Russell v Taxation Review Authority CA188/02

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA188/02

BETWEEN  J G RUSSELL AND ORS

Applicants

AND  TAXATION REVIEW AUTHORITY

First Respondent

ANDCOMMISSIONER OF INLAND REVENUE

Second Respondent

Hearing:         13 October 2003 Coram:  Gault P

Panckhurst J William Young J

Appearances: F M R Cooke for Applicants

A C Beck for Respondents Judgment:  16 October 2003

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT DELIVERED BY GAULT P


[1]        In a judgment delivered on 27 August 2003, this Court dismissed an appeal by the five applicants against an order of the High Court striking out the fourth cause of action in a proceeding for judicial review.

[2]        Those five applicants now seek conditional leave to appeal to the Privy Counsel from the judgment of this Court. Although it was made clear in the judgment of this Court that the claim by one of those appellants, Managed Fashions Ltd, constituted an abuse of process, it was only during his oral submissions in reply that Mr Cooke (who has not previously had involvement in this and the related

J G RUSSELL AND ORS V TAXATION REVIEW AUTHORITY And Anor CA CA188/02 [16 October 2003]

matters) accepted that Managed Fashions Ltd should be excluded from any conditional leave granted.

[3]        The cause of action alleged that the Commissioner by his conduct in objection proceedings before the Taxation Review Authority (TRA), had dishonestly and in breach of legal duties refused to identify and make available documents and witnesses considered material by the objectors, thereby preventing a fair hearing before the TRA.

[4]        As was made clear in the judgment of this Court and in the written submissions filed in support of the present application, the focus of the claim, and the relief sought, is in respect of the conduct of the Commissioner. Relief in respect of the TRA although pleaded (albeit inadequately), stands to one side.

[5]        O’Regan J, in the High Court, struck out this cause of action which had been allowed to remain in an earlier judgment of Fisher J ((2000) 19 NZTC 15,924), only because of the possibility of salvage by amendment. The judgment of Fisher J,  which was primarily directed to other causes of action but in respect of the same general grievances of the appellants, was appealed to this Court. That appeal was dismissed, ((2001) 20 NZTC 17,418), as was a subsequent application for leave to appeal to the Privy Council ((2002) 16 PRNZ 168). A petition to the Privy Council for special leave to appeal was unsuccessful.

[6]        The present application is based upon r2(b) of the New Zealand (Appeals to the Privy Council) Order 1910. The Court may in its discretion grant leave if in its opinion the question involved in the appeal is one which by reason of its great general or public importance or otherwise ought to be submitted to Her Majesty in Council for decision.

[7]        Broadly the questions said to justify leave are whether there are duties on the Commissioner, giving rise to relief by way of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Russell v Taxation Review Authority CA188/02 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] NZCA 352
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Court of Appeal of New Zealand, the applicants, J G Russell and others, appealed against a decision of the High Court which had struck out the fourth cause of action in a proceeding for judicial review. The applicants sought conditional leave to appeal to the Privy Council from the Court's judgment. The applicants alleged that the Commissioner had dishonestly and in breach of legal duties refused to identify and make available documents and witnesses considered material by the objectors, thereby preventing a fair hearing before the Taxation Review Authority (TRA). The focus of the claim, and the relief sought, was in respect of the conduct of the Commissioner.

The legal issues before the Court were whether there were duties on the Commissioner, giving rise to relief by way of judicial review, in proceedings challenging his assessments before the TRA, to make available documents sought by the objector beyond those obtained by the usual discovery process, and to make available witnesses the objector considered were relevant to expose the motives and processes of those involved in formulating the assessment in issue and other assessments made in respect of similar arrangements.

The Court was not convinced that there was any stronger case for leave in respect of the cause of action in issue than in respect of the other causes of action previously dealt with. The matters may be important to Mr Russell and his clients, but any wider general or public importance had been ventilated in the previous appeal to the Privy Council in respect of the Managed Fashions assessment. Further, the issues raised, to the extent that they were relevant to the correctness of the assessments, could be pursued in the uncompleted TRA proceedings or appeals from them. The application was dismissed, and the Commissioner was entitled to costs which were fixed at $3,000 together with disbursements approved, if necessary, by the Registrar.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established