R v Watson HC Auckland CRI 2010-090-3663

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CRI 2010-090-3663

THE QUEEN

v

WALLY DAVID WATSON

Hearing:         4 October 2011

Counsel:         B D Tantrum for Crown

J L Cagney for Prisoner

Judgment:      4 October 2011

SENTENCE OF KEANE J

Solicitors:

Crown Solicitor, Auckland: brett.tantrum@meredithconnell.co.nz

Counsel:

J L Cagney: admin@khlawcentre.co.nz

R V WALLY DAVID WATSON HC AK CRI 2010-090-3663 4 October 2011

[1]      Wally David Watson, you appear for sentence, having been found guilty at trial of the manslaughter of Gavin Cuthbert. You caused his death by an unlawful act, driving dangerously, on 15 February 2010. You are for sentence also, having been found guilty at trial, of two other aggravating offences.

[2]      You drove with an excess breath alcohol. The level was 1001 micrograms of alcohol per litre of breath, just over two and a half times the legal limit. You drove while  indefinitely  disqualified.  Each  of  these  offences  is  a  third  or  subsequent offence, placing them in the aggravated category for the purpose of sentence.

Evidence at trial

[3]      On the evening before the accident in which Gavin Cuthbert died, you and he and another flatmate of the two of you went to the home of a woman friend and spent the evening drinking together. You travelled there in Gavin Cuthbert’s left hand drive Chevrolet Utility and you and he left the address together late in the evening, or in the early morning. Your third flatmate remained.

[4]      Who drove there, and more especially who drove away, was the issue at trial. Gavin Cuthbert had recently been indefinitely disqualified and you were indefinitely disqualified. Both of you clearly enough had been drinking very extensively that night. The evidence of your flatmate as to which of you was the driver was inconclusive. The wider evidence was that, after Gavin Cuthbert was disqualified the month before, he looked to others to drive and that you had driven him on occasions.

[5]      There was no real issue at the trial as to how the accident in which Mr Cuthbert died came about.   The evidence was clear that on Glenview Road, Glen Eden, Waitakere, which is the subject of a 50 kilometre per hour limit, the utility must have entered the gradual left hand bend at which the accident occurred at almost twice the permitted speed. It then yawed diagonally across the south bound lane and the extensive median strip into the opposing lane. It hit the far kerb, then the far sloping bank. It travelled a short way along the bank until it came to a low retaining wall. It then flipped over onto its canopy across the road facing inwards towards the bank at the point of pivot.

[6]      There was no issue either that soon after the accident happened Mr Cuthbert was found pinned under the right hand side of the utility on what was the passenger side, or that you were found sitting just beyond the driver's window unharmed. At the roadside and afterwards you maintained…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Watson HC Auckland CRI 2010-090-3663 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 1270
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of The Queen v Wally David Watson, Wally David Watson was convicted of manslaughter by dangerous driving and two aggravated offences: driving with an excess breath alcohol and driving while indefinitely disqualified. The defendant was found guilty of causing the death of Gavin Cuthbert by driving dangerously at an excessive speed. The court considered the defendant's long history of driving offences and alcohol abuse, which significantly contributed to the commission of the offence. The court was required to decide on the appropriate sentence for the manslaughter offence, the two aggravated offences, and whether a heightened minimum non-parole period was necessary to protect the community.

The court took into account the dangerous nature of the defendant's actions, his extensive criminal history, and the impact of his actions on the victim's family. The court decided on a starting point of six and a half years for the manslaughter offence, with an uplift of two years to reflect the defendant's appalling previous history of driving while disqualified and with excess breath alcohol. The court also considered the need for a heightened minimum non-parole period to protect the community, ultimately deciding on a four-year minimum non-parole period. The defendant was sentenced to eight and a half years imprisonment for the manslaughter offence, with a concurrent sentence of 18 months for the two aggravated offences. The court also disqualified the defendant indefinitely from holding or obtaining a driver's licence.

In conclusion, the court imposed an eight and a half-year sentence for the manslaughter offence, with a four-year minimum non-parole period, and a concurrent 18-month sentence for the two aggravated offences. The defendant was also disqualified indefinitely from holding or obtaining a driver's licence. The court's decision was based on the dangerous nature of the defendant's actions, his extensive criminal history, and the need to protect the community from further harm.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established