Court  orders,  dated   24 November 2022 and 2 December 2022, to refrain from bringing tyres on to premises that were leased by Retyred at 177 Dominion Road, Red Hill, Auckland.

[3]    I heard the application on 7 March 2024, following which I dismissed the application, saying my reasons would follow in due course. These are my reasons.

Background

[4]    SEIL owns land at 177 Dominion Road, Red Hill, Auckland (the premises). It leased the premises to Retyred. The premises  consist of a fenced yard of about  7,500 square metres with a gated entrance from Dominion Road. SEIL also owns the neighbouring property, 179 Dominion Road, from which it runs an auto parts business.

[5]    SEIL leased the premises to  Retyred  under  an  agreement  to  lease  dated 28 February 2022. The term of the lease was five years, commencing 30 March 2022. The first respondent, Mr Sinclair, was the sole director and shareholder of Retyred when the agreement to lease was entered into. Mr Sinclair guaranteed Retyred’s obligations under the lease.

[6]    The agreement described the business use of the premises as “recycling tyres and show home display yard for modular house business”.

[7]    In proceedings commenced on 27 October 2022, SEIL made two substantive claims. It’s main claim against both respondents was that Retyred had dumped and stored large quantities of used tyres on the premises. SEIL said Retyred did this without SEIL’s consent (in breach of cl 16.1 of the deed of lease) and that it had covered almost the whole of the premises with piles of tyres that were a fire risk and a nuisance (in breach of cls 8.2 and 22.1). SEIL said the quantity of tyres exceeded 100 cubic metres without…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sahar Ehsani Investment Limited v Sinclair and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZHC 570
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Sahar Ehsani Investment Limited (SEIL) brought an application against Warren Graeme Sinclair and Retyred (2020) Limited (Retyred) under the Contempt of Court Act 2019, seeking a warrant to imprison Sinclair or a fine, a fine against Retyred, and costs. SEIL alleged that Sinclair and Retyred had breached court orders prohibiting them from bringing tyres onto leased premises in Red Hill, Auckland. The High Court dismissed the application, finding that SEIL had not proved beyond reasonable doubt that Sinclair and Retyred had knowingly failed to comply with the orders. The Court held that SEIL's evidence, based largely on the affidavit of Safar Sahar, SEIL's director, was not sufficiently detailed to prove a wilful breach. The Court found that the activities witnessed by Sahar did not prove beyond reasonable doubt that tyres were dumped in contravention of the court orders. The Court concluded that SEIL had not satisfied the threshold for contempt procedures, which requires proof beyond reasonable doubt of a wilful breach. The Court dismissed the application for contempt orders and declined to make any orders as to costs.

The Court noted that SEIL had not provided detailed evidence of tyre dumping, such as photographs or times of the alleged incidents. The Court also found that Sahar's observations could be explained by Sinclair's affidavit, which stated that tyres were being moved to make space for shredding machinery. The Court accepted Sinclair's evidence that he did not know of any tyre dumping in contravention of the court orders. The Court held that SEIL had not demonstrated a wilful breach of the court orders by either Sinclair or Retyred, and dismissed the application for contempt orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established