Robinson v Whangarei Heads Enterprises Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WHANGAREI REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA
WHANGĀREI TERENGA PARĀOA ROHE

CIV-2013-488-223 [2018] NZHC 751

BETWEEN

JOHN CLIFFORD WALTER ROBINSON

Plaintiff

AND

WHANGAREI HEADS ENTERPRISES LIMITED

First Defendant

VICTOR LEONARD FREAKLEY
Second Defendant

OFFICIAL ASSIGNEE

Third Defendant

Hearing: On the papers

Counsel:

BA Vautier for defendants

JCW Robinson, plaintiff in person

Judgment:

20 April 2018


JUDGMENT OF FITZGERALD J

[As to costs]


This judgment was delivered by me on 20 April 2018 at 4 pm, pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date……………

Solicitors:           Glaister Ennor, Auckland To:           JCW Robinson, Whangarei

Robinson v Whangarei Heads Enterprises Limited [2018] NZHC 751 [20 April 2018]

Introduction

[1]        I delivered my substantive judgment in this matter on 1 February 2018.1 The background to these proceedings is somewhat lengthy and complex, and is set out in my substantive judgment. It is not repeated here.

[2]        At the conclusion of my judgment, I dismissed each of Mr Robinson’s claims against the first and second defendants. I indicated my preliminary but non-binding view that costs ought to follow the event in the ordinary way, on a 2B basis. The parties have been unable to agree costs and have filed costs memoranda. This judgment now determines the costs of this proceeding.

Approach to costs

[3]        As both parties recognise, r 14.2 of the High Court Rules provides that the party who fails with respect to a proceeding should pay the costs of the party who succeeds. Mr Robinson does not dispute that he ought to pay the costs of this proceeding. Rather, he objects to certain aspects of the costs which have been claimed by the defendants.

[4]        As noted above, there are two defendants to this proceeding. As I noted at [5] and [104] of my substantive judgment, Mr Robinson’s claims were directed at the second defendant, Mr Freakley, only and not the first defendant, Whangarei Heads Enterprises Limited (“WHEL”). Despite this, however, I noted in my substantive judgment that:2

… it is difficult to see how WHEL, having the same solicitor/counsel as    Mr Freakley, will have incurred any, or any substantial, costs that would not have been incurred by Mr Freakley in any event. On that basis, it would seem appropriate that there is only one claim for costs by the defendants. If WHEL/Mr Freakley take a different view, that will need to be addressed in their costs memorandum.

[5]        In the defendants’ cost memorandum, WHEL does not make a separate claim for costs, other than to claim costs for commencement of a defence. WHEL says that at the very outset of this matter, it was not immediately apparent that no additional


1      Robinson v Whangarei Heads Enterprises Ltd [2018] NZHC 43.

2 At [104].

matters of substance would need to be attended to on behalf of WHEL separate from Mr Freakley, and WHEL accordingly had to consider its position and defence.

Steps in the proceedings objected to by Mr Robinson

[6]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Robinson v Whangarei Heads Enterprises Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZHC 751
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Robinson v Whangarei Heads Enterprises Limited was heard before Fitzgerald J in the High Court of New Zealand, Whangarei Registry. The plaintiff, John Clifford Walter Robinson, brought claims against Whangarei Heads Enterprises Limited and Victor Leonard Freakley, who were the first and second defendants, respectively. The plaintiff's claims were dismissed by the court, and the matter proceeded to a determination of costs. The defendants sought costs under the High Court Rules, claiming a total of $46,830, plus disbursements of $380. The plaintiff objected to several aspects of the costs claimed, including the amount claimed for the commencement of defence by Whangarei Heads Enterprises Limited, the time allocation for preparation of briefs, and the time claimed for appearance at the hearing.

The court addressed each of the plaintiff's objections and found in favour of the defendants on most points. Fitzgerald J held that Whangarei Heads Enterprises Limited was entitled to claim one day for the commencement of defence, amounting to $2,230, rather than the two days claimed. The court also reduced the time allocation for preparation of briefs from 2.5 days to one day, resulting in a reduction of $3,345. Finally, the court found that the defendants were entitled to claim 1.5 days for appearance at the hearing, amounting to $3,345, rather than the two days claimed. The court also found that the plaintiff was entitled to a costs credit of $446, which was to be offset against the costs awarded to the defendants. The total costs awarded to the defendants were $46,384, plus disbursements of $380, resulting in a total of $46,764. Fitzgerald J ordered that the sum of $15,000 paid by the plaintiff as security for costs, plus interest, be released to the defendants for the purpose of applying against the costs due.

This case highlights the importance of carefully considering the costs claimed by defendants in litigation, and the need for parties to challenge any aspects of the costs that they consider excessive or inappropriate. The court's approach to costs in this case was thorough and considered, taking into account the specific circumstances of the case and the objections raised by the plaintiff. The final orders of the court reflect a balanced approach to the allocation of costs between the parties, taking into account the overall outcome of the litigation and the specific objections raised by the plaintiff.