ORDER PROHIBITING PUBLICATION OF THE JUDGMENT AND ANY PART OF THE PROCEEDINGS (EXCEPT THE RESULT AS SET OUT IN [57]) IN NEWS MEDIA OR ON INTERNET OR OTHER PUBLICLY AVAILABLE DATABASE UNTIL FINAL DISPOSITION OF TRIAL. PUBLICATION IN LAW REPORT OR
LAW DIGEST PERMITTED.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND
CA451/06 [2007] NZCA 111
THE QUEEN
v
BERNARD TERENCE WHIMP
Hearing: 27 February 2007
Court: Robertson, Arnold and Ellen France JJ Counsel: P B McMenamin for Applicant
M F Laracy and K Laurenson for Crown
Judgment: 2 April 2007 at 11 am
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
A Leave to appeal is granted, but the appeal is dismissed.
BOrder prohibiting publication of the judgment and any part of the proceedings (except the result as set out in [57] in news media or on Internet or other publicly available database until final disposition of
trial. Publication in Law Report or Law Digest permitted.
R V WHIMP CA CA451/06 2 April 2007
REASONS OF THE COURT
(Given by Robertson J)
[1] This application for leave to appeal a pre-trial ruling of Judge Crosbie is grounded in an assessment of the scope of the power of a liquidator appointed under the Companies Act 1993 (the Act). Mr Whimp appeals against a decision rejecting his s 344A application challenging the legality of the actions of the Official Assignee (OA).
[2] The fundamental issues are whether what the OA did in connection with a company of which he was liquidator was lawful and if not whether evidence obtained should nonetheless be admitted on the basis of the R v Shaheed [2002]
2 NZLR 377 (CA) balancing test.
Background
[3] On 26 January 2004 the OA was appointed the Liquidator of Henry Holdings (Huntly) Ltd (HHL). On 15 March 2004 the OA was appointed Liquidator of Barberra Holdings Ltd, previously known as Capital Management Services Ltd (CMS) and referred to as such in this judgment.
[4] Both companies operated from offices at Level 8, 180 Manchester Street, Christchurch. There were a number of other companies and individuals which operated on this floor in fairly open plan facilities. There were spaces which appeared to be the base for various people, but the evidence disclosed physical intermingling of activities at the site and investigations suggest a good deal of intermingling at an operational level also.
[5] The premises were owned by McFarlane Buildings Limited and leased to
CMS. The evidence available was inadequate and unsatisfactory as to the status and
position of other entities or individuals, but for the purposes of the appeal it has been accepted that others were using the premises pursuant to undefined bare licences.
First visit
[6] On the morning of 16 March 2004, three employees of the OA – Joanne Coates, Paul Dennehy and Justin McCullough – went to the Manchester Street premises. They encountered various people including the applicant Mr Whimp, Angela Campbell (who had been a Director of HHL), Clinton Rains (a Director and shareholder of CMS), Alistair Scott-Booth, Tristram…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Whimp and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2007] NZCA 111
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court found that the OA, as liquidator, had the legal authority to access and retrieve documents relating to HHL and CMS from the premises, as the lease was in the name of CMS. However, the OA's actions went beyond what was lawful when they intruded into areas occupied by other companies and individuals. The searches were unlawful as they involved personal belongings and areas not obviously related to HHL and CMS. While the Court acknowledged that the OA's actions were not done in bad faith, they were too vigorous and intrusive, and there was insufficient regard for the rights of third parties. The Court concluded that the searches on both visits breached section 21 of the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990.
Applying the balancing test from R v Shaheed, the Court found that disallowing the evidence about the documents present on the premises on 16 March would be a disproportionate response to the breaches. The Court dismissed the appeal and confirmed the order under section 344A as to admissibility. The Court also made an order prohibiting publication of the judgment and any part of the proceedings (except the result) in the news media or on the internet or other publicly available database until final disposition of the trial, with publication in law reports or law digests permitted.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.