R v Vercoe HC Invercargill CRI 2010-025-3955

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND INVERCARGILL REGISTRY

CRI 2010-025-3955

QUEEN

v

MANAWA JAMES VERCOE

Hearing:         13 December 2010

Counsel:         M Sinclair for Crown

B Kilkelly for Prisoner

Sentencing:     13 December 2010

SENTENCING NOTES OF MILLER J

[1]      Mr Vercoe, you appear for sentence on 22 charges which I will tabulate in my  Sentencing  Notes. They  relate  mostly  to  the  sale  of  cannabis,  LSD  and

methamphetamine, but there are also two charges of burglary.

Offence

Section

Maximum

penalty

Possession  of  methamphetamine  for supply (x3)

Misuse of Drugs Act

1975,  ss  6(1)(c)  and
(f)

Life imprisonment

Possession of lysergic acid (LSD) for supply

Misuse of Drugs Act

1975,  ss  6(1)(c)  and
(f)

Life imprisonment

Offer  to  supply  lysergic  acid  (LSD)
(Representative)

Misuse of Drugs Act

1975, s 6(1)(c)

Life imprisonment

Produced cannabis oil

Misuse of Drugs Act

1975, s 6(1)(b)

14 years

imprisonment

R V VERCOE HC INV CRI 2010-025-3955  13 December 2010

Possession  of  cannabis  for  supply  to people over 18 (x10) (Representative)

Misuse of Drugs Act
1975, s 6(1)(d) and (f)

8 years imprisonment

Possession   of   cannabis   for   sale   to people over 18

Misuse of Drugs Act
1975, s 6(1)(e) and (f)

8 years imprisonment

Offer to sell cannabis to people over 18 (x3)

Misuse of Drugs Act
1975, s 6(1)(e)

8 years imprisonment

Burglary (x2)

Crimes  Act  1961,  s

231(1)(a)

10 years

imprisonment

[2]      I observe that the 10 charges of possession for supply to persons over 18 were charged under s 6(1)(f) of the Misuse of Drugs Act;  that is, they are charges of possession for sale.  But the informations speak of possession for supply to persons over 18, which is not an offence under s 6 at all.  It is an offence under s 7, and it attracts a maximum penalty of three months imprisonment.  That is clearly an error, as you have accepted today.   The summary of facts to which you have pleaded establishes clearly, mostly by reference to the texts and tick lists, that you were dealing throughout.  With your consent I will treat the 10 charges of possession for supply as possession for sale;  in effect there are 11 charges of that nature.

[3]      The facts are that you and your partner were targeted in a police operation which began on 7 May.  Text messages were intercepted during specified periods in May, July and August.  They establish that you were actively dealing in cannabis on a daily basis.  In July you sent a text indicating that you were cooking cannabis oil.  I note that is not referred to in the summary of facts, but you accept that those are the facts relating to your guilty plea to that charge.  Between 7 May and 11 August you were recorded as having 110 separate conversations with people relating to selling cannabis, usually in quantities between one tin and an ounce.

[4]      On 7 August you bought a quantity of LSD tabs which you then offered to sell to nine unidentified…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Vercoe HC Invercargill CRI 2010-025-3955 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NZHC 2319
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Manawa James Vercoe was convicted of 22 charges including drug supply and possession, and two counts of burglary. The High Court of New Zealand, Invercargill Registry, presided over the sentencing of Vercoe on 13 December 2010. The court had to decide on the appropriate penalties for the drug and burglary offences, taking into consideration Vercoe's criminal history, his drug addiction, and his guilty pleas. The court also had to determine whether the cumulative sentences for the drug and burglary offences would be proportionate to the overall offending.

The court considered Vercoe's extensive criminal history, including 41 convictions for burglary, and his two previous drug convictions. The court acknowledged Vercoe's drug addiction and dysfunctional upbringing but emphasised that the motivation for the offending was commercial. The court calculated cumulative sentences for the drug offences as one group, and the burglaries as a second group, taking into account the more extensive cannabis offending as the lead offences. The court also considered comparable cases to determine the appropriate starting points for the drug and burglary offences. The court imposed a six-month uplift for Vercoe's release conditions at the time of the offending and a 30 per cent discount for his guilty pleas. The court concluded that the overall sentence of four years imprisonment was appropriate, considering the totality of the offending.

Vercoe was sentenced to four years imprisonment, with two years and six months for the cannabis offences, 18 months for the burglaries, and two years for the possession of methamphetamine and LSD for supply and the offer to supply LSD. The court also ordered the return of the stolen property and the destruction of the drugs exhibits, including the cellphone.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established