S v R HC Nelson CRI-2010-442-11

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

This case has been anonymized

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NELSON REGISTRY

CRI-2010-442-11

S

v

THE QUEEN

Hearing:        22 June 2010

Appearances: Mr Zindel for the appellant

Mr Stevenson for the respondent

Judgment:      25 June 2010

JUDGMENT OF MALLON J

Contents

Introduction............................................................................................................... [1] Background ............................................................................................................... [2] Submissions .............................................................................................................. [8] Approach to imposing a reparation sentence .......................................................... [10] Amount for emotional harm ................................................................................... [11] Insufficient means? ................................................................................................. [18] Undue hardship? ..................................................................................................... [24] Result ...................................................................................................................... [27]

S V R HC NEL CRI-2010-442-11  25 June 2010

Introduction

[1]         Mr S    appeals against an order for reparation of $7,500.   This order was imposed as part of his sentence on his conviction for careless driving causing injury. The  order  was  made  for  emotional  harm suffered  by the  victim of  the  careless driving.  The appeal is on the grounds that the Judge erred in his assessment as to the amount that the appellant could pay.  As a result it is said that the Judge imposed a sum which would cause undue hardship.

Background

[2]      The  careless  driving  causing  injury  charge  arose  out  of  an  incident  one Sunday morning.  Mr S   was driving on a road in a 100 km per hour zone.  He was with his partner and they were looking for an address.   Upon realising that he had gone past the address, Mr S    backed up the road.  The road was straight, but hilly and narrow which limited visibility.   The victim was riding his motorbike and saw Mr S  ’s car reversing towards him.    As the victim attempted to avoid Mr S  ’s car,  Mr  S      was  driving  forward  into  a  driveway.      The  victim’s  motorbike collided with Mr S  ’s vehicle.

[3]       The victim sustained serious injuries.   He was airlifted to Nelson Hospital and then to Christchurch Hospital.  He was in a coma for five days and had to have major surgery.  His pelvis was fractured in two places.  His ligaments in his left knee were torn.    He had internal injuries to his ribs, right kidney, pancreas, spleen and liver.  He also had a punctured lung.  Damage was also caused to the sciatic nerve causing a loss of feeling below the knee and “drop foot syndrome”.

[4]         Mr S     pleaded guilty to the charge.    He was sentenced to 120 hours community work,  disqualified from driving for nine months and ordered to pay reparation of $7,500 for emotional harm.  As to that reparation the Judge said:

[20]      I have asked Mr Ballantyne [counsel] to clarify from you, in the light of what is said in your declaration and in the light of what is said in the reparation report, what your offer of reparation is.  I have been told you offer

the sum of $1500 which you think is adequate to make good the harm that has been caused.  You want to retain your other savings on account of your retirement.

...

[22]      As I have said, the consequences for the victim here are severe.  The costs  of  damage  to  the  motorcycle  have  been…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read S v R HC Nelson CRI-2010-442-11 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NZHC 990
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, Mr. S appealed against a reparation order of $7,500 imposed as part of his sentence for careless driving causing injury. The reparation was for the emotional harm suffered by the victim. The appeal was on the grounds that the judge erred in his assessment of the amount Mr. S could pay, resulting in an order that would cause undue hardship. The court considered whether the amount of reparation for emotional harm was appropriate and whether it would cause undue hardship to the offender.

The court found that the $7,500 was not manifestly excessive given the victim's injuries and the emotional harm suffered. However, the court also considered Mr. S's financial position, which was precarious given his age, part-time employment, and modest income. The court found that Mr. S did not have sufficient means to pay the full amount of the reparation ordered. Additionally, the court found that the order would cause undue hardship to Mr. S given his age and financial position.

The court allowed the appeal, quashed the reparation order of $7,500, and imposed a reparation order of $4,000. This amount represented significantly more than Mr. S considered he could afford but left him and his partner with a little over half of their accumulated savings, which they would need to meet future contingencies. The court noted that Mr. S offered to increase his hours of community work if his reparation was reduced, but the court did not think that was necessary. The court found that Mr. S's sentence appropriately reflected his culpability.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.