Sagar Properties Limited v Tropical Origin Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV 2014-404- 001326 [2014] NZHC 1771

BETWEEN

SAGAR PROPERTIES LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

TROPICAL ORIGIN LIMITED Defendant

Hearing: 28 July 2014

Appearances:

M S Sahu Khan for the Plaintiff
D J King for the Defendant

Judgment:

29 July 2014

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE CHRISTIANSEN

This judgment was delivered by me on

29.07.14 at 4:30pm, pursuant to

Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date……………

SAGAR PROPERTIES LIMITED v TROPICAL ORIGIN LIMITED [2014] NZHC 1771 [29 July 2014]

[1]      The plaintiff applies to support its claim to a caveatable interest in the subject property.   The plaintiff seeks to protect claimed equitable rights to purchase the property in terms of an Agreement for Sale and Purchase dated 2 May 2014 (the Agreement).

[2]      The  front  page  of  the  Agreement  indicated  that  a  Building  Report  was required (by the purchaser), within five working days i.e. by 5:00pm, 9 May 2014.

[3]      Clause 9.3 of the Agreement stated:

If the purchaser has indicated on the front page of this agreement that a building report is required, this agreement is conditional upon the purchaser obtaining at the purchaser’s cost… a report on the condition of the buildings and any other improvements on the property that is satisfactory to the purchaser, on the basis of an objective assessment.   The report must be prepared in good faith by a suitably-qualified inspector to the property at all reasonable times upon reasonable notice for the purposes of preparation of the report.  The building inspector may not carry out any invasive testing in the course of inspection without the vendor’s prior written consent.  If the purchaser avoids this agreement for non-fulfilment of this condition pursuant to sub-clause 9.8(5), the purchaser must provide the vendor immediately upon request with a copy of the building inspectors report.

[4]      Clause 9.8 of the Agreement provides:

…

(4)      The condition shall be deemed to be not fulfilled until notice of fulfilment has been served by one party on the other party.

…

[5]      Clause 1.3 of the Agreement provides:

The following apply to all notices between the parties…:

(1)       All notices must be served in writing.

…

(3)       All other notices, unless otherwise required by the Property Law Act

2007, must be served by one of the following means:

…

(b)      On the party or on the party’s lawyer:

…

(iii)     by facsimile, or by email:

…

(4)      In respect of the means of service specified in subclause 1.3(3)(b), a notice is deemed to have been served:

…

(d)       In the case of email, when acknowledged by the party or by the lawyer orally or by return email or otherwise in writing, except that return emails generated automatically shall not constitute an acknowledgement;

…

[6]      On 9  May 2014  at  1:16pm  the plaintiff/purchaser’s  solicitor notified  the defendant/vendor’s solicitor by email that a Building Report had been obtained that found several issues with the property which the plaintiff required to be completed “in a proper…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sagar Properties Limited v Tropical Origin Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 1771
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Sagar Properties Limited v Tropical Origin Limited [2014] NZHC 1771 concerns a dispute over a claim by Sagar Properties Limited (the plaintiff) to maintain a caveat over certain property, in order to protect its equitable rights to purchase the property under an Agreement for Sale and Purchase dated 2 May 2014. The primary issues for determination were whether the plaintiff had satisfied the condition of obtaining a Building Report, and whether the defendant was entitled to cancel the Agreement based on the plaintiff’s alleged non-fulfilment of the Building Report Condition.

The court examined the terms of the Agreement, particularly clauses 9.3 and 9.8, which set out the requirements for obtaining a Building Report and the notice obligations in respect of that condition. Clause 9.3 mandated that the Agreement was conditional upon the purchaser obtaining a satisfactory Building Report within the stipulated timeframe. Clause 9.8 further required that any condition was deemed not fulfilled until notice of its fulfilment was served by one party on the other. The court also considered the provisions regarding the service of notices, which allowed for service by email, provided it was acknowledged by the recipient.

The plaintiff argued that it had satisfied the condition by obtaining a Building Report by 7 May 2014 and notifying the defendant of this fact by email on 9 May 2014. The plaintiff further argued that its email at 4:53pm on 9 May 2014 confirming the Building Report Condition was satisfied constituted a valid notice of fulfilment. The defendant, on the other hand, contended that the condition was not fulfilled because the plaintiff's email was not acknowledged, and thus not validly served as required by clause 1.3 of the Agreement.

The court concluded that the plaintiff had indeed obtained a Building Report within the required timeframe and had notified the defendant of this fact. The court found that while the condition required notice of its fulfilment, it did not necessitate the defendant’s agreement or satisfaction with the report's findings. The court held that the email from the plaintiff’s solicitor at 1:16pm on 9 May 2014, which notified the defendant of the Building Report’s completion and contained suggestions for negotiation, constituted sufficient verification of the obtaining of a satisfactory Building Report. Therefore, the condition was satisfied and the Agreement became unconditional. The court also found that the defendant was not entitled to cancel the Agreement, as the condition was fulfilled prior to the defendant's purported cancellation by facsimile on 12 May 2014.

Accordingly, the court granted the application to sustain the caveat, finding that the plaintiff had an arguable case for the interest claimed. The court directed the plaintiff to file and serve their substantive proceeding by 12 September 2014, with leave reserved for the defendant to request the discharge of the caveat if the plaintiff failed to do so. Costs were awarded to the plaintiff on a 2B basis, together with disbursements approved by the Registrar.