IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND
CA188/02
BETWEENJ G RUSSELL AND ORS
Appellants
ANDTAXATION REVIEW AUTHORITY
First RespondentANDCOMMISSIONER OF INLAND REVENUE
Second Respondent
Hearing:15 July 2003
Coram:Gault P
Blanchard J
Anderson JAppearances: G J Judd QC for Appellants
A C Beck for Respondents
Judgment:27 August 2003
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT DELIVERED BY GAULT P
[1] Mr Russell, a business and financial consultant with whom the courts are well familiar, considers that officers of the Inland Revenue Department have been conducting a “vendetta” against him. He constructed for a considerable number of company clients arrangements, conveniently known as the Russell template, that have been found to fall within s99 of the Income Tax Act 1976. He has contested that finding in various proceedings as far as the Privy Council. He maintains that in adjusting the arrangements under s99(3) to counteract tax advantages obtained, the Commissioner (by his staff) has been inconsistent, contradictory, in breach of s99(4) and dishonest in frustrating Mr Russell’s attempts to expose that situation.
[2] What he is attempting to do, in the context of a challenge to the assessments of certain of the companies, is to conduct a wide-ranging enquiry before the Taxation Review Authority (TRA) into the processes of the Department. Because the Commissioner is not co-operating as Mr Russell considers he should, Mr Russell and his clients complain that they have been, or will be, denied fair hearings.
[3] In a recent judgment in Dandelion Investments Ltd v Commissioner of Inland Revenue [2003] 1 NZLR 600 this Court said (paras 90 and 93):
As we have said the function of the authority was to hear and determine the objection disallowed by the Commissioner by conducting a fresh hearing into the matters raised in the objection, in which questions of validity as well as the correctness of the assessment could be considered. But the authority’s role remained one which was concerned with the correctness of the assessment. It did not extend to conducting what was effectively a broad-based judicial review of the process leading up to the Commissioner’s assessment and disallowance of the objection and subsequent conduct of the proceeding before the authority. What transpired is contrary to the general primacy of the objection procedure over judicial review as the means of challenge which will ascertain the correct tax liability.
…
In accepting that jurisdiction questions could be raised in the statutory process the decisions of this Court in Canterbury Frozen Meat and Golden Bay Cement [Commissioner of Inland Revenue v Canterbury Frozen Meat Co Ltd [1994] 2 NZLR 681, Golden Bay Cement Co Ltd v Commissioner of Inland Revenue [1996] 2 NZLR 665] did not, and were never intended to, invite fishing expeditions into the internal processes of the department seeking administrative law grounds on which to mount objections to substantive assessments.
Essentially the same points were made by Salmon J at first instance in that case.
[4] The fair hearing said to be denied seems to be…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Russell v Taxation Review Authority and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2003] NZCA 206
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court of Appeal found that the claim for judicial review against the Commissioner was untenable. It held that the Bill of Rights Act does not provide a basis for reviewing the conduct of a litigant before the TRA, as the Commissioner is not a decision-making authority. The Court also rejected the argument that the Commissioner had an obligation to identify and make available witnesses or to give discovery of all relevant documents. The Court found that the statutory rules governing the conduct of proceedings in the TRA and the common law principles of natural justice were sufficient to ensure a fair hearing for the objectors. The Court further held that the common law principle in Scally's case, which imposes an obligation on prosecutors to disclose favourable evidence in criminal proceedings, was not applicable to the tax objection procedures.
In light of the available appeal rights, the Court found it unnecessary to address the reasons for striking out the cause of action, even if a claim based on s27(1) of the Bill of Rights Act were tenable. The Court also held that the claim for judicial review against the TRA was speculative and should not be further pursued, given the available remedies by way of appeal. The appeal was dismissed, and the second respondent was awarded costs of $6,000 together with disbursements approved by the Registrar, if necessary.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi