R v Williams HC Rotorua CRI-2009-063-005871

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND ROTORUA REGISTRY

CRI-2009-063-005871

THE QUEEN

v

GRAEME LEWIS WILLIAMS

Hearing:         22 July 2011

Appearances: A Gordon for the Crown

J Bergseng for the Accused

Judgment:      22 July 2011

SENTENCING NOTES OF WOOLFORD J

Solicitors:

Gordon & Pilditch, Crown Solicitors Office, PO Box 740, Rotorua

Bergseng & Co, Solicitors, PO Box 13282, Tauranga

R V WILLIAMS HC ROT CRI-2009-063-005871 22 July 2011

[1]      Graeme Lewis Williams, you are for sentence today on seven charges under the Misuse of Drugs Act 1975. The are:

(a)       Possession of methamphetamine for supply (representative); (b)        Supply of methamphetamine (representative); and

(c)       Manufacture of methamphetamine (representative), all of which carry a maximum penalty of life imprisonment;

(d)Supply of a precursor substance (ContacNT) (representative), which carries a maximum of 7 years imprisonment;

(e)       Possession  of  a  precursor  substance  (ContacNT),  which  carries  a maximum of 5 years imprisonment;

(f)       Conspiracy to supply methamphetamine, which carries a maximum of

14 years imprisonment; and

(g)Conspiracy  to  possess  a  precursor  substance  (ContacNT),  which carries a maximum of 5 years imprisonment.

Facts

[2]      The  details  of  your  offending  are  recorded  in  my judgment  determining disputed facts dated 29 June 2011.    In brief, you operated a significant methamphetamine dealing business  out  of  your address  in  Rotorua.    During an investigation codenamed Operation Atlas, the police kept your property under surveillance for 45 days between 17 September 2009 and 31 October 2009.  During that time 3582 visitors entered the address.  The average number of visitors per day was 79.   It seems clear that the vast majority were purchasing methamphetamine, either from you or your co-offender.

[3]      The amount of methamphetamine involved is summarised in the judgment (at

[75]):

(a)       On the possession for supply charges, the amounts totalled at least

338.8 grams;

(b)On two occasions there was manufacture of methamphetamine in an amount that alone would attract a starting point at the lower end of band 2 of R v Fatu;

(c)       On the conspiracy to supply charge, the amount totalled 84 grams.

[4]      The amount of ContacNT involved (a pseudoephedrine-based cold and flu remedy) is summarised in the judgment (at [77]):

(a)      On the supply and possession for supply charges, the amounts totalled at least 12 sets of ContacNT which were capable of yielding between

540 and 810 grams of methamphetamine;

(b)There was  evidence of  further substantial  quantities  in  relation  to further supply charges;

(c)      On the conspiracy to possess charge, the amounts totalled two sets which were capable of yielding between 90 and 135 grams of methamphetamine.

[5]      In addition, you acknowledge being party to the supply of 9 to 10 sets of

ContacNT, capable of yielding between 405 and 675 grams of methamphetamine.

[6]      In   my   judgment   delivered   today   addressing   the   Crown’s   forfeiture application, I have decided against making a forfeiture order in respect of the home from which you were dealing drugs.

[7]      In deciding what sentence should be imposed on you I have to take into account the established sentencing principles.1    In…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Williams HC Rotorua CRI-2009-063-005871 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 1327
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of R v Williams, heard in the High Court of New Zealand at Rotorua, involved Graeme Lewis Williams, who was sentenced on seven charges under the Misuse of Drugs Act 1975. The charges included possession of methamphetamine for supply, supply of methamphetamine, manufacture of methamphetamine, supply and possession of a precursor substance (ContacNT), and conspiracy to supply methamphetamine and possess a precursor substance. Each charge carried a significant maximum penalty, with some offences attracting a potential life sentence. The court had to determine an appropriate sentence considering the severity of the drug offences and the offender's culpability.

The primary legal issues centred on determining a suitable starting point for the sentence, considering the totality of the offending, and deciding on an appropriate minimum period of imprisonment. The Crown argued for a starting point of 12 to 14 years imprisonment, citing previous cases involving similar offences. Williams' counsel, on the other hand, suggested a starting point of around 11 to 11 and a half years, considering his role as a middleman in the drug supply chain. Additionally, the court had to weigh personal factors such as Williams' age, previous convictions, and remorse against the gravity of his criminal activities.

The court decided that Williams' role in the methamphetamine supply and manufacturing operation warranted a starting point of 13 years imprisonment for the lead charge of possession for supply. Considering the totality of his offending, including the ContacNT and conspiracy charges, the court imposed concurrent sentences on these charges. The court also found that a minimum period of imprisonment of 50 percent was necessary to hold Williams accountable and to serve the purposes of denunciation and deterrence. The final sentences ranged from 2 years to 10 years and 10 months, with the possession of methamphetamine for supply charge carrying the longest term and a 50 percent minimum imprisonment.

The final orders included the forfeiture of a 1992 Mitsubishi Pajero and $20,000 found in Williams' possession, which were not opposed by the defence. Williams was sentenced to concurrent terms of imprisonment and the forfeiture of his assets, reflecting the seriousness of his involvement in drug supply and manufacturing.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established