Rattray v Palestine Children's Relief Fund

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA ŌTAUTAHI ROHE

CIV-2017-409-448

[2018] NZHC 466

UNDER the Wills Act 2007

IN THE MATTER OF

the estate of James Quinwallace

BETWEEN

ROSEMARY RAE RATTRAY

Plaintiff

AND

PALESTINE CHILDREN’S RELIEF FUND

Respondent

Hearing: On the papers

Appearances:

J M Stringer for the Plaintiff

No appearance by or for the Respondent

Judgment:

20 March 2018


JUDGMENT OF MANDER J


[1]                   The applicant, Ms Rosemary Rattray, seeks an order under the Wills Act 2007 (the Act) that a document signed by the deceased, Mr James Quinwallace, be validated as his will.1 Ms Rattray is named in the document as the executor and trustee of the will.

Background

[2]                   Mr Quinwallace was originally from Ireland, and throughout his life spent time in Australia and more latterly in New Zealand where he became a citizen. His routine over the years was to spend summers in New Zealand and winters in Australia.


1      Wills Act 2007, s 14.

RATTRAY v PALESTINE CHILDREN’S RELIEF FUND [2018] NZHC 466 [20 March 2018]

[3]                   Mr  Quinwallace  and  Ms  Rattray  were  old  family  friends,  and  when   Mr Quinwallace was in New Zealand he would stay at her residence in Christchurch. One such occasion was in early 2012 when Mr Quinwallace stayed for a number of weeks. He was unwell at the time and decided to make a new will before he returned to Australia. Mr Quinwallace asked Ms Rattray to assist him in preparing his will. She did this by using a template provided by the Public Trust.

[4]                   After the document was completed, Mr Quinwallace took it to a Justice of the Peace, a Mr Faitotonu, whom Ms Rattray knew, and lived in her street. On 4 May 2012, Mr Quinwallace attended on Mr Faitotonu and the document was signed and witnessed in a manner that they appear to have believed was sufficient to constitute a valid will.

[5]                   In early January 2017, Mr Quinwallace came to stay with Ms Rattray. He intended to remain at her home until he finished his latest writing before returning to Australia in April of that year. Unfortunately, on 6 March 2017, he unexpectedly died at Ms Rattray’s residence. Because of his sudden death, it was referred to the Coroner. However, a formal inquiry was never opened because the medical evidence indicated that Mr Quinwallace had died from natural causes.

[6]                   The document purporting to be Mr Quinwallace’s will is signed by him. However, the only witness to Mr Quinwallace’s signature is Mr Faitotonu, nor has Mr Quinwallace initialled the first page of the will.

[7]                   Mr Quinwallace is survived by his daughter, Ms Annette Lorraine Barnett, who was born in Ireland in 1967 and conceived during Mr Quinwallace’s marriage to his ex-spouse.  This marriage was dissolved in 1971.  Ms Rattray deposed that  both   Ms Barnett and Mr Quinwallace’s ex-spouse still live in Ireland, and, at the time of his death, Mr Quinwallace was estranged from his daughter.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rattray v Palestine Children's Relief Fund and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZHC 466
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Rattray v Palestine Children’s Relief Fund involved a dispute over the validity of a will signed by the deceased, Mr James Quinwallace, in the presence of a Justice of the Peace. The plaintiff, Ms Rosemary Rattray, sought an order under the Wills Act 2007 that the document be validated as Mr Quinwallace's will. Mr Quinwallace, who spent time in Australia and New Zealand, had asked Ms Rattray, a family friend, to assist him in preparing his will using a template from the Public Trust. The document was signed and witnessed by Mr Faitotonu, a Justice of the Peace who lived in Ms Rattray’s street. However, the will did not comply with the formal requirements of the Act, as it was witnessed by only one person and Mr Quinwallace did not initial the first page. The court was required to decide whether the document expressed Mr Quinwallace’s testamentary intentions despite the non-compliance with s 11 of the Act.

The court considered whether the document appeared to be a will, which it did, as it sought to dispose of Mr Quinwallace’s property upon his death. The court also noted that the document did not comply with s 11 and came into existence in New Zealand. The essential element before a non-complying document could be validated as a will was that the court must be satisfied that it expressed the deceased person’s testamentary intentions. The evidential burden required to satisfy this was not subject to a high threshold. The court found that the document reflected Mr Quinwallace’s testamentary intentions, as he had expressed to Ms Rattray both before and after its making. The will disposed of his estate and included bequests to Ms Rattray and to the Palestine Children’s Relief Fund, which was still in existence. The court was satisfied that the document signed by Mr Quinwallace on 4 May 2012 reflected his testamentary intentions, as articulated to Ms Rattray both before and after its making.

The court made an order declaring the document valid as Mr Quinwallace’s will notwithstanding non-compliance with s 11 of the Act and directed that the costs of and incidental to the proceeding be met by Mr Quinwallace’s estate. The court found that the document expressed Mr Quinwallace’s testamentary intentions, and it was better to give effect to those intentions than to give effect to any previous will. The court took a robust approach to the exercise, carefully considering whether the evidence put before it was such that it could be satisfied that the document reflected the testamentary intentions of the deceased.