RFD Finance Limited v Thorn

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA ŌTAUTAHI ROHE

CIV-2016-409-000522

[2019] NZHC 2157

BETWEEN

RFD FINANCE LIMITED

First Plaintiff

AND

FTG SECURITIES LIMITED

Second Plaintiff

AND

SIMON JOHN THORN, DAVID IAN RUSCOE and TIMOTHY WILSON DOWNES

Defendants

Hearing: 16 August 2019

Counsel:

D J Ballantyne for Plaintiffs S Caradus for Defendant

Judgment:

30 August 2019


JUDGMENT OF OSBORNE J


[1]The plaintiffs make two applications:

(a)for review of discovery orders made by Associate Judge Matthews on 27 June 2019; and

(b)a related application for leave to file a fourth amended statement of claim (after close of pleadings).

[2] There are two plaintiffs, namely RFD Finance Ltd (RFD) and FTG Securities Ltd (FTG). For convenience in this judgment, I will generally refer only to RFD (the first plaintiff) being the assignee of the debt which I come to discuss at [5] – [7] below.

RFD FINANCE LIMITED v FTG SECURITIES LIMITED [2019] NZHC 2157 [30 August 2019]

The substantive proceeding

[3]        The substantive proceeding relates to the actions of the defendants as receivers of Livingspace Properties Ltd (in rec and in liq) (Livingspace).

[4]        FTG pleads that the receivers were appointed on 18 June 2010 by FM Custodians Ltd (FMC) pursuant to a security agreement (“the FMC security”).

[5]        RFD pleads that by deed of assignment of debt and security dated 13 September 2010, two other creditors of Livingspace assigned to RFD a first ranking general security interest (“the RFD security”). The RFD security was over Livingspace’s business and a specific security over the chattels used by Livingspace Invercargill and Livingspace Dunedin being accommodation businesses operated by Livingspace (“the first assignment”)

[6]        RFD alleges (by its statement of claim) that the defendants (as receivers) acted outside the scope of their powers which were created by the FMC security. It asserts that the receivers’ actions trespassed on the rights under the RFD (a first ranking) security over Livingspace’s business and chattels (by virtue of the assignment).

[7]The present statement of claim contains the following allegation:

8. As at 9 December 2013, the redemption calculation for LPL’s [Living Space’s] liability to RFD secured by the [assigned securities] totalled (not less than) $493,058.67 plus additional interest which continues to accrue at the contractual rate payable to RFD …

(“paragraph 8”)

Discovery in relation to the paragraph 8 allegations

[8]        The receivers wanted through discovery to establish the true financial position between RFD and Livingspace and that RFD was not owed any money secured by the RFD security.

[9]        To support that argument, the receivers by memorandum sought discovery of documents related to the indebtedness secured by the assigned securities held on the file in another current proceeding, CIV-2010-409-2323 (“the Walker proceeding”). In

his memorandum, counsel for the receivers described the Walker proceeding as being brought by the liquidator of Livingspace, Robert Walker. Mr Walker sought to investigate possible overpayments received by RFD from Livingspace while Livingspace was mortgagee in possession. Mr Walker in the Walker proceeding asserts…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read RFD Finance Limited v Thorn and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NZHC 2157
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand was presented with two applications by RFD Finance Limited and FTG Securities Limited against Simon John Thorn, David Ian Ruscoe, and Timothy Wilson Downes. The first application was for review of discovery orders made by Associate Judge Matthews on 27 June 2019. The second application was for leave to file a fourth amended statement of claim after the close of pleadings. The substantive proceeding related to the actions of the defendants as receivers of Livingspace Properties Ltd, and the primary dispute concerned the alleged breaches of the receivers' powers and their impact on RFD's security interests over Livingspace's business and chattels.

The legal issues before the court included whether the discovery orders for non-party documents were justified and whether RFD should be granted leave to amend its statement of claim to delete a specific allegation regarding the level of secured debt. The court had to determine if the discovery orders were appropriate given that RFD and FTG were not parties in the referenced Walker proceeding. Additionally, the court needed to decide if granting leave for the amendment would cause injustice or significant delay to the defendants.

In its reasoning, the court found that the discovery orders were not justified as RFD and FTG were not parties to the Walker proceeding, and thus, the orders amounted to non-party discovery without proper notice. The court rescinded the discovery orders but allowed the receivers to make a formal application for discovery, supported by affidavit evidence. Regarding the amendment of the statement of claim, the court concluded that the proposed amendment was necessary to determine the real controversy and did not cause significant delay or injustice. Therefore, the court granted leave for the fourth amended statement of claim, subject to certain conditions regarding further particulars and the close of pleadings date.

The court's final orders rescinded the discovery orders, granted leave for the receivers to apply for further discovery, allowed RFD to file its fourth amended statement of claim, and reserved costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established