IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY
CIV2012-404-001629 [2013] NZHC 1293
BETWEEN CHRISTOPHER JOHN ROBINSON AND ALISON CHRISTINA ROBINSON Plaintiffs
ANDIAG NEW ZEALAND LIMITED Defendant
Hearing: By memoranda
Cousenl: C J Robinson, plaintiff in person (on behalf of plaintiffs) C J Hlavac for defendant
Judgment: 4 June 2013
COSTS JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE ABBOTT
This judgment was delivered by me on 4 June 2013 at 12.30pm, pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.
Registrar/Deputy Registrar
Date……………
Solicitors:
C Hlavac, Young Hunter, Christchurch
Also to:
C J Robinson, Wellsford
C J ROBINSON AND A C ROBINSON v IAG NEW ZEALAND LIMITED [2013] NZHC 1293 [4 June 2013]
[1] The defendant, IAG New Zealand Limited, has applied for costs on a scale
2B basis, after the plaintiffs, Mr and Mrs Robinson, discontinued this proceeding and reissued a new proceeding.
[2] The Robinsons have issued their new proceeding in respect of the same dispute. They say that costs should not be awarded as the new proceeding replaces the earlier one. They ask that the costs of this proceeding be transferred to the new one, and be determined at the end of that case. They also say that the amount sought by IAG is excessive.
Background
[3] The Robinsons at all material times were the owners of a house and contents at 125A Ness Road, Kerikeri. The house and contents were insured under a policy taken out with IAG.
[4] The house and contents were destroyed by a fire in September 2011. The Robinsons made a claim under the policy. It was declined by IAG on the ground that the fire had been caused deliberately by Mr Robinson, and therefore came under an exclusion in the policy for intentional damage.
[5] The Robinsons issued this proceeding contending that the rejection of their claim for indemnity was a breach of the contract of insurance and a breach of a duty owed by IAG to conduct their investigation into the cause of the fire in good faith. IAG denied any breach of contract or of any duty of good faith. It pleaded as affirmative defences a clause in the policy that excluded intentional damage, and that the Robinsons had breach a duty to act in good faith by deliberately lighting the fire (allegedly using a remote control device) to obtain a benefit under the policies.
[6] In May 2012, the parties agreed to stay the proceeding until a criminal prosecution of Mr Robinson, for arson, had been determined. That prosecution has not yet been determined.
[7] The Robinsons are acting for themselves in the new proceeding (they say that they do not have the financial resources to continue to employ their former counsel).
They commenced the new proceeding earlier this year. It duplicates the claims against IAG in this proceeding (with some additional contentions), and adds claims against other parties. The Robinsons have now sought a stay of the new proceeding also, pending determination of the prosecution of Mr Robinson.
[8] The…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Robinson v IAG New Zealand Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] NZHC 1293
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the plaintiffs, who had discontinued their initial proceeding and reissued a new one, should be liable for the costs incurred by the defendant. The court had to consider the presumption that a discontinuing party pays the other party's costs, balanced against its discretion to make an order that appears just in all the circumstances. The Robinsons argued that the new proceeding replaced the earlier one and that the costs should be transferred to the new case. They also contended that the amount sought by IAG was excessive. IAG, on the other hand, submitted that the new proceeding was brought improperly and that the plaintiffs should not escape liability for the costs.
The court found merit in IAG's arguments that the new proceeding was improperly brought, particularly in light of the stay order in the earlier proceeding and the joining of additional defendants. However, the court also recognized that these issues were more appropriately addressed in the new proceeding. The unusual circumstances of the case justified displacing the presumption that the discontinuing party pays the costs. The court exercised its discretion to award IAG costs incurred in the proceeding that could be considered wasted, such as the duplication of efforts due to the reissued proceeding. The court assessed the wasted costs at a quarter of the usual allowance and also considered other duplicated costs, resulting in a total award of $2189 plus disbursements of $108.80.
The court ordered that IAG New Zealand Limited recover costs of $2189, plus disbursements of $108.80, from the plaintiffs, Christopher John Robinson and Alison Christina Robinson. This decision addressed the issue of costs following the discontinuance of the initial proceeding and the reissuance of a new one, taking into account the circumstances surrounding the insurance claim and the subsequent legal proceedings.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi