IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY
CIV-2010-409-001853 [2012] NZHC 354
BETWEEN ALAN JOHN ROBERTS AND LOLA NEROLI ROBERTS
Plaintiffs
ANDROBBIES BAR & BISTRO FRANCHISING LIMITED First Defendant
ANDPAUL MARTIN KOFOED Second Defendant
Hearing: 1 March 2012
(Heard at Christchurch)
Counsel: J M Shingleton for Plaintiffs
M S Henderson for Defendants
Judgment: 1 March 2012
JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE OSBORNE AS TO SECURITY FOR COSTS
Introduction
[1] The proceeding is set down for trial commencing 28 May 2012. The defendants made this application after the case management conference at which the trial was allocated.
The application for security
[2] This is the defendants’ application for an order that the plaintiffs provide
security for costs.
ROBERTS V ROBBIES BAR & BISTRO FRANCHISING LIMITED HC CHCH CIV-2010-409-001853 [1
March 2012]
[3] The application was made on 1 September 2011 on the basis there is reason to believe that the plaintiffs will be unable to pay their costs if the plaintiffs are unsuccessful in the proceeding. The defendants, through Mr Kofoed (who is a director of the first defendant), have explained that the events on which they principally rely for evidence on the threshold test came to their attention late and promptly led them to make this application. I will return to that evidence shortly.
[4] The defendants, in suggesting that the plaintiffs may be unable to meet an award of costs, rely almost solely on the fate of two proceedings which entities associated or controlled by the plaintiffs issued. One a High Court proceeding; one a District Court proceeding.
[5] The High Court proceeding was transferred by the plaintiffs in that case to the Disputes Tribunal following a judicial settlement conference.
[6] The District Court claim was transferred by the plaintiffs to the Disputes Tribunal without consultation after the defendants had filed their initial response in the District Court.
[7] The way in which the defendants have put their application in this regard is this:
He [Mr Roberts] transferred the High Court claim to the Disputes Tribunal following a Judicial Settlement Conference stating the cost to prosecute that claim was too great and because the First Defendant would not make a settlement offer.
He transferred the District Court claim to the Disputes Tribunal also once the Defendant (the same First Defendant as in this proceeding) served a Notice of Response.
[8] Mr Kofoed in his affidavit in support referred to the High Court proceeding. He deposed that Alan (Roberts) had decided not to proceed with the High Court claim because of the cost. In relation to the District Court claim he refers in his evidence to the simple facts as recited in the notice of application.
[9] Mr Roberts filed the evidence in support of the plaintiffs’ opposition to the application for security. He says in relation to the High Court proceeding that costs
were indeed one of the factors which led to the transfer but that that was because it became clear that costs were outweighing the potential benefits…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Roberts v Robbies Bar & Bistro Franchising Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] NZHC 354
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue was whether there was sufficient evidence to support the defendants' application for security for costs. The court examined whether the plaintiffs' decisions to transfer other proceedings to the Disputes Tribunal suggested an inability to pay costs if they were unsuccessful in the current proceeding. The court also considered the plaintiffs' financial position, as indicated by a statement from their chartered accountants.
The court reasoned that the transfers to the Disputes Tribunal were strategic decisions made in light of the potential financial burden of the proceedings and did not necessarily indicate an inability to pay costs. The court found no compelling evidence that the plaintiffs would be unable to pay the defendants' costs if they were unsuccessful. The court also noted that the plaintiffs had significant assets and that the defendants' application was made at a late stage in the proceeding. Consequently, the court concluded that there was no substantial reason to believe the plaintiffs would be unable to pay the defendants' costs and dismissed the application for security for costs.
The final orders of the court were that the application for security for costs was dismissed, and the defendants were to pay the costs of the application on a 2B basis, together with disbursements to be fixed by the Registrar.