Ruscoe v Canterbury Policy Holders HC Wellington

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV 2011-485-1535

IN THE MATTER OF     the Companies Act 1993

AND

IN THE MATTER OF     the Liquidation of Western Pacific

Insurance Limited (In Liquidation) AND

IN THE MATTER OF     an application by DAVID IAN RUSCOE and SIMON JOHN THORN of Grant Thornton New Zealand Limited as joint and several Liquidators of Western Pacific Insurance Limited (In Liquidation)

BETWEEN  D I RUSCOE AND S J THORN Applicants

ANDCANTERBURY POLICY HOLDERS First Respondents

Hearing:         3 November 2011

Counsel:         F B Barton and V M Heward for Applicants

J V Ormsby for First Respondents
J Toebes for Interveners

Judgment:      9 December 2011

JUDGMENT OF SIMON FRANCE J

D I RUSCOE AND S J THORN V CANTERBURY POLICY HOLDERS HC WN CIV 2011-485-1535 [9

December 2011]

Introduction

[1]      This is an application by the liquidators of Western Pacific Insurance Limited for directions.  Western Pacific went into voluntary liquidation on 1 April this year. As at the date of this hearing there are unsettled claims totalling around $60 million. Two thirds of the value of those claims relate to claims arising from the two Christchurch earthquakes.

[2]      Western Pacific had reinsurance arrangements.   One such arrangement was an annually renewed treaty relating to property insurance.  It had two limbs – risk and catastrophe.  The risk limb dealt with reinsurance of individual claims, and the catastrophe limb dealt with loss stemming from a group of claims relating to the same incident.   The reinsured – i.e. Western Pacific – has the choice as to which section of the treaty to allocate a particular claim.

[3]      Claims resulting from the two Christchurch earthquakes have triggered the catastrophe section of the reinsurance treaty for both 2010 and 2011.   The 2010 policy covered Western Pacific to a maximum of $20 million; the 2011 version was limited to $15 million.   In each year there is an excess or retention of $1 million, meaning there is $33 million available to the liquidators.  The treaties provided that the money would be payable even if the reinsured became insolvent, and so had not actually paid out on the triggering claims.  This is recognised by the reinsurers and there is no issue about the $33 million being available to the liquidators.

[4]      The issue the Court is asked to determine is whether that $33 million is available to all claimants and unsecured creditors, or just to those whose claims triggered the reinsurance.  The liquidators contend the money is available to all.  The role of respondent has been taken by the Canterbury Policy Holders.  They contend that s 9(1) of the Law Reform Act 1936 applies so as to give them a first charge over the proceeds of reinsurance.  They are supported by the interveners, being three of

the major banks which hold mortgages over the subject property.1

1      ANZ National Bank Limited; Kiwibank Limited; Rabobank NZ Limited.

[5]      Section 9(1) of the Law Reform Act 1936…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ruscoe v Canterbury Policy Holders HC Wellington and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 2113
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand dealt with an application by the liquidators of Western Pacific Insurance Limited, David Ian Ruscoe and Simon John Thorn, seeking directions in relation to unsettled claims amounting to approximately $60 million. Two-thirds of these claims resulted from the Christchurch earthquakes in 2010 and 2011. Western Pacific had reinsurance arrangements that covered both risk and catastrophe, with the latter being triggered by the earthquakes. The key issue before the court was whether the $33 million available from the reinsurance was payable to all claimants and unsecured creditors or only to those whose claims triggered the reinsurance. The liquidators argued for the former, while the Canterbury Policy Holders, as the first respondents, contended that Section 9(1) of the Law Reform Act 1936 gave them a first charge over the reinsurance proceeds.

The court examined whether the reinsurance policies could be considered as indemnifying Western Pacific against a liability to pay damages or compensation, a condition stipulated in Section 9(1). The liquidators argued that Western Pacific's liability under the original policy was not a liability to pay damages but rather compensation. They further argued that reinsurance is not a form of liability insurance, and thus, Section 9 should not apply. The court, however, disagreed, holding that the term "compensation" in Section 9 could reasonably be interpreted to include the obligation to compensate policyholders for losses within the terms of the original policy. The court found that Section 9 was not limited to liability insurance and could apply to reinsurance situations.

The court concluded that pursuant to its interpretation of Section 9, Western Pacific's liability to pay compensation to its policyholders on the happening of an event, in this case, the Christchurch earthquakes, constituted a charge on the reinsurance money that had become payable in respect of that liability. The court's decision meant that the Canterbury Policy Holders had a first charge over the $33 million from the reinsurance. The orders also provided for the priority repayment of premiums due on the reinsurance, which had been covered by the interveners, and the liquidators' expenses in realising and managing the $33 million.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established