IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE
CIV2023-404-471
[2023] NZHC 1554
BETWEEN MAHBOOBEH RAFIEE
Appellant
AND
ZENOBIA DARUWALLA
First Respondent
AND
AA INSURANCE LIMITED
Second Respondent
Hearing: 23 May 2023 Appearances:
Further Submissions completed:
The Appellant in person
J E McLennan for First and Second Respondents
26 May 2023
Judgment:
21 June 2023
JUDGMENT OF POWELL J
[Jurisdiction for Appeal]
This judgment was delivered by me on 21 June 2023 at 4.00 pm pursuant to
R 11.5 of the High Court Rules
…………………..
Registrar/Deputy Registrar
Solicitors:
M Rafiee – Self Represented
Holmden Horrocks Solicitors – Auckland
MAHBOOBEH RAFIEE v ZENOBIA DARUWALLA [2023] NZHC 1554 [21 June 2023]
[1] Mahboobeh Rafiee seeks to appeal, in this Court, a decision of Judge D J Clark.1 In his decision Judge Clark dismissed an appeal by Ms Rafiee against a decision of the Disputes Tribunal that had found her liable in the sum of $2,787.65 for vehicular repairs following a traffic accident.
[2] Ms Rafiee contends that the Disputes Tribunal did not consider all relevant evidence at the time it made its decision, and when she appealed she was not notified of the hearing date in the District Court which meant she did not appear before Judge Clark at the hearing of her appeal.
[3] At first call of Ms Rafiee’s appeal in this Court Mr McLennan, as counsel for the respondents, raised as a preliminary issue that there was no jurisdiction for this Court to entertain a second appeal, regardless of its merits. As a result, the respondents requested that the appeal be dismissed, and costs awarded on a category 1A basis.
[4] Following discussion with Mr McLennan and Ms Rafiee I therefore gave Ms Rafiee the opportunity to file submissions in response whereupon it was agreed I would determine the issue on the papers. My determination of the jurisdiction issue now follows.
Appeals of Disputes Tribunal Decisions
[5] As Mr McLennan pointed out the right to appeal a Disputes Tribunal decision is restricted. Section 23 of the Disputes Tribunal Act 1988 provides:
23 Decisions of Tribunal to be final
Every agreed settlement approved by the Tribunal under section 18(3), and every order made by the Tribunal under section 18(8) or section 46(2) or section 47(3)(b), and every variation of a term of an agreed settlement under section 47(3)(a), shall be final and binding on all parties to the proceedings in which that settlement is approved or the order or variation is made, as the case may require, and, except as provided in section 50, no appeal shall lie in respect of any such order or variation or approved settlement. (Emphasis added).
1 Rafiee v Daruwalla [2022] NZDC 10653.
[6] The exception to the finality of Disputes Tribunal decisions, s 50, provides for only a limited right of appeal as detailed in s 50(1):
(1)Any party to proceedings before the Tribunal may appeal to the District Court against an order made…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Rafiee v Daruwalla and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] NZHC 1554
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue in this case was whether the High Court had jurisdiction to entertain a second appeal from a decision of the Disputes Tribunal, which had already been appealed to the District Court. The respondents argued that the statutory framework for appeals from Disputes Tribunal decisions limits the right of appeal to a single appeal to the District Court. They relied on sections 23 and 50 of the Disputes Tribunal Act 1988, which provide that Disputes Tribunal decisions are final and binding, except for the limited right of appeal under section 50(1). The High Court, in considering the preliminary issue of jurisdiction, had to determine whether this statutory scheme precluded a further appeal to the High Court.
The High Court held that the statutory provisions in the Disputes Tribunal Act 1988, specifically sections 23 and 50, created a final right of appeal to the District Court and did not allow for further appeals to the High Court. The Court found that these provisions effectively limited appeals to a single appeal from the Disputes Tribunal to the District Court. This interpretation was consistent with previous judicial decisions, which held that the right of appeal under section 50(1) was a final right. Given this statutory framework, the Court concluded that it did not have jurisdiction to entertain Ms. Rafiee's appeal, and accordingly dismissed the appeal for want of jurisdiction.
In light of the dismissal, the Court ordered that costs be awarded to the respondents on a category 1A basis, meaning that the respondents could claim substantial costs for the time spent dealing with the appeal. Mr. McLennan, counsel for the respondents, was given until 30 June 2023 to file and serve a calculation of the costs claimed, with Ms. Rafiee having until 7 July 2023 to respond. The Court would then determine the issue of costs on the papers.