Russell v Russell

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND CA13/02
CA51/02
BETWEEN GRAHAM JOHN RUSSELL
Appellant
AND LORRAINE FRANCES RUSSELL
Respondent
Hearing: 17 July 2002
Coram: Keith J
Fisher J
Salmon J
Appearances: W J Scotter for Appellant
E J Hudson for Respondent
Judgment: 23 September 2002

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT DELIVERED BY FISHER J

Introduction

  1. The appellant Mr Russell appeals against costs awarded against him in the High Court following his unsuccessful defence to an application under the Matrimonial Property Act 1976 by his former wife, the respondent, Mrs Russell. Hammond J awarded Mrs Russell costs assessed under the High Court Rules on a 2B basis, the detailed consequences to be determined by the Registrar. The Registrar determined the figure ultimately payable and then sealed the judgment on the same day. On an application to review the Registrar’s decision Baragwanath J held that the sealing of the judgment precluded jurisdiction to review the Registrar’s decision.

  2. In this Court Mr Russell appeals against both the costs decision of Hammond J and the jurisdictional decision of Baragwanath J. The appeal touches upon the jurisdiction to apply the new costs regime introduced by the High Court Amendment Rules 1999 (1999/334) to procedural steps taken prior to 1 January 2000 and the question whether there is any special approach to costs when dividing matrimonial or relationship property.

Factual background

  1. Mr and Mrs Russell separated after a lengthy marriage. On 14 March 1991 they entered into an agreement under the Matrimonial Property Act settling the division of their matrimonial property.

  2. In 1997 Mrs Russell brought proceedings in the High Court challenging the agreement and seeking a de novo division of property under the Act. A hearing followed before Hammond J on 14, 15 and 16 February 2000. The hearing came six weeks after the commencement of a new inter-party costs regime introduced by the High Court Amendment Rules 1999. At the conclusion of the hearing there was an exchange between Bench and Bar over costs. Counsel agree that it is correctly captured in the following extract from a subsequent memorandum:

    (a)   At the conclusion of the hearing, when the issue of costs was addressed, counsel for the Plaintiff, Mr E J Hudson, requested that the Court set the category costs as from 1 January 2000, which stance was agreed to by counsel for the Defendant.

    (b)   It was further suggested to His Honour by Mr Hudson, that it may be possible for counsel to agree to resolve the costs issue by applying the band category over the whole proceedings. Mr Scotter sought to reserve his position on the issue. Therefore, it was not specifically agreed at the hearing that the band category was to apply to costs incurred prior to 1 January 2000.

  3. The Judge subsequently gave his reserved decision of 22 February 2000. He set aside the agreement as unjust and unreasonable and went on to divide the property on a conventional statutory basis. As to costs he concluded his judgment in these terms:

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Russell v Russell and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] NZCA 262
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Russell v Russell involves an appeal by the appellant, Graham John Russell, against costs awarded to the respondent, Lorraine Frances Russell, in a matrimonial property dispute. The dispute began when Mrs Russell challenged the division of property agreement entered into by the parties in 1991. The hearing took place in the High Court in early 2000, shortly after the commencement of a new costs regime introduced by the High Court Amendment Rules 1999. Hammond J awarded Mrs Russell costs on a 2B basis under the new rules, and a judgment for costs was later sealed by the Registrar. The appellant appealed against the costs decision and the jurisdictional decision of Baragwanath J, who held that the sealing of the judgment precluded jurisdiction to review the Registrar's decision.

The primary legal issue in the case was whether the new costs regime introduced by the High Court Amendment Rules 1999 could be applied to procedural steps taken before the rules came into force on 1 January 2000. The Court of Appeal held that there was jurisdiction for Hammond J's award, as the transitional provisions in the new rules allowed for the application of the new regime to steps taken before 1 January 2000 if it would otherwise lead to an unjust result. However, the Court found that there was a misunderstanding between counsel regarding the application of the new 2B scale to costs incurred before 1 January 2000.

The Court of Appeal considered the appropriate approach to costs in matrimonial property cases and found that in cases involving a division of assets between two parties, it is often appropriate to make no order as to costs. However, in cases where one party has successfully challenged an agreement, costs are more likely to follow the event, with the unsuccessful defendant bearing the costs if they could have recognised the invalidity of the agreement at the outset. The Court of Appeal held that the 2B scale should be adopted as a starting point for costs throughout, subject to a reduction in the allowance for discovery and inspection.

As a result of the appeal, the original costs award was set aside and replaced with a new costs order according to scale 2B in the High Court Rules for steps taken before and after 1 January 2000, subject to the reduction in the allowance for discovery and inspection. The appellant was ordered to pay the respondent's costs in the Court of Appeal, with disbursements to be fixed by the Registrar.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established