Robins v New Plymouth District Council

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA746/2024
 [2025] NZCA 287

BETWEEN

NATASHA ROSINA ROBINS
Applicant

AND

NEW PLYMOUTH DISTRICT COUNCIL
Respondent

Court:

Palmer, Dunningham and Grice JJ

Counsel:

Applicant in person
J E Bourke for Respondent

Judgment:
(On the papers)

1 July 2025 at 10 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe application for an extension of time is granted.

BThe application for leave to bring a second appeal is declined.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Dunningham J)

  1. Ms Robins applies for leave to bring a second appeal against an order for the destruction of her dog, Indy.[1]  The New Plymouth District Council (the Council) opposes the application.  The order was made on 30 August 2024 following Ms Robins’ convictions on the following charges under the Dog Control Act 1996:

    (a)owning a dog that rushed at a person causing them to be injured;[2] and

    (b)failing to register a dog.[3]

    [1]New Plymouth District Council v Robins [2024] NZDC 20949 [District Court judgment].  The application for leave is pursuant to the Criminal Procedure Act 2011, s 253(1).

    [2]Dog Control Act 1996, s 57A(2).

    [3]Section 42(1).

  2. Ms Robins appealed that order.  On 10 October 2024, Grau J dismissed the appeal, finding no error by Judge Hikaka in ordering the destruction of the dog.[4]

The background facts

[4]Robins v New Plymouth District Council [2024] NZHC 2942 [High Court judgment] at [31]–[32].

  1. On 24 October 2023, the primary victim and his friends were cycling in the area where Ms Robins lives.  As the group neared her home, Indy, her black and tan female Rottweiler, began barking aggressively.  As the group got closer, Indy rushed from the property towards the cyclists causing some members of the group to crash. 

  2. The victim fell from his bike and landed on the handlebars of another bike causing him significant injury.  He was transported to hospital with six fractured ribs.  While in the ICU he suffered a number of incidents of atrial fibrillation and, as a consequence of his treatment for this, he suffered a collapsed lung.  He spent at least six days in hospital, four of which were in the ICU.  Soon after his discharge he returned to the emergency department with an upper respiratory tract infection.  His recovery took some time.

The District Court decision

  1. At sentencing, the District Court Judge heard from Ms Robins who said she believed the gate to her property was closed when she let the dogs out to the yard while having a shower, but came out to find there had been an incident involving Indy.[5]

    [5]District Court judgment, above n 1, at [13].

  2. The Judge noted, however, that her evidence needed to be put “in the context of the Council’s records of [Ms Robins] and the way [she] look[s] after dogs on [her] property”.[6]  That history included:[7]

    (a)On 18 December 2017 a complaint was received of two dogs rushing out of her property and at a group of cyclists.  She was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Robins v New Plymouth District Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NZCA 287
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Natasha Rosina Robins sought leave to appeal against an order for the destruction of her dog, Indy, made by the New Plymouth District Council. The appeal was dismissed by the High Court, and Ms Robins now sought leave for a second appeal. The central issue was whether there was a miscarriage of justice or an issue of general or public importance that warranted a second appeal. The court considered the past incidents involving the dog, the evidence presented in the previous courts, and the risk of ongoing dangerousness posed by the dog.

The Court of Appeal noted that the District Court and High Court had already considered the risk of ongoing dangerousness, taking into account past incidents and observations by Dog Control officers. The court found that all relevant matters were considered in the previous judgments. The proposed transfer of ownership did not sufficiently address the risk, and there was no indication of a miscarriage of justice or an issue of general or public importance that warranted a second appeal. The Court granted the application for an extension of time but declined the application for leave to bring a second appeal.

The Court of Appeal granted the application for an extension of time but declined the application for leave to bring a second appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 24 October 2023, Natasha Rosina Robins' dog, Indy, a female Rottweiler, rushed at a group of cyclists, causing significant injuries to one of them. This incident led to Robins being convicted under the Dog Control Act 1996 for owning a dog that rushed at a person causing them to be injured and for failing to register a dog. Prior to this incident, there were several complaints and infringement notices issued for similar incidents involving Indy and other dogs on Robins' property. The District Court Judge ordered the destruction of the dog, a decision that was upheld on appeal in the High Court.

The matter originated in the New Plymouth District Court, where Robins was convicted and the order for the destruction of her dog was made. She appealed this decision to the High Court, which dismissed the appeal on 10 October 2024. Robins then applied for leave to bring a second appeal to the Court of Appeal of New Zealand, pursuant to the Criminal Procedure Act 2011, s 253(1). The application for leave was made more than 20 working days after the High Court judgment, necessitating an application for an extension of time to file the application.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the application for an extension of time to bring a second appeal should be granted.
2. Whether the application for leave to bring a second appeal should be granted.

Held
1. The application for an extension of time to bring a second appeal is granted.
2. The application for leave to bring a second appeal is declined.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal considered the application for an extension of time to bring a second appeal against the order for the destruction of Ms Robins' dog, Indy. Ms Robins filed her application more than 20 working days after the High Court judgment was issued, which necessitated an extension of time. The Court noted the delay was short and the New Plymouth District Council was not prejudiced by the delay. Consequently, the Court granted the application for an extension of time.

The Court then turned to the application for leave to bring a second appeal. Ms Robins did not identify any issue of general or public importance in her submissions. The Court proceeded on the basis that she relied on the ground of a miscarriage of justice occurring. The Court considered Ms Robins' submissions which reiterated her arguments from the District Court and High Court appeal. These arguments included claims that the dog's behaviour was out of character, that the dog should be allowed to live out her remaining years at home, and that Ms Robins was not responsible for the gate being open on the day of the incident.

The Court noted that both the District Court and High Court had addressed these matters in detail. The District Court had considered past incidents involving the dog and recent observations by Dog Control officers, concluding that the risk of ongoing dangerousness was not satisfactorily addressed. The High Court had also considered fresh evidence, including the proposed transfer of ownership of the dog, and found no error in the District Court's decision to order the dog's destruction. The Court of Appeal was satisfied that all the matters raised by Ms Robins had been adequately considered in the previous judgments and that nothing suggested a miscarriage of justice had occurred or might occur if leave for a second appeal was not granted. Therefore, the Court declined the application for leave to bring a second appeal.