Renton v Accident Compensation Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV-2015-485-000288 [2015] NZHC 1356

IN THE MATTER

of an appeal under s 72 of the District

Courts Act 1947

BETWEEN

NIGEL RENTON Appellant

AND

ACCIDENT COMPENSATION CORPORATION

First Respondent

S BISHARA Second Respondent

Hearing: 15 June 2015

Counsel:

A C Beck for Appellant
I G Hunt for First Respondent
A A Lewis for Second Respondent

Judgment:

15 June 2015

JUDGMENT OF COLLINS J

Summary of judgment

[1]      I  am  dismissing  Mr  Renton’s  appeal  from  a  decision  of  Judge  Powell delivered in the District Court on 2 April 2015.   In his decision, Judge Powell ordered Mr Renton to file by 8 May 2015 any further evidence he wished to rely upon in support of his appeal.   Judge Powell directed that if Mr Renton did not comply with this deadline, the appeal would be determined on the basis of the

evidence that was before the Court.

RENTON v ACCIDENT COMPENSATION CORPORATION [2015] NZHC 1356 [15 June 2015]

Context

[2]      On 22 April 1997 Mr Renton lodged a claim for cover with the Accident Compensation Corporation (ACC).   His claim alleged he had suffered a medical misadventure when he attended the Dunedin Hospital’s Accident and Emergency Department on either 27 February 1997, 2 March 1997 or 16 March 1997.   The essence of Mr Renton’s claim was that medical staff had failed to diagnose that he

suffered “florid papilledema”1 which led to Mr Renton suffering “optic atrophy”.2

[3]      On 29 May 1998, ACC declined Mr Renton’s claim.

[4]      Mr Renton sought a review of ACC’s decision.  That application prompted further inquiries by ACC’s medical misadventure unit.

[5]      On 4 September 2003, the reviewer confirmed ACC’s original decision that

Mr Renton had not suffered a medical misadventure.

[6]      On  21  September  2006,  Mr  Renton  filed  a  notice  of  appeal  alleging

Professor Bishara, a neurosurgeon, who examined Mr Renton in his clinic on 4

March 1997, had failed to provide the standard of care reasonably expected of a neurosurgeon.

[7]      On 15 November 2010, the District Court granted Mr Renton’s application to

bring a review out of time. That decision was made by consent.3

[8]      The review hearing commenced on 14 September 2011 but did not conclude because an issue arose about evidence that had not been properly disclosed.   The resumed hearing took place on 2 August 2012 and 21 December 2012.

[9]      A review decision was issued on 12 February 2013.  The reviewer concluded the evidence presented to him did not establish Professor Bishara had committed an error,  and  that  Mr  Renton  had  failed  to  establish  he  had  suffered  a  medical

misadventure.

1      Extensive swelling of the optic disc.

2      Degeneration of the optic nerve.

3      Renton v Accident Compensation Corporation [2010] NZACC 204.

[10]     In  reaching  his  decision  the  reviewer  noted  that  while  Mr  Renton  had adduced evidence from an ophthalmologist, the allegations were against Professor Bishara, who is a neurosurgeon.  Professor Bishara had provided an expert opinion from Mr Balakrishnan, a neurosurgeon. The reviewer said:4

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Renton v Accident Compensation Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 1356
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Nigel Renton appeals a decision of Judge Powell, delivered in the District Court on 2 April 2015, which dismissed his appeal against the Accident Compensation Corporation (ACC). The appeal concerns Renton's claim that he suffered a medical misadventure when attending the Dunedin Hospital's Accident and Emergency Department between 27 February 1997 and 16 March 1997. ACC declined Renton's claim, a decision confirmed by a reviewer. After an unsuccessful application to bring a review out of time, Renton filed a notice of appeal. In his appeal, Renton alleges Professor Bishara, the neurosurgeon who examined him on 4 March 1997, failed to provide the standard of care reasonably expected of a neurosurgeon. Judge Powell's decision dismissed Renton's appeal and precluded him from filing any further evidence. The appeal before the High Court concerns Judge Powell's directions that Renton must file any additional evidence by 8 May 2015 and that if he failed to do so, the appeal would be determined without further evidence.

The court must decide whether Judge Powell erred in dismissing Renton's appeal and precluding him from filing additional evidence. The court considered that Judge Powell's decision was correct and did not involve an error of law or principle. The court found that Renton had ample time to obtain any available evidence to support his appeal. Renton's delays in pursuing his appeal caused prejudice to Professor Bishara, who is now 86 years old and in failing health. The court concluded that Renton must decide whether to proceed with his appeal in the District Court relying only on the evidence that exists or abandon his appeal altogether.

The court dismissed Renton's appeal and upheld Judge Powell's decision. The court made no order as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.