Ririnui v Landcorp Farming Ltd (No 1)

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV-2014-485-2915 [2014] NZHC 732

UNDER  the J udicature Amendment Act 1972

BETWEEN  MITA MICHAEL RIRINUI Plaintiff

ANDLANDCORP FARMING LIMITED First Defendant

THE MINISTER FOR STATE-OWNED ENTERPRISES and THE MINISTER OF FINANCE

Second Defendants

THE ATTORNEY-GENERAL Third Defendant

Counsel:                  A N Isac and G Richards for Plaintiff

S A Barker, B Gnanalingan and L Brazier for First Defendant
J Gough and D Soper for Second and Third Defendants

Judgment:                9 April 2014

JUDGMENT (NO. 1) OF WILLIAMS J

[1]      This matter is set down to be heard on 16 and 17 April 2014.  The plaintiff challenges the legality of decisions by Landcorp and its shareholding Ministers to sell   Wharere   Farm   instead   of   making   it   available   in   settlement   of   Ngati Whakahemo’s Treaty of Waitangi claims.

[2]      It seems accepted that Wharere Farm is within Ngati Whakahemo’s mana whenua.   Heads of claim revolve around s 9 of the State-Owned Enterprises Act. The allegation is that Landcorp and shareholding Ministers each breached the section in their own respective spheres by failing actively to protect Ngati Whakahemo

interests,  by failing to  act  with  utmost  good  faith,  by breaching their  duties  to

RIRINUI v LANDCORP FARMING LIMITED & ORS [2014] NZHC 732 [9 April 2014]

address past wrongs, and by taking steps that would hinder or render more difficult the grant of redress for past Treaty breach.   There is also an argument against Landcorp in legitimate generated (it seems) in discussions between Landcorp and Ngati Whakahemo interests in February/March this year.  Appropriate declarations are sought together with an order by way of injunction in relation to the sale.

[3]      The plaintiff now seeks discovery orders relating to:

(a)      communications between  Landcorp and/or its solicitors and Micro Farms Limited (the purchaser) or its solicitors with respect to the sale and purchase of the Wharere Farm between 27 February 2014 and

6 March 2014 inclusive; and

(b)      any other documents within Landcorp’s control relating to the terms of the agreement  for sale and  purchase signed  with  Micro  Farms Limited, and the timing of the sale to Micro Farms Limited.

[4]      The plaintiff says these documents are relevant because they will or could shed light on the allegation that Landcorp acted contrary to its obligations under the Treaty of Waitangi particularly that of utmost good faith.  A second argument is they go to the question of relief and Landcorp’s claim to prejudice.

[5]      Discovery is not usually granted in judicial review proceedings, for the most part because it is unnecessary.   Public authorities usually disclose relevant documentation in affidavit evidence without the need for specific orders.  And, as it is often said, judicial review is intended to be a short and simple means by which to test the legality of public sector decision-making affecting ordinary citizens.  But on the face of it, such documents as are sought here are within the penumbra of the claim as put by the plaintiff. They are prima facie relevant.

[6]      In this case, Mr Barker…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ririnui v Landcorp Farming Ltd (No 1) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 732
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mita Michael Ririnui brought an action against Landcorp Farming Limited, the Minister for State-Owned Enterprises, the Minister of Finance, and the Attorney-General, challenging the legality of decisions to sell Wharere Farm instead of making it available in settlement of Ngati Whakahemo's Treaty of Waitangi claims. The plaintiff argued that Landcorp and its shareholding Ministers breached section 9 of the State-Owned Enterprises Act by failing to protect Ngati Whakahemo's interests, by not acting with utmost good faith, by breaching their duties to address past wrongs, and by taking steps that would hinder or render more difficult the grant of redress for past Treaty breaches. The plaintiff also argued that Landcorp breached its obligations under the Treaty of Waitangi, particularly the obligation of utmost good faith. Appropriate declarations were sought together with an order by way of injunction in relation to the sale.

The court was required to decide whether the plaintiff was entitled to discovery of documents relating to the sale of Wharere Farm between 27 February 2014 and 6 March 2014, and any other documents within Landcorp's control relating to the terms of the agreement for sale and purchase signed with Micro Farms Limited, and the timing of the sale to Micro Farms Limited. The plaintiff argued that these documents were relevant because they would or could shed light on the allegation that Landcorp acted contrary to its obligations under the Treaty of Waitangi particularly that of utmost good faith. The court found that the documents sought were plainly relevant and must be discovered unless privileged.

The court rejected the argument that discovery should not be granted because the plaintiff's case could not possibly succeed. The court held that it was wrong in principle in considering a discovery application, to decide whether the substantive case can succeed. If the defendant wanted an early finding about arguability, it needed to make the application. The court found that the plaintiff's case was currently constructed, the documents sought were plainly relevant and must be discovered unless privileged.

The court ordered that the plaintiff was entitled to discovery of the documents sought.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.